Pretty Little Liars - The Official Site

wait when did killer<3 come out

Posted by Anna on July 01, 2009 at 05:39 PM EDT #

I just finished Killer moments ago and i'm shocked! i got it yesterday and i could not stop reading it!! The one thing i hate about series is waiting for the next ones to come out!! its torturous, but definitely worth it. Thank you for writing this wonderful series, i'm very happy i found it!

Posted by Haley on July 01, 2009 at 05:54 PM EDT #

OMG THIS WAS THE CRAZIEST ENDING EVER. xD it's so creepy and i totally knew who "they" were the whole time i'm so proud of myself. (: i'm so excited for the next one it's insaneee<3

Posted by hannah on July 01, 2009 at 06:42 PM EDT #

The ending was so cruel! I'm going crazy, I just finished it. It was good though -and Jason and Wilden, holy crap.

Posted by Diane on July 01, 2009 at 06:58 PM EDT #

OMG!!! I can't believe that ending! I don't know what to say, I'm just so excited for the next book. I will explode :)))

Posted by Noelle on July 01, 2009 at 07:05 PM EDT #

omg!! i just finished Killer!! gahh it was amazing!! i kept thinking A was Melissa but who knows now? the end was TOTALLY shocking to me!! i so cant wait till the next one... :) SPOILER ALERT: at the end where it say there willl be 4 new prettly little patients i wonder whats that about??

Posted by Courtney on July 01, 2009 at 08:08 PM EDT #

SPOILER ALERT: wow i just finished killer and i can't believe what happened! how could Ali be alive? if she was alive, she would have had to stay somewhere and her parents thought she was dead. also they found her body in the hole, and Ian said Wilson and Jason killer her. i can't wait for the next one. it comes out in january i think. and to courtney, i think A meant that now the girls are going crazy with all the stuff thats happened so they have to be admitted to a pysch ward

Posted by cassie on July 01, 2009 at 08:47 PM EDT #

SPOILERR ALERRRTT!!: ohhmaghodd. iim utterlyy shockedd. buuht ii feel liiek iitsz tew good tew behh truue iif ali'sz aliive. even thoo iit cudd help solvee lotssz....no onee can denyy tht shessz stiil a hateful biitch...buuht ii stiil LOVEE HERR! hahah. shessz juss sooo..perfectt. iisz iit normal teww be assz confusedd assz ii amm thoo ? my theoryy iisz tht iian iisz most defiiniitelyy NAWWT deadd ann tht policee guyy wiiht the W...waldinn ii thiink ? yeeah. ii thiink hessz guiltyy. ii cant picture jasonn beeiin a murdererr thoo. ii juss lovee hiim too muchhh!! (: which iisz prob roongg.. jenna mayaa ann hiim def have SOMETHIING teww do wiiht the murderr thoo. the twiin theoryy iisz..possiiblee. buuht iim nott sherrr.

Posted by aubreyy on July 01, 2009 at 08:56 PM EDT #

Wow. Excellent Book! This one really turned everything upside down, but I think there's more to the story than the obvious. I'm seriously wondering if Ali had a twin. That's all I'll say for now. :D

Posted by Sarah on July 01, 2009 at 09:17 PM EDT #

Yeah... a twin. Because she didn't reconize any of them... but if she's not dead, what are JD and DW hiding?

Posted by Mandy on July 01, 2009 at 09:28 PM EDT #

SPOILER ALERT!!!!!!! holyyyyy ..... i just finsihed now read it in a day. I can not believe alli is alive. BUT the DNA tests said it was here in the hole. I totally knew wilden had something to do about it a jason was also suspicous. WHAT DOES JENNA HAVE TO DO WITH WILDEN AND JASON NOW!!!! Wilden was at her house tht day hanna saw him and Jason was yelling at her!!!!!!!!! I CANNOT WAIT FOR THE NEXT BOOK IM GONNA DIE! mayb alli had a secret twin they were hiding or something

Posted by Sam on July 01, 2009 at 09:44 PM EDT #

Killer was amazing. When I finished it I was blown away. Ahh it has to be Ali, cause I love her as a character and I think it's cool that she's back. It'd probably be possible for her not to recognize them. I mean, they have grown older, and something could have happened to Ali's memory. Jason flipped out at Aria when she got into his apartment, right? Well maybe Ali was living in the main house. Maybe Jason and Wilden hurt her enough to damage her memory, and the DiLaurentises didn't want Jason to get in trouble. I cannot wait for January when the next book comes out.

Posted by Rachel on July 01, 2009 at 11:53 PM EDT #

omg. I'm excited for Killer. I can't get it now because I only buy paperback. So, that sucks.

Posted by alyssa on July 01, 2009 at 11:57 PM EDT #

no sam, the DNA tests hadnt come back yet, anyways my theory is that jenna was hiding ali but idk what wilden and jason have to do with it, but i knew wilden was guilty. and omg i feel soooo bad for spencer!!! and i think A is actually trying to b helpful this time unlike mona, mayb A is Jenna??? hm....

Posted by KK on July 02, 2009 at 12:12 AM EDT #

whoa good theory rachel! omg i just remembered spencer saw something on the news tht said "r the dilaurentis' hiding something?" maybe thts what it is, mayb thyre hiding ali after jason/wilden damaged her memory!!!! oh and the "wilden had a crush on ali way grosser than ians" freaked me out! ewww

Posted by Kate on July 02, 2009 at 12:16 AM EDT #

OH MY GOSH!!!! i can not believe what happened!!!!!! Sara Shepard is one of my favorite authors and i think this was the best book yet! It was captivating and i read it all in one sitting! haha i just finished it a few minutes ago! i loved how the story kept twisting in different directions..... AND THEN THE ENDING!!! OMG i can not wait until the next book comes out! A few people said January...I hope its soon!!! :)

Posted by leah on July 02, 2009 at 12:22 AM EDT #

HUGE SPOILER ALERT: I know that Jason seems pretty wacko n everything, but maybe it was Ali who went 2 the psycho ward after she "died". Personally, I don't want Ali back cuz she's a bitch that ruined their lives. Hopefully it 's a twin r her memory's gone. The DNA tests never came in tho, so u never know... Ahh!!! I need the next book! It's called Twisted n comes out in January, but what exact day, Sara? Love the books! Thank u n keep writing!

Posted by Steph on July 02, 2009 at 12:27 AM EDT #

SPOILER ALERT: the whole twin theory is over. Every child under 16 has to be enrolled in school and if Alison had a sister she would have to go to Rosewood Day. Maybe its a cousin?

Posted by nutmeg on July 02, 2009 at 01:08 AM EDT #

HOLY GOODNESS! I read killer in ONE DAY! 8 hours straight of reading. ***spoiler alert*** ok, so i agree with alyssa about how like jenna was hiding away ali! Well... i think?ormaybe like they hid ali out in the Poconos house? Jason & Wilden, that is- i ALWAYS knew wilden has something to do with it!!!! Oh my gosh- it all makesperfect sence- jenna said they had sibling problems- jason was like idk what but he did that to ali, only trying to protect her- then sence he had mental problems just LOST it and brought her into the woods because the girls found out the secrets he'd been hiding with wilden he went crazy & decided to get rid of them once and for all. & maybe ali didn't remember because like she hadn't seen then in SOSOSOSO long,or maybe the smoke was in her head or something. My bestfriends look WAY diff. from when we were in 6th grade, oh my goodness, Sara Shepard- you are THE absolute most talented writter out there! I love writting & reading, you have inspired me to write my own novel that i'm working on at the moment- can't waituntil you come to Georgia!!!! I'm SUPER excited!!!

Posted by maggie on July 02, 2009 at 01:12 AM EDT #

well dang.i read the book in one day & didn't put in down for a second! Now i can't even stop thinking about it! if anyone wants to chat about is e-mail me at missmagziepants@yahoo.com because not a lot of my friends read these books! but wowowowow. i'm just SO in love with them! holy smokes these books are good!

Posted by maggie on July 02, 2009 at 01:19 AM EDT #

UGH, HELLO, there's home schooling! So the twin this is SO possible. I think that if Jason was a little insane, maybe there is something wrong with the twin, and so they wanted to keep her secret, and so then she was home schooled. ;)

Posted by Mandy on July 02, 2009 at 02:21 AM EDT #

*Spoiler* Okay I think Spencer can't find her "real" mom because there is no secret mom; so I have a new idea for Spencer! Okay so everyone just skipped over the "natural born" thing and assumed that meant Spence is adopted. But I think Melissa was just messing with her, and Spencer bought it because she couldn't think of an alternative. But maybe The Hastings wanted a second child (probably a boy, so they would have one of each and have a "perfect family") but they couldn't conceive so they went to Planned Parenthood and did the alternative where its done by doctors and stuff (I won't do details, but the doctors plant the baby juice in the mom, haha) and so the grandma didn't approve because she didn't think it was "natural" and so Mrs. Hastings is so nasty to Spencer because she's mad she's not the son she always wanted.

Posted by Tia on July 02, 2009 at 02:39 AM EDT #

SPOILER ALERT!!! I think there have been a few instants in the series where Ali has "forgotten" things, events. In Wicked(?) she said that she went home with Jason after the Ian confrontation when really she walked off with Naomi and Riley. And I can't remember which book; but, didn't she act surprised when the girls asked why her mom wanted to talk to her, and she made up some story about her field hockey uniform? And hadn't she changed shirts that time also? My little theory is that obviously Ali had a twin. Something wasn't right with this twin (hence the Jason visiting her in a nut ward), and she would take on Ali's persona sometimes. Which is what her "sibling issues" were. I think the text with Ali, Jenna, and Naomi... was really Not!Ali instead of Naomi. I think they just assumed it was Naomi.

Posted by Danielle on July 02, 2009 at 02:45 AM EDT #

Did Hanna and Lucas make up in Killer? Did Andrew and Spencer become a couple? Is Ali REALLY alive? Who do you think A is? Please somone answer my questions...please!!!!I didn't get to read Killer and I won't be able to for awhile...so please fill me in! -Kisses

Posted by Me on July 02, 2009 at 10:36 AM EDT #

no they didnt make up, andrew and spencer arent a couple, and ali MAY b alive, not for sure tho. and tia, um.....wild thought

Posted by Nicole on July 02, 2009 at 10:55 AM EDT #

Oh my gosh. I got Killer the day it came out, and I couldn't stop reading it. The ending was so unexpected, but I think I knew all along Ali wasn't dead. And I deffiently knew Jason, was somehow linked to the 'murder.' Who knows? &I really hope they hurry with the next one! Killer was deffeintly the best PPL yet!

