Monday Oct 20, 2008

The most Wicked of them all…

Posted at 02:33PM Oct 20, 2008 by The Little Liar in General


LIVE chat with Sara Shepard right here on
Tuesday, November 25 at 8PM EST!

Look for this icon in the comments:

Sara's Icon


Spencer, Hanna, Aria, and Emily think they finally know what happened the night their best friend Ali died. But nothing is ever as it seems in Rosewood. Everyone’s got secrets…especially the pretty little liars.

If you're a true fan, you know enough of the girls' secrets to bury them. But which little liar's secrets are the deepest and darkest of them all? You tell us!

Comments[179]

« The Liars have a new... | Main | Countdown to WICKED.... »
Join the Clique Fan Club
Comments:

first!

Posted by Jane on October 20, 2008 at 04:30 PM EDT #

most of them have been revealed. but the darkest one was definitely when they thought that they blinded jenna.

Posted by Becca on October 20, 2008 at 04:42 PM EDT #

I kinda think that the deepest sercret that they all shared was how much they confined in Alie when they had only known her for a year or so. I mean why would Hannah Tell Ali something but not tell all her other friends (even the ones shes known for like way more than a year) I just think tyhat is a lillte wierd and may turn into something in one of the next books.

Posted by U kno u Luv Anna on October 20, 2008 at 05:20 PM EDT #

I think that the dirtiest secret is definetly Emily's! I mean come on, all of us have kept secrets from our parents but hers was as dirty as it gets and could have ruined her life! It was a stroke of good luck that she didn't have to stay in Iowa. But thinking that they blinded Jenna was also a huge one two.

Posted by Meaghan on October 20, 2008 at 06:20 PM EDT #

okay to that U kno u Luv Anna chick dude if you read the book it tells you 1 she has known for four years.... and also number two she didn't tell Ali. Ali walked in while she was throwing up... now to my own thing i honestly think that melissa is A and one of the pretty little liars killed ali cause in the first book spencer stormed out of the barn after ali when they had there fight after that she was never seen again... so i think spencer probally did it

Posted by Alexis on October 20, 2008 at 06:21 PM EDT #

Spencer is SO not A. In the last book, it confirms it.

Posted by Meaghan on October 20, 2008 at 06:25 PM EDT #

I love the secert that Spence killed Ali or thats what it seems i CAN NOT WAIT for the 5th book im on the 4th and the other 3 only took me 3 days to read!!!!!!!!!!! lyl Mwah ~S

Posted by Sara on October 20, 2008 at 06:58 PM EDT #

i know who A is n u wont believe it i was literally scared when i finished finding out whop it was spencer nor melissa killed ali none of the pretty little liars are A and dont trust the new pretty little liar in the last book-everthing is not always what it seems i wish i could tell you but i cant oh n heres a hint to who it is - Mwah!!+kisses

Posted by miyah on October 20, 2008 at 08:46 PM EDT #

I think it is definetly that they shared so much to alli and maybe it is good she is gone i mean she was lying to her bffs and keeping secrets and the killer is so easy to find out but maybe it is deeper i mean in the forth book the jenna thing got deeper!!! but maybe that is what the new a wants us to think the last a is dead and she is not gone well A is not gone soooo.....

Posted by sarah on October 20, 2008 at 09:22 PM EDT #

Do you guys think Ali is still alive?? I couldn't tell in the 4th book. I think the dirtiest secret would have to be Aria. Her secret ruined her life for a little while and her and ezra is a huge secret!

Posted by Niina on October 20, 2008 at 09:28 PM EDT #

hmm well i think that almost blind someone is the biggest so far but therre are probly more that we dont know about so who is your giz's fav character?

Posted by kortnee on October 21, 2008 at 03:38 PM EDT #

i think that mona ali's killer and A...but mellissa is very suspicious too...hmm.

Posted by bridgette on October 21, 2008 at 04:02 PM EDT #

OMG I love these books, I read all 4 of them! The author is an AMAZING writer. I couldn't believe who A was once I found out! The deepest and darkest secret was either Aria with Ezra, or ALI blinding Jenna!

Posted by i love this bookkk on October 21, 2008 at 04:14 PM EDT #

Heyy! I just got done with the 4th book and I am sooo excited that they are comiong out with wicked! I'm just confused did they ever really find out if Ian was ali's Killer? BTW! The Gossip Girl's books are good too!

Posted by Katie on October 21, 2008 at 04:58 PM EDT #

For sure the darkest secret was that Ali blinded Jena, Aria's secret comes in second, Emily's third, Spencer's fourth, and Hanna's fifth (her's wasn't bad). Can't wait for the next book to come out, luv the cover! :)

Posted by Marisol on October 21, 2008 at 05:06 PM EDT #

Ali had the deepest secrets, obviously. she had hers, AND everyone else's!

Posted by josia liana on October 21, 2008 at 06:35 PM EDT #

I thinkk Ali's secrets were deffinatly the best. She knew more than anyonne else about all the girls. But now shes deadd.

Posted by Alexxx(: on October 21, 2008 at 08:09 PM EDT #

What is Ali's secret? I am horrible at reading context clues if that's where it is.

Posted by Danielle on October 22, 2008 at 04:52 PM EDT #

i think the darkest secret was finding out that ali and jenna had planned to set off the firecracker to get back at toby..psh who knew?? and i know when i first started reading pretty little liars that last person i thought was "a" was monaa. !!!! whoaa and spencer always in trouble with rents and her sister ..dat girl had a lot of dirty sceretss

Posted by yeri on October 22, 2008 at 07:04 PM EDT #

god.. i knew it was mona all along... everyone kept saying is was jenna.. anyhoo... can't wait for the 5th book. and i definitely think that spencer has the dirtiest secrets. But jenna's secret was pretty bad too. I heard they were either making a movie out of the series or a television show. Don't believe everything you hear though. ;) kisses! -C

Posted by coco on October 22, 2008 at 08:03 PM EDT #

omgosh! i finished the 4th not to long ago, and my friends are somewhere in the middle. we talk about the books a lot and try not to give away secrets about whats coming up, even tho we have. i can not wait for the next ones! these books are amazing... im taking a guess that for the next ones, some one else who hates the 4 finds Ali's diary again (after who A was in the first) and also ruins their lives even more, after when they thought it was all over! omg i can't wait! xoxo

Posted by Kaitlyn on October 22, 2008 at 08:31 PM EDT #

yo yo yo man i cnt wait this anymore im bout 2 pull my hair out. spencer has the deepest secret of all

Posted by luv 2 gossip on October 23, 2008 at 03:34 PM EDT #

i think Ali has the deepest serect of all bc if u read that dairy she knows what s up with EVERYONE her bro, ian, spencer, emily, aria, and hanna. the other one is ian he must have a lot of serects bc he actually kill somone and he hid if for........ like 4 years ugh well thats what i think

Posted by Rebecca on October 24, 2008 at 11:00 AM EDT #

does anyone else think ali has a twin?? like seriously ...the flash backs and dream sequences MEAN something in the 4th book it always went back to when they were at Ali's on the back porch .. they note that Ali isnt wearing the same shirt anymore ... in Hannah's dream Ali tells her to shut up that shes fine ... and Jenna states that Ali had sibling problems as well. However, i dont think it's with her brother ...the scene where Emily sees him on the news he says that he is not staying with his family because they are "screwed up" or messed up something along those lines.... I read the 4th book when it first came out ...so its been awhile but there were a lot of other things that pointed to that scenario ... the only thing that doesnt make sense is why would they hide a twin?? u kno. Maybe Ali wanted Ian to kill her twin so she'd stay out of the way ..who knows

Posted by Rebekah on October 24, 2008 at 02:03 PM EDT #

spencer and Aria's secrets are the most interesting i think... spencer is my favorite character ... but the Biggest i think is ALi's (whether she is dead OR alive) when it is revealed.

