Wednesday Jun 02, 2010

WANTED: Blood Sisters

Posted at 03:03PM Jun 02, 2010 by The Little Liar in General


We’ve been theorizing about the Pretty Little Liars since Book One...now we’re just a few short days away from solving the mysteries of the series! Have you got your theories ready? Let's start with the DiLaurentis/Hastings family tree...


At the end of Heartless, Spencer, in an attempt to put the pieces together about her picture-perfect family, uncovered a forbidden love...between her father and Jessica DiLaurentis. As if that wasn’t shocking enough, additional evidence convinced Spencer that Ali was her half sister, and that Mrs. Hastings—motivated by jealousy and rage—may have been involved in Ali’s murder.


"Spencer turned to her mother. "How could you have hurt her? She was my sister. And, Dad, how could you cover it up when she was your daughter?"" ~Heartless, p. 245


Mrs. Hastings claims that she had nothing to do with Ali's death, but Spencer’s head is still reeling from her dad’s affair and the newsflash that Ali — her friend and nemesis — was also her half sister. How does the news that Ali was Spencer’s sister impact your theory about who killed Alison? How do you think it will impact what happens to Spencer in Wanted?

Comments[41]

« A Warning from A | Main | The Game »
Join the Clique Fan Club
Comments:

I have a few theories on who killed Alison. The news will impact on what happens to spencer in wanted because she'l be more curious and find out more secrets.

Posted by Shannon on June 02, 2010 at 04:15 PM EDT #

Second comment...WOOHOO....ok first thing i wanna say, this book isn't obvious. I don't think Spencer's mom is the killer. I want to say something that probably gives something away, but it impacts Spencer.

Posted by Nicki on June 02, 2010 at 04:51 PM EDT #

Why are the girls dirty in the ad? Did they kill Ali and burry her themselves?

Posted by Justine on June 02, 2010 at 05:16 PM EDT #

Did Sara come up with never trust a pretty girl with an ugly secret, or did the writers of the show?

Posted by Justine on June 02, 2010 at 05:21 PM EDT #

@Justine : The girls are covered in dirt because it's like the girls are covered in their own lies that or because Ali was found there :P I like my first theory better.

Posted by Rosalie on June 02, 2010 at 05:29 PM EDT #

@Rosalie : I like your first theory too , "The girls are covered in dirt because it's like the girls are covered in their own lies" dayyyumm , genious! :) AND CAN SOMEONE PLEASE PUT SPOILER AND TELL ME WHY THEY FEEL BAD FOR ONE OF THE GIRLS?!?!?!. Someone said that they feel bad for _ _ _ _ _ and i reaaaally want to know who that is!!!!!!!! If anyone has any spoilers pleasssse please tell me :)

Posted by Izzy on June 02, 2010 at 06:12 PM EDT #

OK Izzy i'll tell you who it is, so people THIS IS A SPOILER DO NOT READ IF YOU DO NOT WANT TO KNOW AND IF YOU HAVEN'T READ HEARTLESS!! so the person put they feel bad for _ _ _ _ _, the blanks is Jenna!!

Posted by Jane on June 02, 2010 at 06:51 PM EDT #

"Never Trust A Pretty Girl With An Ugly Secret" is on the cover of the first book.

Posted by me on June 02, 2010 at 06:53 PM EDT #

As for the dirt, what i think is that, the dirt represents all their secrets and like their secrets are being dug up, thats why they're all covered in dirt, cause like Alison held all their secrets and she was dug up, i don't know if that makes sense, but that's what i think...

Posted by diana on June 02, 2010 at 06:55 PM EDT #

LMAO i seriously though Emily was Spencer and Spencer was Emily...the the roll-over thingie i found out who is who between them...

Posted by Nicki on June 02, 2010 at 07:26 PM EDT #

@Izzy - we haven't talked in a while on here but before Heartless came out we always talked about our theories!! What do you think happened to Ali??

Posted by Emily <33 on June 02, 2010 at 07:34 PM EDT #

@Justine - Sara came up with it. Hence the fact that its on the cover of the first book.

Posted by alyssa on June 02, 2010 at 08:38 PM EDT #

I'm pretty sure that the dude they said killed Ali really didn't. I think it was Melissa! She absolutely HATES Ali for stealing Ian!