Posted by Alissa on July 02, 2009 at 11:04 AM EDT #

***Spoiler alert*** OMG ALI IS A DUH!!!

Posted by KK on July 02, 2009 at 11:05 AM EDT #

How do u know Ali is a? I mean yeah with the helpful notes but what about the times a was ruining the girls lives, it's pretty far fetched but it cud be. If a was Ali,she wudda recognized the girls from the fire cuz shed been stalking them...I totally think Jason and wilden r douchbags and tried to kill Ali but they didn't. All the theories of Ali staying with Jason r wrong- he woulda killed her

Posted by Ppl lover on July 02, 2009 at 11:34 AM EDT #

ok this twin thing is just crazy now! I think Ali has memory loss, cause Spencer heard a crack, but Spencer pushed ALi, mabye Spencer saw Jason and Wilden push her into a wall and was in such shock that she thought it was her pushing Ali. But i definitialy believe Ali is alive. but i do agree with Steph that ALi was the one in the pysco ward and Jason was checking in on her, but I think Jason was threatening her in there. Can't wait for the next one!

Posted by Melissa on July 02, 2009 at 11:36 AM EDT #

I think that the twin had the mental problems not Jason --and that sign in book was him visiting the twin that was there ... whether that was the REAL ali or not. and i think that him and Wilden helped the one in the mental hospital escape ... idk but i dont think jason was the mental patient he was visiting someone. I wonder if Melissa ran away to go be at Ian's side or if she disappeared to try and solve what was going on herself.

Posted by Bek on July 02, 2009 at 11:42 AM EDT #

Guys why wuld u think Alis the patient or her twin? Jason was logged in or out so it was obviously him annnddd he had those anger problems toward emily or aria. I'm actually rly glad alis back but I still have noo idea how heartless is goof to turn out...

Posted by Ppl on July 02, 2009 at 11:58 AM EDT #

OMG!! What if the crack Spencer heard was actually Spencer pushing Ali into the rock and Ali cracked her head and got brain loss and that is why she doesn't remember the girls. Also if that isn't the case then maybe Spencer and Ali are twins or maybe not, just related some how? and since Spencer has the ability to "block" out things that happened, maybe that is what Ali did and that is why she doesn't remember them (if my other theory is not the case). And for Ppl lover, Jason always protected Ali so if she did live with him (not saying she did) then he would not have killed her cause he protected her!!

Posted by emm on July 02, 2009 at 12:12 PM EDT #

Well i think the twin idea would be cool. It does make since, but why would ali not tell anyone and how would the Dilawentice family keep a twin a secret. Unless the twin and alli did not know they were twins. Anyways is pretty little liars going to be a tv show on abc? I read the book in a day and a half and (spoiler--->) thats so scary how the barn was on fire and aria found the person in the hood and thought it was the person that strood over hanna (ithink) when she fell on the way to see ians faux dead body.

Posted by taylor williams on July 02, 2009 at 12:18 PM EDT #

okay i think the theory where jason was visiting the "other twin" is right & the fact that aria remembered the secretary saying jason had to take a call from "his sister" when aria had seen ali moments earlier at school. ok so obviously the mental hospital thingy closed down so it could turn into a hotel, so they had to release ali's twin. the dilaurentis moved away & took their other daughter and hid her in the main house-where jason hoped aria wasn't snooping around. A is probably jenna trying to help the girls out but still be a b**** at the same time. OR it's naiomi and riley. jenna must of wanted aria to find out ali's twin was in the main house that's why they set the dog after her i don't know anything could happen with this series

Posted by Tiffers on July 02, 2009 at 12:23 PM EDT #

another thing i was thinking is that spencers mom cheated on her husband with ali dad & created spencer. that's why ali and spencer look so much a like. that's why mrs.hastings got all mad when the girls were acting like they were sisters. that's why her mom is so ashamed of her.

Posted by Tiffers on July 02, 2009 at 12:24 PM EDT #

another thing i was thinking is that spencers mom cheated on her husband with ali dad & created spencer. that's why ali and spencer look so much a like. that's why mrs.hastings got all mad when the girls were acting like they were sisters. that's why her mom is so ashamed of her.

Posted by TIFFERSS on July 02, 2009 at 12:25 PM EDT #

*SPOILER ALERT*: OMG i think that is tied with the very first book for the best! i dont get a few things though. 1) isnt mike a few years younger than aria? so if aria and hanna are the same age isn't it weird that theyre dating? 2) are they dating? and 3) how was ian (practically) DEAD then get away? he was apparently BLUE so how is that possible?

Posted by Ashley on July 02, 2009 at 12:25 PM EDT #

wait i have the best theory ever so ali did have a twin (?) but the twin had mental issues, for that reason they dropped her off to live at the mental institution (the radley hotel now) so anyway jason was the only one who wanted to stay in contact with her, because hes a good brother. `for that reason every week he would go visit her, she was very jealous of her twin and mentally insane, who knows maybe with rage she killed ali- or ali killed her. ali did say she had family problems and i think if aria gave the invite to jason, and jason had a past with the mental institute, meaning he went there he wouldnt be very insulted. -but he being a protective brother would be insulted if his little sis went there. ETC.ETC.

Posted by genevieve Mahoney on July 02, 2009 at 12:27 PM EDT #

p.s. for all of those talking about schooling seriously mentally insane kids arent required to attend school -theres mentally challenged kids who go to special schools -then theres mentally insane kids who are taken care of at home or sent to INSTITUTIONS TO BE HELPED.hinthint- jasonvisits hinthint(read my post abovE)

Posted by genevieve Mahoney on July 02, 2009 at 12:30 PM EDT #

omg i just got killer, and i have one chapter left, and its AMAZING!! lol i love this series so much , and I have been waiting forever for killer to come out! so there is gonna be another book coming out in the series? hopefully!!

Posted by avalon on July 02, 2009 at 12:30 PM EDT #

no one killed ali. she tripped and fell into the hole.

Posted by TIFFERSSS on July 02, 2009 at 12:30 PM EDT #

BTW SARAH PLEASEPLEASEPLEASE RELEASE THE FIRST CHAPTER OF BOOK 7. PLLLLLEASE. IM DYING HERE. OR PUSH UP THE RELEASE DATE FOR IT. HOW ABOUT RELEASE IT IN OCTOBER, my birthdays in october. it would be the perfect gift :)

Posted by genevieve Mahoney on July 02, 2009 at 12:36 PM EDT #

WOAH! i just finished like 2 minutes ago! what, ali? i thought it was going to be jenna. and i totally acted like veronica mars the whole way through, trying to piece it together, but none of my predictions worked out so well! alright, maybe stupid but i thought that what happened was Wilden paralyzed Ian, then the girls see him, and it really was Wilden that Hanna saw lean over her. Wilden runs out of the woods in time for the girls to find him, trying to leave at the valet. Then Ian like wakes up or something, and then runs away before everyone comes back. Then like everyone leaves after they can't find him, so Wilden's like, huh? where'd he go, and then finds him and takes him to Poconos and puts his body in the lake, haha. ya, it is pretty stupid. and i think that Melissa is pretending to be ian on the IM. oh my, i love emily and issac, and hanna and mike, and aria and jason, surprisingly, but i guess that's kind of over. anyways, until heartless, or twisted, or whichever! i love you sara shepard, please make a movie/ show, but make sure it's not lame, ex. gossip girl, no offense. xoxoxo

Posted by hannah on July 02, 2009 at 12:36 PM EDT #

Then like everyone leaves after they can't find him, so Wilden's like, huh? where'd he go, and then finds him and takes him to Poconos and puts his body in the lake, haha. ya, it is pretty stupid. and i think that Melissa is pretending to be ian on the IM. oh my, i love emily and issac, and hanna and mike, and aria and jason, surprisingly, but i guess that's kind of over. anyways, until heartless, or twisted, or whichever! i love you sara shepard, please make a movie/ show, but make sure it's not lame, ex. gossip girl, no offense! xoxo

Posted by hannah on July 02, 2009 at 12:40 PM EDT #

oh and the hooded creature spoiler: alison has been in the woods for a while. didnt it say a hooded person WITH BLONDE HAIR peeking out was seen crabwalking into the barn... creepy. well we know who blonde hair that belonged to: alison/ali'stwin?. none the less crazy. and who was standing over hanna (?) when she was running to get to ians body= a hooded creature. and for all we know the person with the flashlight could very well of been this hooded creature(ALi/ali-twin) :P

Posted by genevieve Mahoney on July 02, 2009 at 12:41 PM EDT #

another idea: the girls are truely going insane. you know how when you find out your friend has lice your head starts itching. or when you think someones mad at you everything they do ends up seeming more hostile to you then it truthfully is. maybe theyre going mad with suspicion, and A is helping out. i do think the saw ians corpse, but idk whats going on there, i do think they saw ali/ali-twin, once again though idk. i think everything else tho, is them going mad with suspicion

Posted by genevieve Mahoney on July 02, 2009 at 12:44 PM EDT #

Ok I truly think Ian is dead and someone said that Ian texed someone saying Jason and Wilden killed Ali? Well since Ian is dead, someone caould have gotton Ian's phone! Like A maybe and just said that...cause member in one of the other books A was kinda tricky and sent Hanna the dress but said it was Mona (which it actually was, but no one knew) So A may seem like it is helping the girls know,but maybe A is trying to be nice so it can do some twists and turns to fake the girls out!! Also I hope Ali is alive but she prob is not.. Does anyone no if Jenna has blond hair?? cause if she does then she is A no dought about it.. And (: Yup Jenna i think is A...(: (: (: (:

Posted by emm on July 02, 2009 at 01:06 PM EDT #

does anyone know when the next book come out not killer the book after that???

Posted by taylor on July 02, 2009 at 01:24 PM EDT #

omygawd ALI is A!!! IF she's still alive!!! Here's what i think: Ali is A and has been stalking the girls. Remember how they say they always see a flash of blonde hair? It's ALI stalking them & sending the A notes. But i also think Ali has a twin and that is who Aria saved from the fire! and i think the DiLaurentis' are hiding 1 of the twins and Jenna is hiding the other, and if Ali's not A then it's Jenna, or maybe they are A together....

Posted by Little_Miss_ Fabulous on July 02, 2009 at 01:51 PM EDT #

Killer was an awesome book! I was totally not expecting the end. I keep wondering what's going to happen next. How is Ali still alive?! That was a big shocker for me!! It was totally amazing. I wish the next book was out right now for me to read, I hate having to wait. These books are truly addictive. I love these books so much, they are my favorite series of all time! <3

Posted by Hannah on July 02, 2009 at 01:56 PM EDT #

yeah the next book comes out January 19 2010 it's called Heartless!