Posted by Rebekah .. again on October 24, 2008 at 02:08 PM EDT #

sorry im at work and im bored and i keep thinking of new things to say ... In the beginning I thought A and or Ali's killer was either Mona or Officer Warren?? is that his name?? the one that Hannas's mom was dating ..anyways ..because it said that Ali was seeing an older guy ...I was right about my Mona hunch .. and at the end of the 4th book with them arresting Ian ... there was no sense of resolution to me ..almost as if hes NOT the real killer...I still have a feeling about Warren .. it says he was quite the partier in HS and suddenly decides to be a cop IN Rosewood?? Kinda sounds like someone wants to be in the inner circle when something goes down.

Posted by Rebekah ... yet again on October 24, 2008 at 02:14 PM EDT #

i dont really know what secrets i like the best. they're all sooo good! i LOVELOVELOVE the pretty little liars books...they're the best books i've ever read! I cant wait 'till wicked comes out and i'm getting it the day it does. i love these books and i hope sara shepard keeps making them!

Posted by Lauren on October 24, 2008 at 06:00 PM EDT #

the most interesting secret is probably when they blinded jenna and spencer w/ her sisters boyfriends-but im only up to book 3 so i dunno who a is yet (i want no spoilers lolz) anywho i think spencer has the most to hide for some reason she seems like mysterious and she was the last person 2 see ali before she died

Posted by Briana on October 24, 2008 at 06:29 PM EDT #

I so think Ali is alive! I dont care what it says, this is soo confusing! :) The whole time we believed that Melissa or Spencer killed her, and I tohught Spencer was A, and Melissa killed Ali! But I was really wrong, :P I think Ali was hiding a twin all along too! That is so true! Becuase theres an Ali look alike!

Posted by Jenna on October 24, 2008 at 07:27 PM EDT #

the filthiest secret was jenna's blindedness. ill tll you why i think that. because it brings so much gilt to them how would you feel if you thought you blinded some1 then find out that it was all a lie?

Posted by Pretty Little Mandy on October 24, 2008 at 10:47 PM EDT #

I still think Ali is alive, too! The twin thing is totally plausable. That would be a HUGE secret. I just somehow don't think Ali is REALLY gone. Plus, Ian honestly didn't seem very guilty of the crime, like it seemed as if he were falsely accused. Hmmm. There's much more of a story to continue. [:

Posted by AlyciaCHAOS on October 25, 2008 at 12:14 AM EDT #

There are so many deep secrets in Pretty Little Liars which is one of the reasons why I love it! The deepest secret in the story is either how mona was "A". But in my opinion that was gross and so creepy how she stalked them. She really needed to get a life! Then the Jenna thing was unbelievable! I couldn't believe that she planned to try to kill her brother. But then again, her brother was a tad creepy. But I swear I LOVE this book series! And of course, whatever happens next will defiantly be Wicked! :) Peace yall!

Posted by kim on October 25, 2008 at 10:26 AM EDT #

i loveee these bookss<3 i think ali is deffinitaly alive and when i was just reading the comments i just strated thinking about it ali deffinalty has a twin or something it makes perfect sense. i thin the deepest secreat is deff ali's kaybyee ttyn

Posted by brianna on October 25, 2008 at 07:14 PM EDT #

i think that now that spencer knows that she has those blackouts, she'll start remembering more tof what really happened while she was friends with ali! ali;s secrets are definatly the most important like she was going out with ian and i also think there are more secrets of hers they will learn in the next book cant wait for book #5!!!!!!!!

Posted by megan on October 25, 2008 at 08:38 PM EDT #

Well, I know an Ali secret, she was going out with Ian and Ian killed her for the flag piece, which is why she's dead.

Posted by Virginia on October 26, 2008 at 08:56 AM EDT #

I think the biggest secret was the one Jenna knew about Mona seeing the whole "Jenna Thing" happen.

Posted by Melanie on October 26, 2008 at 03:00 PM EDT #

i think the deepest secret is the the "jena thing" oh and i love this books each of the books only took me one day to read!!!

Posted by gabby on October 26, 2008 at 05:26 PM EDT #

I love these books!!! I can't wait until Wicked comes out!!!! These books keep you on the edge of your seat, your eyes glued to the pages.

Posted by Claire on October 26, 2008 at 07:56 PM EDT #

i think the biggest secret was that Ali and Jenna planned the whole Jenna Thing. I don't think Ian killed Ali and a new A? Don't you think Aria, Hanna, Spencer, and Emily have learned enough by now to go straight to the police if they got a text like that. Why would they want to go through the whole thing again?

Posted by Alicia on October 26, 2008 at 09:52 PM EDT #

I think the biggest secret was the Jenna secret becaue of how awful it was. Blinding a girl is a lot worse than being a lesbian or bulimic or hooking up with a teacher or you rsisters boyfriend!

Posted by Brittany Bop on October 27, 2008 at 11:26 AM EDT #

I think all the girl's secrets were huge. But I can't say which is the biggest.

Posted by Nonie on October 27, 2008 at 04:21 PM EDT #

OMG!! i'm SOOO excited for this book to come OUT!!! i love this series!!! idk why, but its absolute genius!!! :))))))))))

Posted by Sam on October 27, 2008 at 05:15 PM EDT #

i think the deepest secret was mona being a! but the pretty little liars secrets are all shockin, the most shocking would hav to be emily's because she is supposed 2 be rosewood's good girl nd thts not part of the plan....is it?

Posted by xnikkix3 on October 27, 2008 at 06:04 PM EDT #

I think the deepest secret has to be Ali's. Her secrets have had more affect on the girls than their own.

Posted by chloe on October 27, 2008 at 06:47 PM EDT #

(Alison is my real name!) I totally think Ali didn't die. I think she had a twin that SHE pushed into the ditch, and put her one-of-a-kind tiffany ring on her finger. I swear, Ali is alive, and she's watching.....