Posted by Alexa on June 03, 2010 at 10:11 AM EDT #

Well me and my cousin are reading the books together....we both agree that Billy Ford isn't the killer. And doesn't all suspects need alibi's? I mean, they said it was him by pictures as proof, but how do we know if it really is him? I think he was set upped. With the theory as Ali and Spencer...i don't think they are related...probably Ali and Melissa...and also, the theory as Ali is Courtney....i think it's true...that's how i think it impacts Spencer when she finds out there Ali is alive and Leah is the one dead...speaking of which, what does she has to do with anything?

Posted by Brittany on June 03, 2010 at 05:11 PM EDT #

@Brittany....i guess so....but with people saying Courtney is Ali's twin...it's probably is true..

Posted by Nicki on June 03, 2010 at 09:09 PM EDT #

wowww theres only acouple days till the last book comes out.... its sad i remmeber when i found the series and fell in love with them:( but im happy to find eveything outttt! all that i know is that billy ford is not kill her and its all a setup(thats my opinion)

Posted by KASSIDY on June 03, 2010 at 09:44 PM EDT #

helloooo

Posted by Holly on June 04, 2010 at 02:51 PM EDT #

WHOS COURTNEY!?!?.......i forget....is she like in wanted or somthin...or have i just been stupid and forgot her.

Posted by me on June 04, 2010 at 02:54 PM EDT #

Yeah, i dont really remember who Courtney is or why she may be Ali!!!! Can someone explain....?

Posted by Kilee on June 04, 2010 at 05:36 PM EDT #

Courtney was Iris's old friend at the perserve she was her roomate until she left and Hanna came and I'm guessing Courtney told Iris alot about her family and stuff. Its weird how Hanna like new about Spencers half sister but doesnt really no its Spencers half sister.

Posted by LOVE-life on June 05, 2010 at 11:44 AM EDT #

kso;; since there's a possibilty that spencer &ali are half-sisters, then maybee..the person who went after ali had something against spencer too, so it'll impact spencer because she'll be the target next? which is why its sooo hard to figure who A is because A isn't just involved with one of the pretty little liars, but ALL of them. so A can't be mellissa because she's only concerned with spencer..ahhh, it's so fun thinking of theories! &&izzy you were right, before heartless came out all we did on here was dream up theories lolz (:

Posted by urma blastt(: on June 06, 2010 at 11:37 AM EDT #

my theory is that billy raped ali. then ali killed herself. i dont know how ian jeremy and darren are involved. and could courtney just have been a code name for ali?

Posted by jennyyy on June 07, 2010 at 03:52 PM EDT #

@Izzy thanks for the response it's really nice of you to say but i can't take all the credit my friend thought of it when I sent her the show poster by email :P

Posted by Rosalie on June 07, 2010 at 05:50 PM EDT #

i think that Courntey is alison. Because when Hana was at the Preserve Iris drew a pic of Ali but it was really Courtney and Iris said that Courtney was manipulative like ai and suffered from slight depression like alis mom hinted at AND iris said she got out in nov. when the notes started.

Posted by Sammie on June 07, 2010 at 08:10 PM EDT #

@Jenny I AGREE WITH YOU soo much. thats the best i think courtney is ali to and i agree because ali killed ali i get it. good job! :)

Posted by Sally on June 07, 2010 at 08:14 PM EDT #

I already finished this book...the lady at Books A Million sold it early and I bought it on the 6th instead of thee 8th! IT WAS SOO GOOD! You have to read in between the lines, throughout this book because it is a little bit confusing, since there are some REALLY BIG TWISTS THAT YOU NEVER SEE COMING!

Posted by ashlyn on June 07, 2010 at 10:37 PM EDT #

OH MY GOSH. I JUST FINISHED THIS BOOK. The lady at Books-A-Million sold it 3 days early, so I already read it. This book is not easy to understand at some points and is really confusing,, but really good! Just read between the lines, and remeber (SPOLIER BELOW-STOP IF YOU DONT WANT TO KNOW) ********************************* Remember when Aria went to see the psychic, and she said "Ali killed Ali," well she was right, Ali was never the girl the 4 girls were friends with, it was always her twin sister Courtney, and Ali killed Courtney, and then tried killing Aria, Hannah, Spencer, and Emily...but killed herself in the fire she set.

Posted by kristine on June 07, 2010 at 10:42 PM EDT #

Why would Courtney say she was Ali? Why would Ali want to kill Spencer, Hannah, Aria, and Emily? If Ali killed herself in the fire that she set, where did she go if she COULD NOT move since she was dead? So, all the killers are dead? What happens to Leah and Wilden?