Posted by Little_Miss_ Fabulous on July 02, 2009 at 02:01 PM EDT #

hey hannah&litttlemissfabulkous, can i do ya? see ur +i+s and all? how big r deyyyy????!!!!!

Posted by RICK on July 02, 2009 at 02:09 PM EDT #

it was so good, i peed my pants alittle when i read the last 3 words.

Posted by megann on July 02, 2009 at 02:16 PM EDT #

OMG that book was AMAZNING!!!!!!!!!! how is ali still alive???? can u stop in ohio anytime soon 2 do a book signing and stuff.. when is the next book coming out i can't wait

Posted by birthday girl on July 02, 2009 at 02:26 PM EDT #

omg all this time i was trying to tell me friend (who is also obsessed with these books) that wilden was behind this the whole time. i mean before i finished Killer i thought, who else? I suspected wilden from the beginning and i cant wait to see what else happens!! i love these books to DEATH!! :) P.S. DON'T stop writing these books. i dont know how i would survive without them :)

Posted by stephany on July 02, 2009 at 03:24 PM EDT #

SPOILER ALERT!!! So I had a feeling that Jason was behind it in a way from when the news found him at Yale and the stuff that he said. Wilden was always strange. I think that mrs.hastings is Spencers real mom but something happened. ALI!!! In a way I think it's her but then again I don't. I think that everyone saying stuff about the mental hospital is right,how of could have been Ali's twin. Maybe thatsvwhat she ment when she said that she ha sibiling issues too.

Posted by Gaby on July 02, 2009 at 03:50 PM EDT #

Yay i am sooo happy! in most series the books get worse as time passes, but not pll! thank you so much for writing these incredible books!

Posted by Kadi on July 02, 2009 at 03:51 PM EDT #

well theres only 2 left stephany

Posted by Kaylee on July 02, 2009 at 03:52 PM EDT #

ehmeeeee! j'adore the series! xox Montreal

Posted by Montreal_Queen_Alpha on July 02, 2009 at 03:55 PM EDT #

maybe, Ali and Spencer were switched at birth, lmao

Posted by hannah on July 02, 2009 at 03:58 PM EDT #

OMG KILLER WAS AMAZING!

Posted by mariah on July 02, 2009 at 04:13 PM EDT #

ohmygoodness! I just finished Killer & I'm freaking out! It was such a shocking ending! Can't wait for the next one! <3333

Posted by Kay <3 on July 02, 2009 at 04:20 PM EDT #

Oh my gosh, love the books in this series! Seriously I devour these books. Got it yesterday, and finished it within three hours. Crazy ending, I'm trippin'! Next book comes out when? Can't wait :)

Posted by Lauren on July 02, 2009 at 05:09 PM EDT #

this book was incredible. there were points towards the end where i had my hand covering my mouth because i was in shock. i finished this book in 3 hours and i was actually trembling after i finished it. as for someone's theory about naomi or riley being A i dont think that could be.. they don't seem smart enough to do it they're kind of just stupid bimbos that follow whoever is bitchier. i do think that the twin theory is completely right. i also think melissa could be A still. there are a lot of signs pointing to that. its so crazy. i can't wait for the next oneee.

Posted by Lisa on July 02, 2009 at 05:22 PM EDT #

OMG I JUST HAD AN IDEA and sorry if someone already said this but what if ali has been with her family all this time. like what if she was found, and maybe that's why jason freaked out when spencer went to his apartment? and maybe ali was in the woods because she was trying to stop jason and wilden! maybe she found out. (by she i meant ali.) and was anyone else TOTALLY creapped out as much as i was? i finished it at night so i totally flipped.

Posted by hannah on July 02, 2009 at 05:24 PM EDT #

OMFGGG .... i finished in one day straight !!! the ending woaaahhhh! i need the next boook! theyre so addictingg . prob the best book series evr

Posted by stephh on July 02, 2009 at 05:24 PM EDT #

and another thing, because you know how wildens car was in the shop and he had to use that black one and he had the pass? what if that's what he was using to hide ali there? he had like an unusual crush on her so what if he was torturing her? maybe she was trying to escape in the woods. but then again hannah saw a person in a big hoodie stand over her when they found ian so maybe ali is playing it like she was the innocent one? i don't know. because they said she smiled or whatever and you know how the girls would always here giggles or laughs? maybe it was ali..or jenna! and what's up with those random mentionings of maya? maybe she has something to do with this because she does live in ali's old house

Posted by hannah on July 02, 2009 at 05:33 PM EDT #

ya i agree theres like random maya mentions its weird

Posted by KK on July 02, 2009 at 06:08 PM EDT #

i SO agree with danielle. i think she has a really good idea because maybe jason was visiting the twin of ali's. maybe ALI wasn't the one killed but her twin was so the family moved due to like, bad publicity. or maybe ali was killed and the one in the woods was the twin and that's why she didn't recognize them.

Posted by nellie on July 02, 2009 at 06:11 PM EDT #

Okay, I've been reading all of these comments and "Tiffers" theory makes SO much sense! Both of her comments makes sense. Maybe Ali and Spencer are related? And maybe that call for Jason when Aria wanted to talk to him was from his other sister, Ali's sister?! Omg I think I'm going to pass out I'm so excited for the next book in January!

Posted by Jessica on July 02, 2009 at 06:15 PM EDT #

allie has a twin baiiiii

Posted by brianna on July 02, 2009 at 09:02 PM EDT #

Im so Excited for The next book Heartless: January 19 2010 and then finally Twisted: December 2010 i love this book series. I honestly think that Jenna is A, she might seriously be helping out, or not. At first i figured that Mellisa Killed ali because of her whole affair with ian. Then maybe since it was mentioned jason was kinda obsessed with Melissa that he wanted to kill Ian because he was with Melissa. Wilden wrote that he couldn't believe that Ian would be with her so he offered to help jason kill Ian. No idea at this point ali could be a total hallutiontion anything could happen!

Posted by Nicole Suarez on July 02, 2009 at 09:30 PM EDT #

Question: did it bug anyone else how in Killer they kept saying that Spencer's eyes were green? They've always been blue in the other books!!

Posted by knk on July 02, 2009 at 09:43 PM EDT #

Killer was such an amazing book! as much as i didnt like Wicked i really enjoyed Killer! it was the scariest out of all (including Unbelievable)

Posted by Sheila on July 02, 2009 at 10:09 PM EDT #

**somewhat spoilers**Okay, I think that your all wrong. If what was coming next was easy to figure out, then the story wouldn't be good. Sara can't do anything that would be easy to guess. Truthfully, i disagree with the twin theory and that it's Ali (althought I really hope it is) but that it's something way more unthinkable unless you were the one to think it up. That book gave me the jitters all night and it won't leave my head, but look at it as twisted as it already is. You're purposly being lead to the wrong conclusion because that makes it better. Either way, love the series! Lots of love to fellow fans, Macy

Posted by Macy MaLeek on July 02, 2009 at 10:20 PM EDT #

AMGZ, i just finished "Killer" and WHOA, that ending blew me away! I think Ali is alive, or maybe she has a twinn, or who knows! I think Mellissa is -A, & I'm still madd how Spencer totally got scammed. I feel so sorry for Spencer, & I hate her mom. I'm confused about Hannah & Kate, I mean, they keep being mean to each other, but then they just blow it off like "lol, watevah!" And Emily, why does Issac's mom hate her again? What's up with Maya, what's with all these random pop-ups? And Aria, poor girl, I hope she doesnt end up with Jason. Jason can't be a murderer, he's like super protective, but Wilden, oooh, I don't like him! I'm going CRAZEE for the next book, 'Heartless', but it doesn't come out til Jan. 2010! That's tooo long! i <3 these books. they blow mi mind and leave me wanting more!!! =D

Posted by Urma =D on July 02, 2009 at 10:39 PM EDT #

I agree with Macy, everything is so twisted and confusing that something none of us is expecting is going to happen. With the whole Spencer thing, she should have listened to Andrew about her whole mom thing. I'd be mad if i had like 2 million dollars and then its all gone because i trusted someone that I didnt even know was my mom or not. I wanna know why Ali lied about what she but on her time capsule flag piece, im pretty sure that she didnt forget what she put on it, because she did lie a lot so she could have done the same with that. I cant wait for Heartless! omg wayy tooooo long to wait ! gahhhh :) love the series by far my favorite. and b.t.w. never reading them at night again, scared me soo bad ! but still love them :)

Posted by Gemma on July 02, 2009 at 11:13 PM EDT #

I think that (haha, nobody will agree with this!) The girl at the end of Killer is Jason's twin. Let me explain. I think that while the DiLaurentis family was living where ever it was that they were living, I think that Jason's twin got fed up with their dad's abusivness and ran away. That would cause Jason to need therapy (his twin is gone... how hard would that be???), and they would have the family resemblance. Ali would have been really young, so she might've needed a bit of therapy right before they moved, but not as much as Jason. I also think that while Darren and Jason knew about A, they weren't A. To me, A seemed young and hip making me think that A is Maya, Mona, and Melissa. Overall, the book was. AMAZING.

Posted by Megan on July 02, 2009 at 11:33 PM EDT #

Is it just me or do I have a slight suspicion that Jenna isn't as blind as she claims? I mean it makes sense. She always wears those big sunglasses, and in one of the books one of the girls felt as if she was being watched by Jenna. I think Jenna is faking the whole thing...I just have a bad feeling about her.

Posted by Morgan on July 02, 2009 at 11:45 PM EDT #

OMG KILLER IS SOO GOOD!! I haven't finished yet since I didn't have enough time but it is sooo good so far. I can't wait for Heartless!! You will always be my fave Teenfiction author! <3 you Sara!

Posted by Tara on July 03, 2009 at 12:09 AM EDT #

Wow!!! AH-mazing as usual! I finished my book at a resturaunt and literally shouted out "Oh my god!!! No way!!" The waiters all stared at me! lol and WOW! i hope you read my comment sara because i really wanna tell you some stuff. FIRST: i think that your twists are brilliant SECOND: i really think it would be a twist if Emily got pregnant by isaac! because they had sex! so that would be wow! and they could name the baby ali. hehe naww BUTTT can u pllllleeeeaasssssee bring ezra back!! he's the FIRST reason that A taunted aria so i dont want him to go away!! and i think xavier is such a perv! i give you props for all of those! anyways maybe u should do a hangman game and give us a few letters to guess the next name of your book!!! ok good luck with the books!! GOD BLESS! PLEASE READ ABOVE SARA! :)

Posted by Taylor on July 03, 2009 at 12:22 AM EDT #

wow morgan, ur right! i never really thought of that but.... it makes perfect sense! she always like randomly brings up "the jenna thing" ive never rlly realized what her blindness had to do with anything, but, now i get it, shes faking, mayb so she can easily stalk the girls? hm...