Posted by Alison..for real on October 27, 2008 at 10:02 PM EDT #

Ian didn't do it. As far as we know his only motive was to keep his and Ali's relationship a secret from Melissa ... and obviously .. play boy really doesnt care what anyone thinks ...he does what he pleases. If he killed Ali to keep his secret from Melissa ...why didnt they stay together after High School .. they broke up almost immediatly afterwards. Also, Jenna knows more about Ali's sybling problem then she let on ...I doubt it was the same situation Jenna was in ... im going with Ali has a twin. It makes sense.

Posted by Rebekah on October 28, 2008 at 11:04 AM EDT #

But remember when in the begging of the 4th book the girls said that ali brother had mood swings, That might have a big affect on things also he saud that his family had problems, maybe he has problems and his family is normal but act diiferent (well to him)

Posted by U Kno U Luv Anya on October 28, 2008 at 07:30 PM EDT #

heyy

Posted by Sara on October 28, 2008 at 09:15 PM EDT #

Thats true ... I guess we will all see in a lil less that a month. = ]

Posted by Rebekah on October 29, 2008 at 01:19 PM EDT #

of course its da jenna thang i mean dey blinded da girl but wat toby did was horible(he desirved wat he got btw)n y wait so long not 2 tell anybodi but ders emily&maya thang i mean whoa gul talk about shakin thangs up watevea maks u happi gul but im sooooooo loking 4ward to da 5 book

Posted by tia on October 29, 2008 at 06:18 PM EDT #

I think that Ali might have a twin, cause i am almost positive she is still alive. when jenna said that ali had sibling problems 2, I had no idea what she meant. what do you guys think?

Posted by NINa on October 29, 2008 at 09:19 PM EDT #

i dont know me and my friend came up with this: we think that bones and a ring are easy to fake so we are pretty sure ali is stil alive

Posted by madeline on October 29, 2008 at 10:14 PM EDT #

DO NOT READ IF YOU HAVE NOT FINISHED THE SERIES SO FAR...................... i think ali's secret is the biggest....because you know when in the 4th one how aria goes back to the college to pick up her phone and jenna's there and she's like oh me and ali planned the "jenna thing" but well she didn't call it that and she said that what happened between jenna and toby isn't as bad as what happened with ali and her brothers jason....................i don't know thats just a thought!

Posted by christina on October 30, 2008 at 06:53 AM EDT #

I LOVE THE 1st FEW CHAPTERS OF THE 1st BOOK "Pretty Little Liars!" I WISH I WAS ABLE TO READ THER REST!!!!!

Posted by cheese1756 on October 30, 2008 at 02:25 PM EDT #

I finished the fist book and I'm about to start on Flawless. These books are amazing and the are the best. I can't stop reading them. They should totally make a movies about these books. I can't stop reading.What's up with this Jenna Thing. Isn't wierd how they found Ali but they are getting e-mails from A {maybe Ali told someone else eveything}.AMAZING books!!Genius!

Posted by maria on October 30, 2008 at 04:32 PM EDT #

does anyone know if ezra is going to come back in PLL 5?

Posted by laura on October 30, 2008 at 05:01 PM EDT #

OMG I CANNOT ABSOLUTELY NOT WAIT 4 BOOK 5!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by omgomgomgomg on October 30, 2008 at 05:21 PM EDT #

***Dont Read If U DIDNT Finish Da Series SO Far******* OMGGGosh I Just Remembered Dat Ezra left i Wonder if her cums buck. Then Member At the very end wen 1 of them(i forgot who) but dey was @ da court house and she seen sumbody looking out a car tinted car widow and she thought it was Ali but dey drove off!!!!! Dat part creeped my out but i LOVE Diss book!!!!! I Cant wait till November The 25! I Wonder is Ali Cumz Bak Or If Ian Breaks Out Of Jail And Hates The Girls uhuuuuummm IDK We Will Have 2 see!!!!!

Posted by Nea-ya on October 30, 2008 at 07:28 PM EDT #

holy s***t i can't wait!!!!!

Posted by Pretty Little Mandy on October 30, 2008 at 09:17 PM EDT #

I would say that the darkest seceret. Of all would be the one about Emily.I mean we all have secrets held from our parents but I mean one that big is just horrible and dirty.well I can't freiken wait till the book comes out!!

Posted by Sarah on October 30, 2008 at 10:52 PM EDT #

Heyy, u guys!! i cant wait for this book to come out and i agree with some of u ppl that alli secerts are the BEST and that she does have a twin!! lets read it and weep!! lol jkjk lyl ~$

Posted by Sara on October 31, 2008 at 09:05 AM EDT #

I think the biggest secret is the one they talk about in PLL #4 : Unbeleivable. You know, how Ali 'had sibling issues too'.

Posted by Olivia on November 01, 2008 at 10:48 AM EDT #

Lol my names Ali wich makes all the more weird to read. I just finished the last one and an't wait for number 5. I can't pick the best secret but..... does anyone think they're will be more books after Wicked???

Posted by Ali on November 01, 2008 at 04:39 PM EDT #

I swear Ali's alive. who knows maybe she had something to do with Mona finding her diary. I totally agree with the twin idea. Maybe Ali's family knocked the twin into the ditch, faked it was Ali, and maybe that's why Jason said his family's messed up. i also think Jenna knows more than shes letting on....and Officer Wilden totally suspicious. He's a noob cop...anyway i cant wait for book number 5 im going to be the first one on the line where i live!

Posted by Pretty Little Book Nerd on November 01, 2008 at 04:52 PM EDT #

i think the biggest secret is in book 5 when aria is pregnant and find s alliii

Posted by cutiepututie on November 01, 2008 at 09:29 PM EDT #

How do you know that will happen? The book isn't out yet. I think the biggest secrets are Ali's too. She is hiding so much. I've thought that she had a twin since book 3. Who knows tho. I guess we'll see soon.

Posted by Danielle on November 01, 2008 at 11:22 PM EDT #

Ok first off i would like to say that i never once thought Spencer was the killer and i am glad she isn't! Idk for sure though if Ian really did kill Ally...I mean they have tricked us before especially A so idk....But what i dont get is what Wicked is going to be about since A is gone...How is there going to be a new A????? Anyway i think all the secrets Ally kept from them was BIG!! I mean they trusted her with everything and all she did in return was lie to them and keep secrets. So anyway i really cant wait to read the next book! Will all know the truth soon! MWAH! ~D~

Posted by Danielle on November 02, 2008 at 12:10 AM EDT #

first of all ali's name is spelled A-L-I not a-l-l-y. get it right. i looooved the ending of unbelievable. it was siiick. the jenna thing is the worst, definably. whatever. peeeace!

Posted by brook lyn on November 02, 2008 at 01:13 PM EST #

I think spencer!

Posted by yuraddictionx3 on November 02, 2008 at 05:42 PM EST #

I am reading the third book in the series. For Christmas I want the 4th and 5th book so badly! I can't wait to find out who "A" is and what happens :) :D

Posted by Juliana on November 02, 2008 at 05:46 PM EST #

i think the worst was emilys!!! and i really think they should put ali on one of the covers i really want to see what she looks like!!!