Posted by madeleine on June 08, 2010 at 01:05 AM EDT #

SPOILER ALERT!!!!! oh, em, gee. i absolutely LOVED "Wanted" i woke up and ten minutes later i made my brother drive to me Barnes &Noble to buy the book, &i just finished reading it...it was sooo good. it explained EVERYTHING. i can't believe it was ALI behind everything! And i can't believe the whole "Ali killed Ali" thing, even though it totally made sense..it was just a shock, the whole Courtney and Ali thing! i feel so bad for the girls, they were soooo fooled for like, every since they talked with Courtney-as-Ali. but at least everything worked out for them. Hanna's mom is no-nonsense when she came back lolz! im happy for Spencer and Aria, i'm glad how it worked out. &&Emily..idk bout her, i think she's scarred. but whoa the real Ali was an effin b**ch, a smart one but still. lolz i kinda feel bad for Courtney too, just cuz Ali had that much of affect on her..but this was a great ending, &i love the pretty little liars!(:

Posted by urma blastt(: on June 08, 2010 at 01:52 PM EDT #

I LOVE PRETTY LITTLE LIARS. I hate how they were never friends with Ali, but a psycho Courney. Not to mention we dont have a legit end!

Posted by Ali on June 08, 2010 at 05:17 PM EDT #

omg i just got done with wanted cant belive it! pplz if u havent read wanted yet HURRY UP becuz it wuz SOOOOOOOOOO worth the wait :)

Posted by jaela berr on June 08, 2010 at 05:40 PM EDT #

who is jenna? and what is her purpose and role in the story?

Posted by laura on June 09, 2010 at 12:35 AM EDT #

jenna was a girl that the fake Ali (really Courtney) blinded. before she was blinded, she had met Ali's twin, and she was suspicious of the switching that happened. &&since she was suspicious of the truth...Ali took care of her. :(

Posted by urma blastt(: on June 09, 2010 at 12:58 AM EDT #

Dude everyone is talking about how Courtney is the crazy one but Ali seems pretty crazy to me...

Posted by PrettyLittleObsessed on June 09, 2010 at 10:24 PM EDT #

So was ali ever really friends with any of them an if she wasn't then why did she want to kill them ? Oh an why did she kill courtney?

Posted by Brianna on June 10, 2010 at 10:51 PM EDT #

I think Mellisa has SOMETHING to do with the whole thing! She's hiding something for sure!

Posted by Nakia on June 15, 2010 at 03:27 PM EDT #

@Brianna: she WASN'T friends with them. her twin Courtney pretended to be her when they came looking for the flag &&they sent Ali away thinking she was Courtney. So Courtney stayed and pretended to be Ali (tada!) &&she was the one who befriended the girls..NOTT the real Ali. so when Ali came back for that one night she was so angry at her sister she killed her (harsh much)...&then she wanted to kill the other girls because she had it set in her mind that they ruined her life.

Posted by urma blastt(: on June 17, 2010 at 09:19 PM EDT #

i finished the book last night. everything makes sense! i cant believe A actually told us who killed ali or courtney. ali killed ali. i totally forgot about that note because the only thing that came to my head that ali killed herself, but that wouldnt make sense. i wish there could be a happy ending with ali...but she killed some people so that frendship would be crazy. in the end, ali and courtney were insane. they were the pychos, not hanna :P PLUS i think hannas dad should divorce isabelle, kates a brat.

Posted by hannah on July 03, 2010 at 11:48 AM EDT #

how the heck is the amish girlfriend or wilden fit in with ANYTHING?

Posted by hannah on July 03, 2010 at 11:50 AM EDT #

@hannah: I think it was just to throw you (and the girls) off. It was to make it look like Wilden was guilty (and it seemed to work, considering Emily believed it. Heck, I did too! Haha)... So that's where the whole amish girfriend disappearing thing came in. Ali didn't want anyone to suspect anything, so she made it look like others did it. Like Wilden...and Ian...and Spencer's mom...and Melissa...and Billy...and everyone else.

Posted by Sarah on July 30, 2010 at 02:56 PM EDT #

Courtney is allis twin sister that lived in. mental home Courtney and Ali trade places a Courtney is the one killed the night of the sleepover

Posted by jess y on August 27, 2010 at 12:17 AM EDT #

Post a Comment:
  • HTML Syntax: NOT allowed