Posted by Allison Anne on July 03, 2009 at 12:33 AM EDT #

okay so I just finished killer (now I'm kinda creeped out which is why I'm still awake, I shouldn't have been reading at night haha) and I agree with the whole ali's twin thing/jason was hiding Ali's twin/ ali's twin was psycho/Alis twin is back buuut it could be Ali instead of ali's twin and Ali's twin actually died idk and something happened to her memory oooor there is no twin idkkk and I think the time caplsule flag that aria had has something to do with it like I think only wilden killed ali/whoever idk because the no parking thing with a j in it? so maybe it was like not Jason? I have no idea just a guess wow I'm really confusing myself now Ali has to be dead cuhs then who would wilden have killed?? idkkk.

Posted by Alix on July 03, 2009 at 01:14 AM EDT #

oh and I also agree that we prolly will neverever think of what actually is going to happen cause like none of us guessed anything this far so like idk anddd just contradicting myself now hahaha but I think melissa is a. mayyybe. and I also loooove Andrew campbell!!!! I always did even before anything happened between him and spence haha.

Posted by Alix on July 03, 2009 at 01:17 AM EDT #

I just have one question Noone has even thought of. I hope Ali has a twin or sometim but even if she doesn't...if sshes standing rite in front of the girls...then who's in the hole?

Posted by ppl lover on July 03, 2009 at 02:32 AM EDT #

Also, I really truthfully believe Jason was involved in a not so nice way and wilden was a freak al along. And I've notices a lot of u think jenna is a. How can that be if she's blind or even not?

Posted by ppl lover on July 03, 2009 at 02:36 AM EDT #

Hmm.. Just wanted to share a couple of ideas. I think Jenna is partially blinded, coz she does have scars around her eyes, but she isn't 100% vision impaired. Also, someone mentioned before (can't remember who) that in Wicked, when Hanna falls (when they're looking for Spencer) she thinks the ground smells like dog poop. Well, there's also a whimper noise that they keep hearing, so Jenna may have been around. Coz, dogs make whimper-y type noises, and I thought it made sense. So, she goes everywhere with the dog, just kinda as a safety thing. But doesn't she carry a white cane that blind people use? Also, about Ian's 'body'-you know how in Romeo and Juliet, when Juliet takes the potion to make her seem to her parents to be dead so she doesn't have to marry the guy she doesn't want to? My guess is that Ian somehow managed to get hold of something similar, then went to the woods and drank it for a 24 hour effect so the girls could see his 'dead body' and freak out. And he worked with makeup and stuff to create realistic-looking bruises and all that-if they can do it for films and stuff, surely a guy can do the same to freak out a few teenage girls. As for how he looked blue and oxygenless, if he's out in the woods in January (I understand it to be winter in January in America-can someone please correct me if I'm wrong?) then he'd be cold enough to look blue and all that-people's skin can turn slightly odd colours if cold enough. Just a few thoughts, and if anyone wants to post spoilers or correct me or whatever, that's cool :) SJ

Posted by SJ on July 03, 2009 at 05:44 AM EDT #

3 words to describe Killer.. OMG. I finished reading it last night. Yes, I know Im a fast reader. It's also cause it is so addiciting, you cant put the book down! I enjoyed it so much. And, by the end of the book, your not gonna be able to wait for Sara to make the next one! THE END IS UNBELIEVABLE, you wont even have a clue what will happen next! My favorite book out of them all. Best book Ive ever read, THATS for sure. I hope you guys love it as much as I did! xo, -A.

Posted by A on July 03, 2009 at 07:57 AM EDT #

Okay, as soon as june 30 came around I forced my mom into the car to get the boook, and i finished it in three hours! i was sosoooo excited to read it :D and I was so shocked by everything that happened! it's definitely one of the best books so far :] i didn't really think much of wilden until this book... maybe cause i was paying closer attention to like maya and melissa and jenna. but yeah, the book was amazinngggg. I can't wait for when the next books come out! and sara, are you ever coming to philly? oh! and pleasepleaseplease sara post the first chapter of heartless on here :D i wait forever for these awesome books to come out, and i finish them in like, a nanosecond. ahah :P i think that the girl in the woods that aria saved really was ali, or at least i hope so. it all leads to that, because the dna tests for the body never came, but maybe sara's just setting me up for a big surprise, as usual ;] i think that the twin theory is really good too, like when someone said that ali kept changing shirts in one of the flashbacks and she would forget things that had just happened... so a twin is definitely possible. ILOVETHISSERIESSSSS <3

Posted by JB on July 03, 2009 at 10:29 AM EDT #

i think that the girl that was in the woods really was ali, or at least i hope so. cause like they never had the dna tests for the body that was found.. the ring was the only evidence. but maybe sara's just setting me up to believe that for a big shockerrr. but and i also think that ali having a secret twin that's like psycho is a good theory too. like when someone said that in one of the flashbacks ali would randomly change shirts, or she would forget things that had just happened.

Posted by ilovepll on July 03, 2009 at 10:32 AM EDT #

i kinda had a feeling all along that allison was somehow still alive, but when i told all my friends this they thought i was insane. well, i can finally say "i told you so" with a huge smile on my face! also, i think melissa's behind the whole thing. could she be A? she's hiding something...big. also, does anyone know if the series is going to be continued? any more books coming out after killer?

Posted by Tash on July 03, 2009 at 10:34 AM EDT #

it's almost pathetic how quickly i read these books. i mean i wait for them to come out for a super long time, and then when i finallllly get it, i finish the book in like a nanosecond ! these books are so addictingggg, and i can't wait for january 19 :D sara, are you ever coming to philadelphia?

Posted by beccccca! on July 03, 2009 at 10:36 AM EDT #

tash, yes there's two more books coming out after killer. they're called heartless and twisted, and the next one comes out in january and the last one comes out in decemberrr.

Posted by JB on July 03, 2009 at 10:37 AM EDT #

Spolier..? kay. well honestly, i dont think ali has a twin thats a little bit much. but i do belive she lost her memory somehow or whateveer. but then again, would how would she not recognize her face on the news everywhere. but idk, i don't want to predict all this crazy stuff because that would ruin the next book.

Posted by sah on July 03, 2009 at 10:57 AM EDT #

Truth be told, I haven't read Killer yet. My bestie and I decided to re-read the entire series before we received Killer and read it, and I just started Wicked last night and my copy of Killer comes today. My friend finished it in about 7 hours, locking herself in her room until she finished it. I was out shopping with her yesterday and she started spazzing because she wanted to give me some spoilers, so I let her. I totally think Ali had a twin. I don't know how, I didn't read the story (keep that in mind) but it sounds like she did, and maybe it was her twin that died? - J

Posted by J on July 03, 2009 at 11:35 AM EDT #

That was seriously the greatest ending out of all of the books so far. The only problem is... Now I have to wait for the next one. o_0 Hurry and get it done so we can find out if Ali is REALLY alive or not. Because as in Pretty Little Liars goes; Not everything is as it seems. :P

Posted by Amie on July 03, 2009 at 11:59 AM EDT #

i finished killer it was beyond amazing but what the next book called and when does it come out????

Posted by blob on July 03, 2009 at 12:07 PM EDT #

I really think that Ali could be alive and maybe that night when Ali left the barn, Ian was there and maybe Jason... OH OH maybe Jason and Ian were fighting and Ian, by mistake, pushed Ali into the rock instead of Jason and Ali cracked her head which is what Spencer ment by "the crack" and so Ali lost her memory and that is why she didn't remember the girls!!!!. I still need to no why Ali left Naomi and Riley back then?? It never said why she did, it just said Ali left them because of a fight!! maybe the fight has something to do with something important! I dunno but i really want to know what the fight was about!!! -emm xoxo (: (:

Posted by emm on July 03, 2009 at 01:07 PM EDT #

Oh my God. This series is fing amazing. THE BEST series ever written! I KNEW Ali was alive. I just knew it. Like totally. This was the greatest cliffhanger ever. Oh and blob, the next book is called Heartless. And it's released on Jan 19th, 2010! Sooooo long from now.

Posted by Alison on July 03, 2009 at 01:31 PM EDT #

omgosh Sara!!! what are you doing to us! I just finished killer, it was insane! i guess i knew the whole time who "they" were and about Ali, but it was still so unexpected! i'm gonna go crazy waiting for the next one. Sara this is really cruel to do this to us. It just all seems so obvious, and Sara wouldn't do it like that, she has to have some sort of twist, she wouldn't introduce darren & ian as the killers so early if there is still 3 more books to come out.

Posted by Tabi on July 03, 2009 at 02:48 PM EDT #

I finished Killer yesterday and it was sooo awesome! OMG Ali's actually alive! I thought she was but I wasn't sure. I'm really sad about Jason, though. I liked him and Aria a lot, even though he's kind of psycho (I have no idea why) But I'm really happy about Hanna and Mike. I feel soooo bad for Spencer! She used all her college money and it was a scam!!!!! Her life sucks. I CANT WAIT TIL HEARTLESS!!!

Posted by Priya on July 03, 2009 at 03:15 PM EDT #

First of all, from all the spoilers I read ( seriously i don't understand people who hate it when they find out the end, it doesn't ruin anything ! ), i have many theories. Well first of all I always knew Jason and Wilden had something to do with this. Like Wilden was realy realy weird in the 5. Jason... was suspicious? But I think that Ali's mom has something to do with Spencer... However I'm 100 % sure Spencer is adopted or something of the sort. Kate I'm sure has something to do with A, 'cause about the last pages? I bet Mona knew from the beginning that Ali was alive. And that Ali manipulated her just like the rest of the girls. Maybe she realy did care about Hanna? Maybe she knew secrets about Mona and threatened her like she threatened the rest? I know it seems that I like Mona, which I don't, but I'm looking for alternatives, 'cause this series is soooooo twisted. I'm usually a pro at guessing at what happens in books but this is realy doing my head in. I just wanna read Killer! And also I don't know about the twin theorie about Ali... like maybe Jason was mad about it? That they shushed his other sister up... he actually hated Ali? And I think Melissa has something to do with the murder... In one of the books she mentions that she knew that Ian was cheating her with Ali... maybe she knew then, and wanted to take her revenge? So she killed the "twin" by accident... Jenna... Jenna... I have no idea. Will someone say something about Jenna please? I need more spoilers! I realy want to figure this out... even though it's praticaly impossible...