Posted by floobo on November 03, 2008 at 12:44 AM EST #

having a tough time deciding between Aria & Spencer--Aria kinda took after her dad & had "connections" with their teachers & students, but then again Spencer kissed her sister's bf &, yet again repeated history. Then Spencer fights with Ali & UGH!!! They're both kinda even, I would say

Posted by catie on November 03, 2008 at 03:52 PM EST #

ooooooo i cant wait 4 the next book but also the worst of them all has to be arias. i mean, hers was the only one that was illegal. but im kinda grr about how spencer wasnt carrying wren's love child... it wouldve been a perfect plot twist!!!!! oh welllll.......

Posted by kim on November 03, 2008 at 04:56 PM EST #

all you girls are wrong... except the ones that say i have a twin... spencer is the only one that knows. she was always my favorite. oh by the way aria chack up on your mom and ezra... ;] hanna sweetie, you need to learn how to keep your things to yourself. people dont like a liar. oh wait all of you are. hanna your very close to come toa rude awakening. and my little emily, your still gay. just cuz you have a boy on your mind doesnt mean.... anything. and jenna knows EVERYTHING... my best friends (: .... your all screwed. love ya. -a.

Posted by alison_ on November 03, 2008 at 05:58 PM EST #

hey its alison again... dont be fooled by what you read girls. look at the clues and read between the lines. everyone knows. they just dont have the gutts to say it, spencer, aria, hanna, and emily will have a secrete meeting very soon. in which -a. will come. and all especially you will be shocked. but dont be scared. at least only one will walk out alive. well only for a while.... ;]

Posted by alison_ on November 03, 2008 at 06:04 PM EST #

heyyy, well i finishd the first book && i`m confused about lots of things, first, is mona a?! && if so, how do people find out she`s a ? -_____-, why don`t they just go to a police inthe first place? i mean being gay is no big deal, & kissing your sister`s bfs is not that bad, && throwing up your foood, i mean gross but w/e ;] && ali, man, i don`t get it/

Posted by steffyroduh on November 03, 2008 at 07:34 PM EST #

I LOVE THESE BOOKS! SPOILER ALERT!!!!!!!! I think the biggest secret is Ali's. In the books, it is hinted that there's more to her than being glamorous and popular. Her family had problems, like Jason(her older brother) said, just that we don't know what it was yet. Also, Ali and Jenna bonded over sibling problems, but maybe it wasn't with only Jason. I agree with Rebecca, that Ali might have had a twin because of all the flashbacks in Unbelievable(PLL4). I think Melissa killed Ali, she might have anger problems or something. When her and Spencer was at the beach house, Melissa said "It takes someone unique to kill..." also there was a barbie doll that Spencer said looked like Ali and Melissa just popped off the dolls head. I think Melissa made Ian take the blame because Ian's motive was just plain stupid. Ali has the biggest secret of all of them and she was probably the best pretty little liar. I think Ali might still be alive.

Posted by Ashlee on November 04, 2008 at 09:56 AM EST #

Omg i so totally think Ali's still alive. I agree she might have a twin who knows. and wen emily saw blue eyes a i soo totally thought it was Ali. i still think it was her. lyk hello the hole story revolves around aria,spencer,emily,hanna, and ali. dugh! and the darkest secret would be aria thats sooo grows a TEACHER!! lyk EWW much. emily's isnt that bad lyk hello many ppl are goin that way its all cool wit me unless their tryin to get wit me. and spencer isnt that bad ethier its normal. SMOETIMES oK. hanna sounds good to me ok. anyways i soooo cant wait for the book to come out!

Posted by Alexa on November 04, 2008 at 12:04 PM EST #

Like HELLO did you really think i was gone? think again!! Huney im so back and ready to ruin your life. These pretty little liars have darker secrets this time so im here like always to tell you the HOLE truth! Mwahh! ~A~

Posted by ~A~ on November 04, 2008 at 12:10 PM EST #

Okay come on Monas secret is huge!!!! but really she did all of that over a little scar. thats jst sad nd makes her look crazy

Posted by zoey on November 04, 2008 at 12:46 PM EST #

i thought Mona's secret was the deepest. She didnt have to tell the rest of them that she was A. she could have gone on terrorizing the girls, and nobody would have found out. she knew that hanna would figure out that she was A. she knew her well enough to figure out how her mind works.

Posted by laura on November 04, 2008 at 12:53 PM EST #

I think that the deepest is yet to come, and its probley Melisa, who has the biggest baddest secret! I'm already DYING to read them!!! This book is going to be "WICKED"

Posted by Brittany on November 04, 2008 at 06:37 PM EST #

I think that ali and ian dug up a body, put her ring on it through it in her back yard, facking her death, then ali is in hiding, because we all know that mona had white hair, not blond!

Posted by Guess Who on November 04, 2008 at 06:45 PM EST #

these books OWN. cant wait for the 5th.

Posted by shelbaay!!@#^ on November 04, 2008 at 09:49 PM EST #

Ugh. You people are the worst. Most of you should know exactly who I am by now... I mean, it's even easy to see for Jenna! Oh well. I guess you'll find out in Wicked...

Posted by A on November 04, 2008 at 09:54 PM EST #

i just finished flawless and its been like the best series of book's i've ever read!! im dieing to no who killed ali??? it hink it was Mona but i'll just have to wait and see???

Posted by kelsey c on November 05, 2008 at 11:31 AM EST #

i love-love-love the pretty little liar books! I couldnt stop reading them! i was shocked when i found out who "A" was an who killed Ali-totally unpredictable! anyway cant wait for "wicked"!

Posted by angeline on November 05, 2008 at 06:27 PM EST #

Mwahahahaha!!!!!

Posted by alison_ on November 05, 2008 at 07:06 PM EST #

WOW. i love the girls that think they are ali on the comments. losers. sweetie pies, this isn't just a book. just wait till aria, emily, spencer, and hanna get in it. and by the way ladies, "wicked" isn;t the last of them...

Posted by alison_ on November 05, 2008 at 07:47 PM EST #

Hey every1!! I love the first book and i m sure that i would LOVE the other 3 if i had read them!! So i was wondering if u read my comment and u read all 4 books so far PLEAASSEEEE tell me everything that happened so i can get the brand new 1 that is coming out!!!!Thanks a lot! x0x0x0x0x0x0x0x0x0x0x0x0x0x0x0x0

Posted by Vanessa! <3 on November 05, 2008 at 07:51 PM EST #

TWILIGHT ROCKS!!!!!!!!!!! EDWARD CULLEN FOREVER!

Posted by Obsessed with twilight on November 05, 2008 at 08:09 PM EST #

i think they are all pretty dirty secrets . they were all so shocking to me. like why jenna was really blind and how toby used to touch her. emily liking girls was like woah!! i hate her family out in the country. her cousins are LIARS! they lied about it being her idea to go the that party >.< more under:

Posted by {Ali}cia the Alternative Music Addict! i <3 PLL on November 06, 2008 at 10:13 AM EST #

aria i think her dad is really sick. with his own student. yuck . and he has 2 kids and a wife. spencer when she was a kid she expirenced voilence ( when her & her family was confronted by the guy with the gun) scary much.

Posted by {Ali}cia the Alternative Music Addict! i <3 PLL on November 06, 2008 at 10:14 AM EST #

AND WORSE MONA WAS A! i cant believe A was among them the whole time. I thought it was her because she said at the end of one of the books that i have a's in my name too. but i kinda put that to the side. i thought after she( i believe emily) smelled the banana gum it was maya.

Posted by {Ali}cia the Alternative Music Addict! i <3 PLL on November 06, 2008 at 10:19 AM EST #

but it couldnt have been because maya doesnt have white blonde hair like emily( er spencer on of the 2) saw go across the window in ali's room. so i put two and two together! i sooo cant wait for the 5th book!!

Posted by {Ali}cia the Alternative Music Addict! i <3 PLL on November 06, 2008 at 10:20 AM EST #

there needs to be a movie!!! like reallyy im on the 4th book and i cant stop reading it im so eager to see wat the 5th book is about =]

Posted by illie on November 06, 2008 at 03:02 PM EST #

omg there has to be a movie!!!!! omg the books are so good i think Emily's secret was juicy you kno lol tlk later - bby cc

Posted by CC_luvbby? on November 06, 2008 at 03:11 PM EST #

Wicked isn't just a book. It's a bible chronicling the lives of 4 tortured souls. Wicked is going to be an amazing ending to all the cliff hangers! And it doesn't end there. xxx- moi

Posted by AAAAA on November 06, 2008 at 07:47 PM EST #

Can't wait man! That was funny AAAAA "bible"

Posted by Pretty Little Mandy on November 06, 2008 at 09:13 PM EST #

I'm number 100 OMG I can't wait till wicked I think it'll be the best one yet

Posted by Sarah on November 06, 2008 at 10:30 PM EST #

K heres the problem- Ali is a fictional character and you all are just foolish to pretend that you're Ali. Or did make-believe suddenly become the next best thing to play, even if you're 13 and 14? The secret that's the 'dirtiest' is Emily's- emily should keep that to herself, and avoid it best as possible. I can't wait for wicked!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by bRi BeE on November 07, 2008 at 09:27 AM EST #

what i dont get is how twilight just came out n there is a movie and pretty little liars is just as uhmazingg and there isnt a moviee there has to be one i would def. be the first person theree =] and for some reasoon i really dont liek aria in the book she seems like a tattle tale i understand she is going thru a lot but every chance she got she tried to tell some one.. hmm

Posted by illie on November 07, 2008 at 01:53 PM EST #

i think the worst secret is when they blinded jenna,but i wouldnt be suprised if there would be a more dirtier secret to come then the one the've kept for years.

Posted by Ricki on November 07, 2008 at 04:17 PM EST #

I think the biggest secret is Aria's. Well her multiple secret. I mean knowing that your dad cheated on your mom is pretty big. That made them get a divorce! And Aria being with a teacher is pretty big. Ezra got arrested. the other secrets didnt do as much. but as far as Ali being alive, i think she is or she has twin or something strange. there is the whole family problems thing jason said i think she might have a twin. maybe the twin had issues or something and the sent her away for a while. I dont think it is a coincidense that people that look like her keep coming up. that is just weird. but yeah

Posted by KGB on November 07, 2008 at 04:33 PM EST #

Mwahaha. There's a new A in town. There are new even dirtier secrets to spill. Duh i am still here.

Posted by -A on November 07, 2008 at 04:37 PM EST #

there making it into a tv show :)

Posted by brittany on November 07, 2008 at 04:39 PM EST #

there really should be a movie. it would be so intense with the stalking and killing and stuff. I would definetly see it and so would my friends.

Posted by Katie Gray on November 07, 2008 at 04:39 PM EST #

there will be 8 books

Posted by brittany on November 07, 2008 at 04:44 PM EST #

Even though she's dead, I think Ali had the biggest secrets because she knew everyone elses and she had her own that she wrote in her diary and never told the girls about.

Posted by Kayla on November 07, 2008 at 05:09 PM EST #

the grils all hav there really deep dark secrets...the all equal!!

Posted by book luvrr on November 07, 2008 at 08:38 PM EST #

kay, since i kno u people read the comments, just fix the first chapter thing, because i can't read it. it doesn't pop up. and the diary too. i could read the first chapters of the other books, but not this one, wicked, so fix it. thanx i <3 pretty little liars

Posted by the rael ali on November 07, 2008 at 09:58 PM EST #

wow.its just so freaken weird.first i thought it was just alisons sprit haunting me.but it wasnt.it was just shocking.

Posted by spencer on November 08, 2008 at 10:22 AM EST #

does anyone know what will happen in the next book? Are they really making it into a tv show, it better be good not like gossip girl, it is nothing like the books...

Posted by Hanna- on November 08, 2008 at 11:41 AM EST #

Wow, for everyone to think A is gone...you better think again. Im still here ladies. You might know but Spencer, Hanna, Aria, and Emily are going to go on like nothing happen until I "bring it up again". Get ready ladies, this is far from over. -kisses Z

Posted by Z on November 08, 2008 at 01:00 PM EST #

omg i CANNOT wait for this book to come out. i thought unbelieveable was going to be the last one but im sooo glad theres a 5th one. sara shepard is an AMAZING author and i luv her to death. her books are...chillingly subtle as i like to call them and i hardly ever put them down. it must have been really hard to fit all the little bits and pieces together to be perfect but in the end they were awesome and amazing and totally...wow PROPS TO SARA SHEPARD FOR WRITING THE MOST AWESOME BOOKS EVER!!!!

Posted by beauty is only skin deep but ugly goes clean to the bone on November 08, 2008 at 01:44 PM EST #

Hehe, I think Spencer is the one with the biggest secrets, shes always getting herslef into big trouble, and then when everyone thinks she killed Alli, it was to much, she is definetly the worst pretty little liar

Posted by Mona on November 08, 2008 at 01:53 PM EST #

First off my name REALLY is Emily Fields, Lilly is my middle name. Got it? Anyways this is such a good question. I feel that Hanna's secret is worse because she hurting herself. Evenshe's not cutting herself she's developing bulimia. As of now I'm a recovering bulimic so i know what she's going through. So yeah I'm more like Hanna than Emily.....so ironic huh?

Posted by Emily Lilly Fields on November 08, 2008 at 05:12 PM EST #

Wow thats cool about your name being emily fields. My last name is hanna spelled like in the book.

Posted by Hanna- on November 08, 2008 at 05:20 PM EST #

does anyone know when the boards are coming,they said it would be soon.

Posted by Hanna- on November 08, 2008 at 05:24 PM EST #

omg i think maya is a i just sorta thought abouyt that....

Posted by Kelley on November 08, 2008 at 06:12 PM EST #

jenna's seceret is for sure the deepest, i mean who would have thought that she knew about everything? ;) ARIA AND EZRA FOREVER!