Posted by lalalala on July 03, 2009 at 04:20 PM EDT #

Maybe she realy did care about Hanna? Maybe she knew secrets about Mona and threatened her like she threatened the rest? I know it seems that I like Mona, which I don't, but I'm looking for alternatives, 'cause this series is soooooo twisted. I'm usually a pro at guessing at what happens in books but this is realy doing my head in. I just wanna read Killer! And also I don't know about the twin theorie about Ali... like maybe Jason was mad about it? That they shushed his other sister up... he actually hated Ali? And I think Melissa has something to do with the murder... In one of the books she mentions that she knew that Ian was cheating her with Ali... maybe she knew then, and wanted to take her revenge? So she killed the "twin" by accident... Jenna... Jenna... I have no idea. Will someone say something about Jenna please? I need more spoilers! I realy want to figure this out...

Posted by lalalala on July 03, 2009 at 04:22 PM EDT #

sorry but i think i put my comment as preview by accident. idk. how do i take it off?

Posted by lalalala on July 03, 2009 at 04:23 PM EDT #

omfg...i got Killer yesterday, and i finished it in like 6 hours, not all at once though**. i cannot belive the ending, but how could Ali be alive all those years?!i do believe that wilden adn jason are the "bad people", but really, if Ali was alive, why was her body found in the hole, and she was buried and everything too?? maybe like some other peopl said, she does have a twin, although that kind of doesnt go with the books. i CANNOT wait until the next book comes out, btw...does anyone know when it is?i saw one girl wirte tht its coming out in january, but thts a long time from now. if u know wen its coming out and what it will be called, please write a message so we all can find out....thank u for starting this series, its amazing!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by stephanie on July 03, 2009 at 05:11 PM EDT #

Wow killer was good...I think Melissa is with Ian somewhere in Rosewood. I do think Ali was in the house when Jason flipped on Aria. Like someone else said A is Ali and Ali contacted Aria making her come to the house but idkk. Umm...Hanna and mike?? ehh its alright. Whoa Issac's mom: phsyco. Poor Spence. Oh and whoever said that when Spencer pushed Ali that made her loose her memory caz Spencer heard a crack. idkk.

Posted by Morgan(: on July 03, 2009 at 05:31 PM EDT #

Wow. Killer was really good. I just hate how the girls hide everything. I wish Spencer would just ask her parents if she was adopted. I was so upset about what happened. She needs to ask Melissa too. As for Hanna I am happy about Mike but I dont think she should believe Kate. I feel like Maya and Emily ill have something and I feel Maya is in involved in this somehow. I really always thought Alison was alive. I could tell from the beginning Darren is involved. I want to know why Jena is involved and what Jason did. Ahh its killign me!

Posted by allison on July 03, 2009 at 07:37 PM EDT #

**********SPOILER ALERT************ omgg! i finished killer 2 days ago when i got itt and ahhh! so amazing. Now i want to give my opinion on what has happened... They said when they found the body it looked like Ali but the DNA tests haven't come back yet and so they just buried her. Maybe another girl that looked like Ali got killed and her body was dumped there. Ali was probably scared that someone wanted to kill her but got the other girl instead. So naturally she went into hiding. Spencer is probably a child where the parents tell the doctor how the baby would look. So the g-ma thought that wasn't natural and blah, blah blah so now Mrs. Hastings is still annoyed that she went and did that since the g-ma died. And Wilden and Jason.... pure genius! im so going to the book signing!!!! ahhh!!! yayy!

Posted by aliii on July 03, 2009 at 08:23 PM EDT #

Can someone please tell me the name of the book where Ali, Spencer, Hanna, Emily, and Aria pretend to be sisters and Ali's mom gets mad because of this and tells them that they shouldn't to that ? An if you can the page number too ?

Posted by alexandra on July 03, 2009 at 10:26 PM EDT #

Kind of spoiler alert: what if aria finding the yearbook was a set up? jenna and jason could be working together to trick aria because they know that she will tell the other girls. if the dog was jenna's dog by some chance, then they could have led her to the room and then the yearbook was conveniently sticking out; jason could've written the thing about wilden just to confuse them. that would explain why he was at her house and they were arguing, something to do with that. anyways, great book.

Posted by emily on July 03, 2009 at 10:38 PM EDT #

you know, we are all believing that what Spencer remembers from that night is true, but we shouldn't. She was dead set on the fact that Ian had killed Ali, and then when she thought about it more she became convinced that Jason was the one that was there. What if there were tons of people and Spencer doesn't remember them? Or what if the candle thing that Ali did had really worked, and Spencer imagined it all? Ah, this series is mind boggling.

Posted by emily on July 03, 2009 at 10:47 PM EDT #

spoiler: ok the book doesnt make any sense!First of all, Ian says that wilden and jason Killed Ali and set him up. Why doesnt that make sense to me? when you commit a muder you have to have a good motive. Why would wilden accept to muder ali with jason? Even if he was jasons friend i dont think that anyone would kill for his friend . And even if he didnt like Ian. Second of all, If the plan was to set Ian up why di the acusation only came up 5 or 4 years later?. And at last , if they had ''killed'' ali, and the girls saw Ali in the forrest , Who was the girl in the backyard?I really dont think that Sarah Shepard would be that stupid to put a Twin because that would be just OBVIOUS (for me anyways ) So in conclusion, i really think that theres ALOT more to the history then what we heard so far.... Dont u agreed? I like the books and all that . But sometimes Sarah sheppard really annoys me.

Posted by leticia on July 03, 2009 at 10:51 PM EDT #

you know, we are all believing that what Spencer remembers from that night is true, but we shouldn't. She was dead set on the fact that Ian had killed Ali, and then when she thought about it more she became convinced that Jason was the one that was there. What if there were tons of people and Spencer doesn't remember them? Or what if the candle thing that Ali did had really worked, and Spencer imagined it all? Ah, this series is mind boggling.

Posted by emily on July 03, 2009 at 10:51 PM EDT #

If you love PLL, check out this forum: prettylittleliars [dot] darkbb [dot] com

Posted by Linda on July 03, 2009 at 11:46 PM EDT #

It's true that Sara Shepard wouldn't do something that obvious... but would someone please tell me why Jason killed Ali? [ or a girl that looked like Ali ]. [ I haven't read the book ]. And will someone tell me what Jenna has to do with this? You know Ali could be A after all... she could have been in league with Mona... and let Mona be killed in her place. Kate probably been on this for very long... By the way has Hanna's and Lucas's relaitonship improved since? And what's this thing with isaac's mom refusing for Emily to see him? O.o Wow I'm realy lost, I just can't wait to read the book! Oh and I don't think that Melissa was lying... I think she might not be that bad after all... or is she? :|

Posted by phoeniiix on July 04, 2009 at 12:15 PM EDT #

<center>J'adore ces livres! Je ne suis fachee jamais parce que les livres sont tres amusantes! Killer a ete magnifique! Je veut Heartless maintenant! Ecrivez vite, s'il vous plait! TRANSLATION>> I love these books. I am never mad because these books are amusing. Killer is magnificent. I want Heartless now! Write fast, please! Oh, et, je ne pense pas que Ali a une soeur. On peut, mais c'est WAY OUTTA LINEEEE. COME TO FRANCE FOR SIGNINGS!

Posted by Kasey on July 04, 2009 at 12:34 PM EDT #

If you love PLL, check out this forum: prettylittleliars [dot] darkbb [dot] com !! If you love PLL, check out this forum: prettylittleliars [dot] darkbb [dot] com !! If you love PLL, check out this forum: prettylittleliars [dot] darkbb [dot] com !!

Posted by Linda on July 04, 2009 at 02:11 PM EDT #

If you love PLL, check out this forum: prettylittleliars [dot] darkbb [dot] com !!

Posted by Linda on July 04, 2009 at 02:12 PM EDT #

Alright i just finished wicked at 2 in the morning and i know that im not getting killer untill it comes out in paperback (suckss!) so i read the spoilers (they didnt ruin anything honestly my theories were pretty close haha) back to my pointtt.. about 'WICKED' and who A is : EVERYONE IS FORGETTING A HUGE CLUE GIVEN AT THE END! okay so on the last page 'what happens next...' A says "These pretty little bitches got everything i ever wanted, and now i'm going to make sure they get exactly what they deserve" so the info i have about A is that 1. A GREW UP IN ROSEWOOD 2. A IS JEALOUS OF THE GIRLS. THEY HAD EVERYTHING A WANTED BUT NEVER HAD!

Posted by Magda on July 04, 2009 at 03:13 PM EDT #

okay and also i dont think the email sent to spencer was REALLY ian. i think A was there when ian spoke to spencer about how the police know something. and since ian knew, he knew too much and when someone knows too much they get hurt/killed. so i think that email was really from A who made an account with ian's name and A killed him beforehand? its possible. (but i read a spoiler that ian's still alive?) well thats my theory. i cant wait till KILLER comes out in paperbackkkkkkkk!!!

Posted by Magda on July 04, 2009 at 03:14 PM EDT #

Spoiler Alert! I just finished killer! I have to wonder though.. The girl Aria brought back from the woods, Ali, maybe, said she got a text from A? How does Ali know A?? And why was Jason freaking out if Aria went into the main house? Was he hiding something?? Great Series Sara Shepard!!

Posted by Chelsea on July 04, 2009 at 03:15 PM EDT #

a thing about WICKED and who A is: EVERYONE IS MISSING A *HUGE* CLUE ABOUT WHO A IS AT THE END OF WICKED!! on the "what happens next" page..."these pretty little *****es got everything i ever wanted and now im going to make sure they get everything they deserve" A IS JEALOUS OF THEM. could it be this supposed twin who wanted to be just like them but was always hidden because alis parents were ashamed of her? maybe. i havent read killer yet so maybe my theories will change once i read it!

Posted by Magda on July 04, 2009 at 03:18 PM EDT #

AGHH! Uhh Spoiler Alert. I SOO predicted that Ali was still alive, check under Aria's comment thingy :]. Best one so far. Can't wait for more too come out. I always suspected Jason and Wilden.. but never really had information about them, so it was back burned. But, I wasn't as shocked though. Keep it up

Posted by Leslie on July 04, 2009 at 05:05 PM EDT #

I keep hearing about a possible twin. Now, that could be possible but why would they hide the twin? There's no possible reason. Plus, it would need to get out sometime and Spencer is her nextdoor neighbor so she'd have to know. It would make sense why she changed from a halter into a tee in one of the books but her mom could've made her change too. I'd believe the whole twin thing when I get a reason to have her hidden but there's no reason. I hope it's really Ali though! I just want to hear what she thinks because we've never heard from Ali herself. That would be really cool. But if it's Ali who was in the hole? Who was having the fight with Jason? And where did Ali go after her and Spencer had a fight? So, I really have no idea what to think. So, I believe that she has a twin but I don't. I'm just soooo confused right now. Hopefully November comes quick!!! I'm not sure if I can wait that long!!

Posted by Lizzie on July 04, 2009 at 05:25 PM EDT #

There's no way Ali had a twin. I'll explain why: Emily said when she was in 3rd grade that she saw Ali, her mom and Jason at the market... don't you think they would've ALL been out? Also, Ali said she wanted too run away, and how she didn't like her family.. so much that she was friends with Jenna, they had that abusive brother thing in common. Thus, Jenna knew he was going too the Radley place, back then. Which is why Jason might have been over her house. He thought Jenna had told Aria about him being at Radley's which was supposed to be a secret... But bback too Ali. They only ID'd her body because of the ring that was on the body's finger... which was a ring that Ali ALWAYS wore. So they didn't bother checking the DNA, because the parents thought they finally had closure. As for the body? I'm thinking they had someone else go in there. Are Wilden and Jason killers? Probably. Ian figured out Ali was alive. And, Wilden and Jason couldn't have that. So they "killed" him. Im thinking that Melissa might have bargained with them, since her and Ian are long time lovers. And she once had a thing with Jason. Whoever A is... I'm thinking Melissa is..(WHY? In this book A's been trying too help them solve what happened too Ali and not stalking them) A knows the secrets, and Jasona and Wilden found out that A was helping them and decided too kill them.. so why was Ali in the woods that was going too burn down. They realized that hiding the her, and the whole murder thing could all go away, if she did too. Hahaha. I think way too much, just a theory

Posted by Leslie on July 04, 2009 at 05:25 PM EDT #

Oh my god. I just finished reading it now and I cannot believe it! At first I was like, uh I don't think its going to be that shocking, but I was wrong! Such a shocking ending!

Posted by xElleinad on July 04, 2009 at 08:38 PM EDT #

OHMYGOD! KILLER WAS SO INTENSE! it was by far the best book! SPOILERS!: and whats with the new A? I never would've thought she'd help them figure it out instead of torturing them with their secrets. and wow i knew darren wilden was in on it some how, but i wonder who killed Ali IF ANYONE EVEN DID CONSIDERING THE ENDING! i read it in one night it was amaaazing!

Posted by victoria on July 04, 2009 at 08:53 PM EDT #

Wow! iI didn't see that coming! Ali alive? I wonder who's body they fond! where has she been hinding for like 4 years?!?!?!?! Can't wait for the next book!

Posted by Melissa on July 04, 2009 at 09:39 PM EDT #

Wow! iI didn't see that coming! Ali alive? I wonder who's body they fond! where has she been hinding for like 4 years?!?!?!?! Can't wait for the next book!

Posted by Melissa on July 04, 2009 at 09:42 PM EDT #

okai, new theory: jason must have been HIDING ali. ( i dont believe ali has a twin) remember how he got all madd wen emily bumped his car just a little bit? he was MADD, & later on emily thought 'wat if something was in there' what if it was ALI? and then wen aria went to his apartment & he acted all madd what if he was hiding ALI there? i dont think he would hurt her, so he can't be tha one who supposedly "killed" her. but tha body that was discovered in tha hole, im still questioning about that. AND WAT HAPPENED TO IAN? he was dead, & now he's emailing spencer??? its so confusing....BUT I LOVE IT.

Posted by Urma =D on July 04, 2009 at 10:36 PM EDT #

I was on SARA SHEPARD's Twitter page & she said that Heartless (the 7th PLL book) comes out on November 9th! NOT January!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by Grace on July 04, 2009 at 11:18 PM EDT #

Ali's mom is Spencer's real mom but Spencer's dad is her real dad[thats why he saved up money for her college]..hence Spencer's mom hates her...also ali's mom asked spencer at the beginning,''You are Spencer right?''...A cant be Maya or jenna as Jenna is dark haired and so is Maya...Jason has a twin brother[the one who did not recognize emily and was mean to her]...the only reason he did not want to go with Aria on the train was becoz he was meeting Ali..in wicked Ian had told spencer that it was not such a good idea for him to tell melissa 'his little sob story' hence Melissa might have killed ali..the police are hiding the fact that ali has a twin.

Posted by Lyra on July 04, 2009 at 11:50 PM EDT #

This was hand down my favorite book of the series. I cannot WAIT until the next one. The twists and everything made it impossible for me to put the book down. The ending....holy...wow. I'm so into these books my freakin heart stopped when I read that :p I really know how Ian's death was all faked. Because that was really convincing ahaha. I've been trying to put the pieces together. Picture of Ali with Jenna. Wilden at confession. Spencer's fake mom. Jason in the coocoo hut. Gahhhh I needz the next book before I go insane haha! Sara - [you have an awesome name, by the way ;D] these are my favorite books in the world. I got like 5 of my friends addicted too. And I cannotttt WAIT for the next onee :DDDD

Posted by Sara on July 05, 2009 at 10:51 AM EDT #

OMG i think that Spencer real mom is Mrs.Dilarents, Ali's mom

Posted by Cecilia on July 05, 2009 at 01:01 PM EDT #

baah! killer was soo freaking awesome! after reading i was really shocked and really confused. there are so many secrets that are still left uncovered. i have so many questions! (spoiler?) i think one of them should really talk to Naomi and Riley and why they broke up with ali before. Naomi must know something about the whole jenna-ali thing too because she was there in the picture A sent them. and did anyone notice the last A text was in a different font? maybe sara was trying to show that it really wasn't A? maybe wilden? knowing about the texts and trying to lead them to the woods, as a trap? (maybe that was already obvious) so maybe there's no doubt that he would do it again. the girls already told him too much, and knowing he has something to do with it, they are not safe at all, especially because he is of a higher authority being a police and all.

Posted by Angela on July 05, 2009 at 02:42 PM EDT #

you know what i just realized? Jason D goes into enraged trances....and so does spencer. pushing her sis down the stairs? then not remembering stuff she did after? creepy

Posted by carlie on July 05, 2009 at 02:44 PM EDT #

...and for the whole twin theory, it does make sense, but isn't it too obvious? to be honest, as much as it would fit in, i would be disappointed if that were the case, i hope sara has another explanation to everything that would keep us off guard until we read the answer. i think jenna has something to do with it (maybe being A) but the helpful A. i think she wants to help the girls out and tell them something, like when she was standing out of Aria's house wanting to tell her something but didn't. im not sure if ian is alive or not. im really confused, there's so much more to know and only 2 more books. can't wait to see what happens next! sara, please try again to come to toronto! i was excited for that day till it was cancelled :( i know alot of people who are fans of yours here, many whom i so called 'created' (; hehe but anyways thank you for such a great series! -angela

Posted by Angela on July 05, 2009 at 02:45 PM EDT #

OMG!!!! You're finally coming to my city!! Ahhh I'm so excited! I'll see you July 11th!

Posted by Hill on July 05, 2009 at 05:04 PM EDT #

Visit the PLL forum and register for a total new Pretty Little Liars experience : http://prettylittleliars.forumotion.com/forum.htm

Posted by Forum on July 05, 2009 at 05:05 PM EDT #

SPOILER: OMG!!! this book was crazy!! i didn't think any of this would have happened!! and my theory is that jason might have faked ali's death. but whose body is it?? and you know how the girls always see blonde hair? i bet its ali!!! and thats who hannah saw in the woods in wicked. I LOVE THIS BOOK!!! CANT WAIT FOR THE NEXT ONE!!!

Posted by amy on July 05, 2009 at 08:21 PM EDT #

AND. did anyone read the end?? like the note from A part. cuz now it seems like she's PRETENDING to ruin their lives...STRANGE!!

Posted by amy on July 05, 2009 at 08:23 PM EDT #

omg! i just finished the book today and i only started yesterday these books are so good. SPOILER ALERT: i cant believe that wilden is evil thought he became good from his former days at rosewood high. I cant believe wilden and jason killed alison. Jason is pretty creepy and i think maybe ali had a twin sister that was never talked about and hidden from the town. Because theres a part in the book when they try to steal alis flag and jason leaves the house and alis parents leave to and alis outside and a light is turned on in her room and then goes off. But my question is why would they hide a family member from the rest of the town? oh and the girl in the one pick with blond hair that her face isnt shown with ali and jenna in it cld be the ali look alike not naomi This book is awesome and i have so many more qsts unanswered its crazy cant wait 4 the nxt one in jan.

Posted by josette on July 05, 2009 at 08:27 PM EDT #

I think that Ali does not have a twin. She can't have a twin that wouldn't make sense. I think that the girl in the photo was Spencer or Mellisa who knows.

Posted by Cecilia on July 05, 2009 at 09:04 PM EDT #

SPOILER I think that Ali is alive and she lives with the DiLaruentis's. When Aria was with Jason at the Train Station the news title came on and said Are the diLaruentis's hiding something? so jason got freaked becasue they were hding ali and he ran out. Also he freaked when aria was in his apartment becasue he thouhgt she went in the main house and might have seen ali. I think Ali isnt aloud to go out and at the end the girl in the woods said someone had sent her a note. so i think ali got a note saying to go to the woods but she wasnt aloud so she got into a big hooded sweatshirt and that is why the girl was in a sweatshirt. The girl at the end is def ali.

Posted by Bridget on July 05, 2009 at 10:38 PM EDT #

I personally find this twin theory unorignal and kinda preticable. Sara is an amazing author who comes up the most exicting twists and plots. I think Ali is alive, and she just has memory lost. Has anybody ever seen the show, Criminal Minds? Well there was an episode where the family was hiding that the oldest son killed the little brother cause he had mental issues and they were trying to keep the family together and not lose both kids. The older brother is like Jason and Ali's parents are like boys parents in the episode. So its kinda the same thing with Ali's family. But I think Ali's parents don't know Ali is still alive. Ali's family is hiding the fact Jason killed Ali, but he really didnt and I think Jason believed he and Wilden did. So thats my super long theory.