Posted by Alisia on November 08, 2008 at 06:27 PM EST #

I seriously think that Ali does not have a twin. Jason probably does have problems, he said that his family had problems. What if they are normal and he has problems, so he said they have problems, because they have problems compared to him (well if he sees himself as normal). =} U Kno U Luv........Anya!

Posted by U Kno U Luv Anya on November 08, 2008 at 07:58 PM EST #

I think the dirtiest secret would have to be who killed Ali (if she even IS dead) but ya i did NOT see that one coming! But the only thing is i was mad because i found a spoiler an accident online before the book was even released so I was i little sad........Well Kisses- Kelsey

Posted by ~KELSEY #1 FAN~ on November 09, 2008 at 12:50 AM EST #

i think when jenna said they both had problems w/ they're siblings is in think she means that ali's brother was like molesting her or somethin the blinding is probably the worst secret becuz no one really knows the whole truth and i really dont think any of the other secrets r that bad mostly embarassing. at first i thought that andrew campbell was a and then i thought ian was a and i never really thought that spencer killed ali just another one of her hullucinations. i thought melissa surely killed ali, i still think that and she's only making up the drinking story.

Posted by Iza on November 09, 2008 at 03:00 PM EST #

luv the books they are so efing bomb lol. i can't believe all the secrets that were spilled i almost died wen i found out Ali and Jenna planned the fireworks stuff lol. can't wait 4 the next book. wicked luv the name and the cover <3 ashley mccraw

Posted by ashley mccraw on November 09, 2008 at 03:02 PM EST #

these books are amazing! i actually was thinking that ali had a twin, because emily saw the girl in the car at the end, and she had different shirt on in the flashback. im not entirely sure that ian was the killer... yeah he was supposed to meet her in the woods but someone else couldve known about it and went there too. so idk i think they need more evidence than that. melissa is always suspicious to me, like when she said a killer is unique. but if you look at the hints for the next book it makes it seem like ian did it. i cant wait another 16 days!!

Posted by lalalala on November 09, 2008 at 03:54 PM EST #

okay so the books are fantastic. its hard to choose which part was so scandelous. cause each book was amazing no matter what. So im just gonna say though the 3rd and 4th book were my faves. I kinda dont think that ali is dead i think that someone that is a cop facked that she was the body they found so idk.

Posted by stephanie on November 09, 2008 at 04:36 PM EST #

Okay, what is up with Ali and her brother? I think he must have done something bad to her or maybe they both did something bad. I don't know since I haven't read the fourth book yet! That's just what I think.

Posted by Mandy on November 09, 2008 at 05:13 PM EST #

Ok, I believe the person who is A is Jenna (wait for it) in the 4th book Jenna is texting on her phone! She's even taking a freakin' art class. She's blind!!!!! And how the hell did she draw Aria? And why would she pop out of nowhere in the dark where Aria was? I think that Ali is not even dead. She probably made a deal with Jenna because after all Ali knew Jenna's secret too and she "didn't like Jenna." Ali has her own secrets also. I think Jenna's secret was the deepest and dirtiest.

Posted by Letitia on November 09, 2008 at 06:47 PM EST #

okay first of all i love this series and i definitly think ali is not dead. i am still trying to fiqure out who they found behind ali's house but i dont think it was her. I sorta hope shes alive but i dont know why. i think aria's and erzas relationship should keep going through out the fifth book because to me i think they are cute together. time will tell i guess <3

Posted by Jaydn on November 09, 2008 at 10:13 PM EST #

HOT DAMN. I am SO ready for PLL 5 to come out.

Posted by Laura on November 10, 2008 at 07:06 PM EST #

omg i just read the book pretty little liars and it was absolutley fabulous i cant wait to get the rest of the series and it read it too if you have any comments on the rest of the series i would love for yall to email them to me talley.katie@yahoo.com plz!!!

Posted by katie talley on November 10, 2008 at 07:21 PM EST #

I Love this book, im reading unbelivable, lets say its the first book that i could actully get into and not want to put down. I can't wait fot the new book, Wicked!

Posted by Hey.babe. on November 10, 2008 at 10:36 PM EST #

I think Jenna is also A because she and Mona were once friends so they probably would have teamed up against the "pretty little liars". However, I don't think the author would make it that easy so there has to be a twist. And I DEFIENTLY think Ian did not kill Ali and it was really Melissa. I can't wait until Wicked comes out!!!

Posted by LUV PLL!!! on November 11, 2008 at 01:38 AM EST #

I think that the darkest one is that the blinded jennna i mean yeah they planned it... but not to blind her! What do u guys think?

Posted by Michelle_ Babiie on November 11, 2008 at 10:31 AM EST #

I think Ali is still alive and A is really Ali and Mona was just helping her.... And Ian was part of it.

Posted by MANDI on November 11, 2008 at 04:15 PM EST #

Listen here people, there are tons of dark deep secrets! but the deepest is the authors little twist on the end of unbelievable! i mean ali still alive ? they found her body ! who else could it possibly belong to ?!? i guess thats the big question !

Posted by miranda and katrina on November 11, 2008 at 07:56 PM EST #

i love this series so much!!! i cannot wait for wicked! I think the worst is Aria because she never told her mom about meridith. but spencer is pretty bad for doing it with her sisters ex

Posted by Jennifer on November 12, 2008 at 06:51 PM EST #

i read all the books now i think like the whole seris are is happening again! i love the books i told my friends about this spencer looks great on this cover! i will read this if i die! i have all the books in hard cover! the worst secert about ally is that she and Ian were going out!

Posted by Elyse on November 12, 2008 at 07:30 PM EST #

I can not wait for the new book to come out! I deffff think its not stopping after Mona, yeah she knew things, but Idon't think she knew everything, someone else must have! I think I'm going to brush up on my "Pretty Little Liars" trivia, since I read them all so fast, I need to get my mind back in the game for the new book! I'm so stoked! Plus, The whole Erza thing, simpily AMAZING! And Noel is def my favorite characher, even though his name is like Nole and mine is No-elllll (:

Posted by Noel on November 12, 2008 at 09:51 PM EST #

hmm, let's see, i am probably the biggest fan of this series ever. haha i have done three reports on the pretty little liars series and tomorrow i am giving a book talk speech about it for english class. i am sooo excited for the 5th book :] well you are an amazing author and the secrets in each characters life is so in depth. i don't know where you come up with most of the ideas. well, you are a writer. haa :) well, i will be letting you know how i like the 5th book. (im pretty sure im gonna loove it just like i do all the rest:D) --kayleigh:P

Posted by kayleigh :] on November 12, 2008 at 10:17 PM EST #

lmao so i loved the comment about twilight in the middle of all the pretty little liars stuff lol .. i love them both so yeah. and YES there are going to be more books ... at one point on this site under the "author" tab sara said get ready for 4 more pretty little liars books .. so yeah .. Ali has a twin ..has to .. and the theory about how SHE pushed her twin in the ditch was good ... never thought of that ... i just still dont get WHY her parents were kooks and thought they had to hide one of them ..i dont get it

Posted by Rebekah on November 13, 2008 at 11:49 AM EST #

wow i never thought sara shepard was going to be able to continue this series, but she did, and dang it gives me the chills!

Posted by Danielle on November 13, 2008 at 08:52 PM EST #

Goddd. All the girl's secret's are pretty dirty. I really like Hannah and Spencer for some reason. They're my favorite characters in the book. I kinda knew it was Mona all along but Sara Shepard is just such a good author that it still came as a surprise. I was so intensly reading the books I couldn't stop. I remember I got Unbeleivable the DAY it came out. Ever since I've been waiting for the next one and now I'm sooo impatient!! Anyway I think that Spencer's secrets are.. well, not the dirtiest, but the ones that make everything more intense!

Posted by Gwen on November 13, 2008 at 11:55 PM EST #

this is hard, i think maybe spencer has some of the biggest secrets cuz she's plagairized (idk if i spelled that right), possibly killed Ali even tho my bets on Mellissa,and like broke Mellissa's arm! Who knos what else she has done 2 seeing as shes blocked out a ton! i can't wait 4 wicked, i have like 20 pages left in unbelievable. yay!

Posted by C on November 14, 2008 at 09:46 AM EST #

Has anyone else read the first 7 chapters? I'm so excited. I pre-ordered the book and I can't wait to get it. Emily really does have a boyfriend!! That's really exciting. YAY! Not much longer to wait.

Posted by Danielle on November 14, 2008 at 10:24 AM EST #

Five more days Five more days Five more days Five more days Five more days Five more days

Posted by Pretty Little Mandy on November 14, 2008 at 02:48 PM EST #

These books are amazing i can't believe that Toby is dead and wrote a sucicide note to Emily. And i wonder who A is i hope to find out soon but she is starting to give advice so i think that Sara Shepard is an amazing writer!

Posted by Ashley on November 14, 2008 at 04:12 PM EST #

Love= The Pretty Little Lairs Bokks!

Posted by Sara on November 14, 2008 at 04:14 PM EST #

Books*** Sorry bout that spelling error!

Posted by Sara on November 14, 2008 at 04:15 PM EST #

Hey girlies!- you dont know me and i dot know you. but one thing is for sure. if there is a real A writting comments on this wall. Can she prove it? A- if u r out there prove it bye sending a txt msg to this # 615-202-0344. Then we'll see if there is a real A in town. Sry but i aint gonna post my name. Txt anything A.. I want proof. -M

Posted by M on November 15, 2008 at 11:56 AM EST #

Hey girlies!- you dont know me and i dont know you. but one thing is for sure. if there is a real A writting comments on this wall. Can she prove it? A- if u r out there prove it bye sending a txt msg to this # 615-202-0344. Then we'll see if there is a real A in town. Sry but i aint gonna post my name. Txt anything A.. I want proof. -M

Posted by M on November 15, 2008 at 11:58 AM EST #

HAHAHAHAHA! MANY PEOPLE HERE THINK THEY R A BUT IT IS MEE. AND THAT CHALLANGE OF TXTING YOU M IS VERY GOOD FOR ME TO PROVE TO YOU. DO YOU REALLY DOUBT ME? TOO BAD. I'LL TXT U A MSG WITH UR NAME AND UR PHONE NUMBA! AND FOR ALL THOSE GIRLIES OUT THERE. SEND ME YA NUMBA AND I'LL TXT YA TOO. ACTUALLY THE 3RD ONE TO GIVE ME HER NUMBER WILL GET A VERRYYYYYY SPECIAL MSG! 'TILL "WICKED" BABYGIRLS. -A

Posted by alison d. on November 15, 2008 at 12:04 PM EST #

guys--------- i think ali is alive.. like in the book i mean. and it is possible that she had a twin. maybe on the first book when it talked about them going to ali's house and then her mom interrupted to talk to her.... and she supposedly "changed" clothes. i think she has a twin or if she doesnt im positive that in "wicked" tha real ali will b the nxt A. girlieesss ALI is still ALIVE!!! put that in your mind! and A... i still havent gotten ur txt msg. u FAKE! -M

Posted by M on November 15, 2008 at 12:10 PM EST #

Omg! i luv this book series and im stoked they are coming out with a fifth book! but if i go after school to get it will it be in the stores already oon the 25th or do i have to wait until later that day?

Posted by **?luv this book?** on November 15, 2008 at 02:12 PM EST #

I am soooooooo excited for the fifth book! I can't wait!!!!!!! It is the best series I've ever read and anyone who disagrees is crazy!:P Sara Shepard is a GENIUS! How can someone come up with four diffrent stories and blend them into one? Most of my friends read her books too! It feels like FOREVER 'till the fifth book comes out! -from a pretty litle liar lover Emily xoxo Mwah

Posted by emily :P on November 15, 2008 at 07:34 PM EST #

Remember in the 4th book emily was in iowa and that girl trista had the same feautures ali had? Emily said that she made her feel safe. hmmm and the deepest secrets were aria's and spencers. And M ur ryt ali probably duz have a twin. And if thats rong then melissa killed ali kuz in one of da books i tink da 4th it said dat melissa stared at the hole in ali's backyard long and hard just focused on it and then in the 3rd with the hotub conversation o yea thers clues LOL. CANT WAIT TILL WICKED COMES OUT!!!!

Posted by haitianprincess on November 15, 2008 at 08:12 PM EST #

alison d.: I think you're right. I mean, how could there be 4 more books (#s 5-8) and they could only be filled with secrets? I mean really, how boring would that be? - J

Posted by J on November 16, 2008 at 01:58 PM EST #

lets see cant wait to see you r guys faces when wicked comes out.... and the new movie!! woops there goes a pretty little SECERT and a pretty little liar will slip away FOREVER thank to whom else than ME!!!! mwha ~A

Posted by the tru ~A on November 16, 2008 at 04:05 PM EST #

OMG! Ok. I love these books! I truly don't know what I would do without them! I've read the series twelve times! And I absolutely can't wait until the 5th book! I swear I am not going to be able to do anything until I finish the book when I get it.

Posted by Mimi on November 16, 2008 at 06:18 PM EST #

omg "the tru ~A" are you serious they are coming out with amvie for the series and if so wen will it be out im like a pretty little liars fanatic but hey.... I guess we all are! : )

Posted by **?luv this book**? on November 16, 2008 at 08:09 PM EST #

At first I thought Ali having a twin is plain stupid. But now after reading all the comments, I'm wondering if maybe she could. Especially since in one of the flashbacks she said, "I wish she was out of my life forever." Who could she be talking about?...her twin maybe?? And also, Jenna knows alot more about the A thing, since she couldn't tell Aria who else saw Ali blind her, and then it turns out it was Mona. Still, why couldn't she say anything? And Emily "Killer" Fields? That's one of the clues, so what does that mean? Did she kill someone? And they only identified Ali by the ring. What if Ali killed her twin, put the ring on her, and is still alive?