Posted by ginger on July 05, 2009 at 11:13 PM EDT #

OMFG. im in like complete shock, i JUST finished it, and im like going insane. I meen i just had to wait like 6 months to get this book, i finally have it, and it has ANOTHER intence ending. Im seriously dying to read the next book, i like NEED it. But like someone said before, Jason did seem very protective about Aria going into the main hoouse, maybe Ali was hiding there or something, like in a basement. Who knows. Im just still in shock, and k its not a twin :P, that would just be stupid. It has to be her, like its not going to become some stupid thing. im SURE its her. Something probably did happen to her memory, who knows. ( Also about the DNA, maybe Wilden made something up, saying he got the results and that it was her dna, not having any proof.) Idk, who knows. I just cant wait for the next book :)

Posted by Nicole on July 05, 2009 at 11:48 PM EDT #

OMFG. i just finished killer. this is INSANE! best book so far! ahhh. i need the next book! :D

Posted by lindsay on July 06, 2009 at 12:19 AM EDT #

ok so I dont think ali has a twin and jason is mental not ali and i think jenna was keeping ALI in her house/jason's man house but spencer does look like ali so maybe spencers "dad" couldnt get her "mom" preggers so her mom had an affair with Ali's dad wich was probably why ali always seemed so nasty to spence and ali blocked out the whole time she was with her old friends when she hit her head she could have reconized them and since she hasnt seen them in almost four years that she completly doesnt reconized them So I highly doubt that ali has a twin jason would have spilled it and I think the whole reason wilden is a cop is because if they ever found "ali's" body that he would make sure that he and Ian never seemed suspicious as much as people may want to belief that aki has a twin they dont cause it would have came out or they would have seen "her" before in pictures and stuff

Posted by Mickerz on July 06, 2009 at 12:35 AM EDT #

I don't think Wilden and Jason had anything to do with Alis killings. Its just wwwaaaayyy to obvious now. I think they killed Ian. I have no idea who this fake Ian person is. Melissa? She did give Spencer the labtop. I have always been very suspicious of Melissa, especially after the beach house incident with Spence. Now onto this whole Ali thing. I have no idea if it is her or a look-a-like or a twin. She could be A, and could have been pretending not to recognize them. Or she could have forgotten them. I mean its extremely suspicious that she is dressed in black and hooded in the middle of the woods no matter who she is. And if she is a twin... why would anyone be trying to kill her? Its not like anyone knows about her. AND if its not a psycho twin and IS ali... who is that girl that they found in ditch?

Posted by casey on July 06, 2009 at 01:58 AM EDT #

Oh and heartless is now coming out in November, NOT january. Two less months of waitingg!!!

Posted by Casey on July 06, 2009 at 02:00 AM EDT #

OMMGGG! imm speachlessss.! SPOILER: ali alivee !? i hoped she was the whollleee time , butt imm dieing to know what was going on with jason and jenna ! andd wilden !? and ii kinda think A is helping them . ! like yeahhh , omgg !!!! i cannot wait for heartless and twisted.

Posted by Cali on July 06, 2009 at 02:34 AM EDT #

Darn myself for not being able to keep myself from reading these comments! Grr. I couldn't help it!! Well from what i read -___- .... OMG!!!!! I cannot wait to get the book.

Posted by desiree on July 06, 2009 at 03:12 AM EDT #

OMG. the ending was soo surprising!!! i couldn't belive it. i always new she was alive. and i knew officer wilden was involved in her disappearance. i just didnt expect jason to be involed!! i dont think she has a twin. how could people not know and why would they keep it a secret? i think she is pretending or has gone through memory loss. and i also know jenna and maya are involved. i just dont know how. and i dont know who the new A is. however whoever it is is on their side. A wanted them to find this stuff out so its not officer wilden or jason. im thinking maybe jenna? but she is blind so maya could be watching them for her!!!

Posted by jordyn on July 06, 2009 at 06:19 AM EDT #

SPOILER! I think it may have actually been ali, because in the book it said that ali told ian she wanted to run away, so maybe she did just that. and remember all through the book they heard giggles? maybe that was ali, if not i think jenni has been creeping on them and she is A. but how is the time capsule flag a really big hint??

Posted by onyx on July 06, 2009 at 09:01 AM EDT #

if ali is alive, who's body did they barry?

Posted by nowelle on July 06, 2009 at 09:04 AM EDT #

SPOILER!!! I think that Ali is definatly alive. She was probably hiding in the main house. She probably did not reconigze the girls because it was dark outside and she was to scare to pay attention. Spencer was definatly adopted by Ali's mom, because when the time capsal thing Ali's mom asked if that was Spencer then went inside and slammed the door. Also Spencer lives right next to the Dilarents maybe so that her real mom could see her. I also wish that the time capsul flag had more of a clue!!!

Posted by Cecilia on July 06, 2009 at 10:35 AM EDT #

Ali is definatily alive!!

Posted by Cecilia on July 06, 2009 at 11:52 AM EDT #

i dont think jenna is blind and just cause ppl have to be in school doesnt mean she HAD to go to rose wood????? ****SPOILER ALERT: the whole twin theory is over. Every child under 16 has to be enrolled in school and if Alison had a sister she would have to go to Rosewood Day. Maybe its a cousin? Posted by nutmeg on July 02, 2009 at 01:08 AM EDT

Posted by megan on July 06, 2009 at 12:48 PM EDT #

If you love PLL, check out this forum: prettylittleliars [dot] darkbb [dot] com !!

Posted by Linda on July 06, 2009 at 12:52 PM EDT #

o my gosh im sooo excited to read this book. i cant wait im goin asap to get it :) yay i love this series...

Posted by maylynn on July 06, 2009 at 12:58 PM EDT #

OMG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I love these books so much but the ending of Killer is killing me!!! I need to know what is going on! I definately think Ali is alive and the next book is going to be soooo amzing! Does anyone know when the next book comes out???

Posted by Vicki on July 06, 2009 at 01:50 PM EDT #

i love this series.. everyone seems to be giving their theories, im not sure about the whole ali/twin sis/A thing...but i dont thnk that spencer is adopted, she cant be cause in the 5th book aria looks @ the portrait in spencers house and recognises the ski sloped nose to be the same as spencers. althou' i think,spencers father is her real father, but her mothers not. her father had an affair and spencers their 'love child'. so according to the grandma spencers not technically a natural-born as it was with someone else outside the marriage. that could be why spencers father is much nicer to her than her mother is... Oooh also guys i wanna suggest a book 2 u all, its reaaalllyy good!! it's called 'Stolen' by lucy christopher, i dunno why but it kinda reminds me of this series, perhaps because of all the twists, anyway give it a go, u wont regret it, i promise

Posted by kristina on July 06, 2009 at 01:56 PM EDT #

OMG OMG OMG!!! i have ranted and raved about her books! i love this series its so amazing! like i cant even put it into words!!!!!!!!!!! I tell all my friends how much they should love it!!! because omg i love her books! OMG! KILLER! WAS AMAZING! WHO KNEW THAT THAT WOULD HAPPEN AT THE END?!!!!!!!!! and i so knew the ppl throughout the book like the 2 ppl who hatred ian! grrrr omg omg WHEN IS THE NEXT ONE COMING OUT?!!!!!

Posted by Gabi on July 06, 2009 at 02:10 PM EDT #

OMG OMG OMG! i here she's not making another book! but she's going to make the books a tv series on abc family!!!!! that makes me mad! i wanna know whats gonna happen!! plus there not gonna look like they do in my head haha but ya someone please tell me if this is true?!

Posted by Gabi on July 06, 2009 at 02:34 PM EDT #

(SPOILER ALERT!) Regarding the ending of killer: I think that Ali had (has) a twin. The photo A sent Emily had an unidentified blond in the picture. It was said to be Naomi, and as my friend suggested, Mona, but it was probably Ali's double. If Ali's sister was friends with Jenna, that would explain the Ali- Jenna connection. When Aria was with Jason, she talked to him about the time they saw eachother at school. The secretary told Jason his sister was on the phone for him, but Aria had seen Ali enter the school earlier that day. Maybe it was Jason's sister, just not Ali. Also, Jenna may have said Ali has sibling problems, but she didn't specify what kind or with whom. Maybe it was someone different from whom everybody thought. However, if it really is Ali alive, then I'm dying to know who's body was really in that whole.

Posted by Taylor (SPOILER ALERT!) on July 06, 2009 at 04:53 PM EDT #

So, does anyone know if there is going to be another book after Killer? I wouldn't think she would stop writting after that ending! There are still way to many loose ends!

Posted by Amy on July 06, 2009 at 05:35 PM EDT #

Ok, after reading allllll 166 (or something of that sort) comments, this is what I think. I really don't think that Ali has a twin, that's just a bit too out there. I think that it really was in the end, that she's not dead. I think that she has been with Jason the whole time, which is why he freaked when Aria went into the appartment. I think that Wilden and/or Jason hurt her the night that everyone thought she was killed, and Jason took her somewhere (like the Poconos) to hide her. When they hurt her, she lost her memory that's why she didn't reconize them. As for who the girl found in the hole, wearing Ali's ring, I'm not sure. I do think that Jason was the one in the phyc school, which is why he was so insulted by Aria asking him to the Radley opening. That explains the supposed 'sibling issues' that Ali told Jenna about. Wilden is without a doubt hiding something, for that matter so is Jason. I'm trying to speculate TOO much and just let myself be surprised when I read Heartless! (JANUARY 19, 2010!!!!)

Posted by MacKenzie on July 06, 2009 at 06:47 PM EDT #

WOW tht was a surprise ending....i was so mad tht it just stopped:)!! ahh im going to go insane! when does the next book come out? :)

Posted by Abby on July 06, 2009 at 06:50 PM EDT #

So truly I am wondering if Mona was actually A?? Maybe Ali has been out there all this time and when the girls were getting close to figuring out who A was Ali had a secret on Mona, making Mona take the blame for A by manipulating her into doing it!! So yah maybe Mona did love Hanna in a friend way but Ali got to her and made her take the blame for it!! Also people are saying Jenna may be A?? I think she is totally cause she was outside Aria's house at the baby shower and it seemed like she was watching the house..so maybe she is not blind like a lot of people are saying!! As for Ian and Widen, Widen is weird but not murder weird, just like he is protecting something..or someone.. I think Ian is dead and someone got a hold of his phone and is saying stuff to make the girls crazy cause they knew he was dead!! :) :) :)

Posted by emm on July 06, 2009 at 06:55 PM EDT #

okay so i just got back from borders book store got the last book they had and i couldnt wait started reading it in the car... so far this book is effin uhh-mazzing!!!!!!