Posted by Char on November 18, 2008 at 10:11 PM EST #

Hello girlies! personally I don't think any of you know the real truth about these Rosewood girls,their secrets get even darker in the last book! Guess you'll have to wait and see! By the way, I'm still watching! kisses,--A

Posted by A on November 30, 2008 at 05:57 PM EST #

I really dont like the people who pretend to be A. Its really AH-nnoying. I will help if you talked in code like A. FAKES! Anyway, Sara, you are my guide for writing. And for all the imposers, someone is Always watching ;) ?Rose? Ksses!

Posted by Rose on December 04, 2008 at 07:16 PM EST #

sorry meant to put kisses! stupid com. :) lol

Posted by Rose on December 04, 2008 at 07:17 PM EST #

PART-1 coluld spencer be the killer?? she was there. or maybe.. emily, she might be mad cause ali dint want her back, or hanna who with all her heart wanted to be ali. or dear aria who is so lost in what she wants. who knows? all i know is spencer, all she wants is someone to be there. cause we all know that her family isnt there so maybe her new romance is what she needs. and hanna. oh poor hanna.. all she wanted was to be popular.

Posted by bridgette. on December 30, 2008 at 03:41 AM EST #

PART-2 and when she got that it turns out it was her worst enemy. or was mona really a? and emily, big whoop, shes a lesbian. well why cant her parents and family except it. and just cause she has her little past with girls doesnt mean she cant have a new guy. maybe she wants to re start fresh. and lost but not least, aria.. okay she was in a realashionship with an older man. it happens.

Posted by BRIDGETTE. on December 30, 2008 at 03:42 AM EST #

PART-3 its not her fault this guy became her teacher. and she knew him before so just let her be. and as they are saying she mught be into another older guy in da new book, its not that she diggs oldder guys. i bet its a coincidence. these books holds lots of suprises so just keep reading to find out more.

Posted by BRIDGETTE. on December 30, 2008 at 03:42 AM EST #

I do think Ali has a twin and is still alive!thats a good theory. i also think that the new A killed Ian. I loved wicked and cant wait for killer. I also think Jenna is behind some of this, why wouldn't she talk 2 aria?

Posted by becca on January 01, 2009 at 10:53 PM EST #

Dirtiest woodb bout jenna i luved aria and ezra 2gether theri romatic journey was 2 much fun

Posted by Hottie on January 06, 2009 at 06:13 PM EST #

MAJOR SPOILERS AHEAD! I love this book, I read the first 8 chapters on HarperCollins Browse Books thing! I really believe Ali *had* a twin, but with mental issues, that's why I think Ali is alive, and I mean, why there's always someone who looks like Ali and then disapears? Plus, Ali had a different shirt than her dead body, so only if she came into the house she could have changed it. And Jason says his family has problems, maybe it's about the twin? But then Jenna says that she and Toby weren't as bad as Ali and Jason. So, or Jason killed Ali (it could be!), or she helped Ali to kill the twin. No one (as far as we know) knew Ali had a twin so Jenna could have mistaked the Twin for Ali. I think Jenna knows a lot! Not as much to be A, but seriously, is she really blind? In the books, she texts on her cell phone, draws Aria, and appears on a dark night right to Aria? Tell me. Plus, we discover that Jenna and Ali had planned The Jenna Thing, and that they both would scare their brothers, so Jenna must have known that she had problems with her brother, and it could be about the twin. I guess the next "A" is Maya, it's pretty obvious, she is living in Ali's house and she could have gotten Ali's diary (although I don't think so, Sara Shepard wouldn't repeat that), or Ali's cell phone, whatever, or even discover the twin's room! Plus, she could be taking revenge on Emily for not being with her anymore, and stalk her friends too. If all this "twin" thing is untrue, I really believe Melissa or Jason killed Ali. Melissa is a byotch and she says "it takes someone unique to kill", and then she pops the head out of a Barbie that looks like Ali, she could have anger issues over Ali for all the Ian thing, and then accuse Ian himself of killing Ali! That's what I would do if I killed her. Then, Jason. As said above, you can see that trough the books we get clues that the DiLaurentis' family had problems and that thing Jenna said. Those are my theories. Oh, the dirtiest secret is Ali's!

Posted by Michelle on January 14, 2009 at 10:35 AM EST #

"in the 4th book Jenna is texting on her phone! She's even taking a freakin' art class. She's blind!!!!! And how the hell did she draw Aria? And why would she pop out of nowhere in the dark where Aria was? I think that Ali is not even dead. She probably made a deal with Jenna because after all Ali knew Jenna's secret too and she "didn't like Jenna." I think Jenna isn't blind. I think Ali has a twin. And that Maya is the new A. And that Jason or Melissa killed Ali's twin, and that Ali is still alive...

Posted by Michelle on January 14, 2009 at 10:37 AM EST #

Maya is soo A, why can't anyone see it! Gosh, she lives in Ali's house! I bet Mona wasn't A, it was Maya all the way - because all the "A" letters start when she comes to Rosewood. I think Maya threatened Mona to say she's A. She could have gotten blond hair from her clothes, or even, she could have made a deal with Mona, not to tell she was the actual A and Maya wouldn't reveal a secret of Mona - as far as I think, Maya could have the diary too, and we know Jenna and Ali had a bond, and Jenna was Mona's friend so Ali might have known some secret.

Posted by Michelle on January 14, 2009 at 10:45 AM EST #

They are the BEST books i have ever read!!

Posted by kayy on January 25, 2009 at 03:03 PM EST #

wow that`s intence michelle LOL i love it!!!

Posted by Emma D on January 30, 2009 at 10:51 PM EST #

I think that the deepest darkest secret all the girls have kept has not been told quite yet.

Posted by Mona on February 01, 2009 at 06:11 PM EST #

hey, so about Alli. Sure the book says her body was found and shes gone, but for four PRETTY LITTLE LIARS isnt that too good to be true? After all she had ALL of their secrets! And so do I. The story line is PERFECT kind of like Aria's old life. Hanna is making herself sick in an effort to be FLAWLESS. Emily being accepted!?!?!? UNBELIEVABLE. And the new A sounds awefully WICKED! What , I wonder will our little confused -personal pitbull -Emily get into in the next book.KILLER? or will it be about just that. I wish I knew but I guess well just have to suffer wont we? xoxo -A P.S. Nothing is ever as it seems:AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAMwah!

Posted by -A on February 09, 2009 at 09:27 PM EST #

Look I Think that ian is guilty but it makes sense that melissa probably had something to do with it i mean her personality Ian cant keep a secret from her so that means she knows something.

Posted by Dee on March 02, 2009 at 11:48 PM EST #

Omg I love this series Wish they would put Ali on the cover for once I kinda think Ali has a twin now since she said I wish she was out of my life forever.

Posted by A on March 31, 2009 at 10:44 PM EDT #

Post a Comment:
  • HTML Syntax: NOT allowed