Posted by maylynn on July 06, 2009 at 08:35 PM EDT #

****THIS MAY CONTAIN SPOILERS****So I just finished Killer and all I can say is OH MY FREAKIN GOSH!!!!!!!! Sara Shepard you are an AMAZING writer! Every single detail that you put is another clue, another twist, another brain teaser. When I read this book my heart beats faster as if I'M the one being stalked by a person named "A" and dealing with a chilling, spine tingling mystery that involved a past best friend. I literally tell EVERYONE I know about this series because its just so dang amazing! Killer was no exception, every word had me thinking and questioning who the killer might be. I felt so bad for Spencer, her parents are b****** and I really was hoping that Olivia was her mom so she could be happy. The fact that she scammed Spencer out of her money was SO UNEXPECTED!!!! And even though I knew Wilden was suspicious, I had no idea he was friends with Jason or that Jason might be mental! I mean, how do you come up with this stuff? And of course the ending was MIND BLOWING! Ali might be ALIVE? This whole time? I'm so jealous of you brain Sara, your so clever and you really know how to make a good mystery novel, putting all the right twists in all the right places. Ahhh I can't wait for the next one! January is not soon enough! <3

Posted by thatonegirl on July 06, 2009 at 10:08 PM EDT #

And even though I knew Wilden was suspicious, I had no idea he was friends with Jason or that Jason might be mental! I mean, how do you come up with this stuff? And of course the ending was MIND BLOWING! Ali might be ALIVE? This whole time? I'm so jealous of you brain Sara, your so clever and you really know how to make a good mystery novel, putting all the right twists in all the right places. Ahhh I can't wait for the next one! January is not soon enough! <3 Oh and also to even though the twin theory make sense, a part of me hopes its not true. After all, you are known for your incredible surprises!

Posted by thatonegirl on July 06, 2009 at 10:12 PM EDT #

Please somebody help me I haven't read Killer yet !! So do you think Jason molested Ali? What was going on between Ali and Ian !! ?? Theories and what you learned in Killer are totally welcomed !!! Please help me I want to know !!

Posted by Cindy !!!! on July 07, 2009 at 12:19 AM EDT #

OMG! That was intense my theory kept changing. I ended up being half right cause I thought Jason was involved in the "supposed" murder. I also think Jenna is A or Ali was actually pretending to be Jenna considering how big those glasses were. I remember in one of the books A said that there was a J in his/her name, so I definitely think Jenna. But January?! I don't I could stand that! I'm dieing to know what's next! I know Jenna is involved in some way, being a key role, but I don't know how. I think the twin thought is really good, but I want Ali alive for some strange reason. Love PPL! <3 xx

Posted by Nikita on July 07, 2009 at 01:19 AM EDT #

OMG! That was intense my theory kept changing. I ended up being half right cause I thought Jason was involved in the "supposed" murder. I also think Jenna is A or Ali was actually pretending to be Jenna considering how big those glasses were. I remember in one of the books A said that there was a J in his/her name, so I definitely think Jenna. But January?! I don't I could stand that! I'm dieing to know what's next! I know Jenna is involved in some way, being a key role, but I don't know how. I think the twin thought is really good, but I want Ali alive for some strange reason. Love PPL! <3 xx

Posted by Nikita on July 07, 2009 at 01:25 AM EDT #

OMG! That was intense my theory kept changing. I ended up being half right cause I thought Jason was involved in the "supposed" murder. I also think Jenna is A or Ali was actually pretending to be Jenna considering how big those glasses were. I remember in one of the books A said that there was a J in his/her name, so I definitely think Jenna. But January?! I don't I could stand that! I'm dieing to know what's next! I know Jenna is involved in some way, being a key role, but I don't know how. I think the twin thought is really good, but I want Ali alive for some strange reason. Love PPL! <3 xx

Posted by Nikita on July 07, 2009 at 01:27 AM EDT #

ok... so for everyone that is saying that the twin thing cant be true because it is WAY too obvious, i agree. Sara Shepard wouldn't make it so easy to figure out. She is doing exactly what she did before the girls thought Ian was the killer, making us believe that Spencer killed Ali, then that Melissa did, but it was never either of them. If the series was so obvious, then it wouldn't be good. Clearly, Sara is going to have a reasonable explanation for all of this that is so crazy that none of us would EVER think of it. But Killer was absolutely AMAZING and i cant wait for Heartless to come out in January! I LOVE PRETTY LITTLE LIARS :)

Posted by Kelly :) on July 07, 2009 at 01:38 AM EDT #

To Alexandra, re; the We Are All Secretly Sisters game the girls played-it's mentioned in Wicked, pp. end of 143/start of 144. :) Sara Shepard is brilliant 2 come up with these books-I'm dying to read Killer but to my knowledge it isn't yet out in NZ. I hope it's out soon-I'm deliberately reading the spoilers and every spoiler I read makes me wanna read the whole book lol...

Posted by SJ on July 07, 2009 at 03:37 AM EDT #

That was the most craziest f'ing book ever!!!!!! i loved it though, all the twist and turns!!! just lovely if you ask me! ;) !*!*!*!**!*!*SPOILER ALERT BABY!*!*!**!*! WOWZERS, it was Wilden and Jason, and then that Ali stunt at the end!!! i mean CRA-ZAY. hehe. But i really like Isaac and Emily, they were such an awesome couple, dont make them break up for good. *puppie eyes* i mean Isaacs mom is like freaking mommy dearest. haha, i cant believe she CUT OUT EMILYS HEAD OUT OF THE PICTURE! and then went to AppleBees and like went all Bio*** mode! :) and i seriously feel bad for Spencer, because (1) she has no money in her college account or whatev, (2) her so-called-biological-mom, could be some freak stranger that lied to her, and (3) her mom will kill her for sneaking in her dads office, and getting all that info that was none of her beez wax!!! ooohhh, wait and the whole thing with Andrew! *ouch* And oooohhh, man that was so cute, the whole thing with Hanna and Mike, they are hilarious, with there own little twisted humor, and i think its funny how they just get each other!!! and i really liked the fact that Aria and Jason were getting along, and then went on actual dates!!! i still want them to go out, (i know what your thinking im crazy) but i think he was wwwwaaayyyyy better then (!perv alert!) Xavier. but then again he did go off on her in the apartment. hhhhmmmm 2nd thought, im not so sure! and now the questions.........Who the heck is "a"?????? i mean at first A was being all nice and was just giving them clues to who was Ali's supposed killer, but then it turns out Ali isn't dead....so was A leading them to think things? And was Jasons first love Melissa? and was Wilden talking about Ian being messed up, in the yearbook, because he took Melissa from Jason? or was he talking about Ian hooking up with Ali? and i personally think that Ian is alive! okay now that i think of it, i think that this whole thing started off with a love triangle of some sort! like Melissa kissed Jason (and probably did more) then Melissa started liking Ian, and probably dropped Jason, like yesterdays news! idk just a thought. hahahaha. but keep FREAKING WRITING, YOUR HEELLA GOOD WITH THE CREATIVITY OF THIS STORY!!! and i cant !!!!wait!!!! for Heartless (if thats what the name for the next PLL's bookie is called).

Posted by Nessa ;) on July 07, 2009 at 04:57 AM EDT #

okay, i LOVE this book, it was.......so exciting and intense!!! i dont know who mentioned it but, that would be crazy if Emily got prego from Isaac, i mean they did do it, hahaha!! but it would feel like the book would lose its element in a sense idt i can explain why though. also i feel toottallly bad for Spencer, poor girl doesnt know who to trust anymore! life just seems to get confusing for her!!! and Hanna i am like UBER happy for her and Mike i hope they pull through (unlike Lucas, i mean good guy, just not for Hanna)!!! Aria i was happy for her when she took a stand against Xavier, but then i had a bad feeling about Jason, so she kinda is pretty much stuck! (!PERV! OR !PHYSCO!) and Ali being back, well that was just......i cant put it in words, just insane!!! i mean could everybody be right, with the whole twin scenerio, or could she really just simply lost her memory??? i think she fell and hit her head, but didnt die, just got knocked out, then Jason carried her home with MAYBE the help of Darren (Wilden) amd when she woke up couldnt remeber anything!!!! idk just a thought.

Posted by Nessa ;) on July 07, 2009 at 05:15 AM EDT #

i just read "killer", and all i have to say is... I KNEW IT! I KNEW IT ALL ALONG! well i hoped so much at least, i remember in one of the books it said that they'd have to "wait to get the DNA testing", and then i thought for sure she was alive. but then books past and i thought they had already done the DNA testing since it felt like so much time had gone by, but then i read "they still hadn't done the DNA testing" AND I KNEW! :D i'm absolutely obsessed with these books, i suggest them to basically everyone i know haha, i find myself wanting to even hide under the covers at some parts, it's not only funny, realistic, and addictive, it's scary in a good way.

Posted by Molly on July 07, 2009 at 06:47 AM EDT #

Spoiler- Remember when Ali hypnotized the girls in book 1? What if she hypnotized Spencer into thinking that she had a fight with Ian or Jason? Or she hypnotized them so she could meet Ian. In Killer, Ian tells Spencer and her friends what happened, but Ian can't be believed either because he was drunk. I also think that maybe Ali had a fight with her twin. Ali's twin might have been ruining things for Ali by taking on her persona and other stuff, and Ali lost it and killed her.Ali went into hiding after what she realized she did, and never came out until Jason or Wilden sent her a note to meet them in the woods. When Spencer pushed Ali against the wall, she had memory failure and forgot the girls. I think it was Ali in the mental institution because she hated her twin, and Jason was not crazy at the time and visited her. *****If Ali had a twin, why did she never write about it in her diary? I think she did have a twin, but I am still wondering*****

Posted by LW on July 07, 2009 at 10:51 AM EDT #

SPOILER ALERT well i don't think ali has a twin, and i think jenna was hiding her and that they are both A because jenna would have known whats going on with them and ali knows information on them since they were bff's. remember how it said ali was a good liar..? and maybe not but i knew wilden was suspious but not like that! anyway, say what you think of this and stuff.. can't wait for the next one and if you like this series you might like the private series, about murder at private school.. it is excellent.

Posted by Claire on July 07, 2009 at 11:14 AM EDT #

PS- When Emily was going to Ian's trial in Wicked, Emily said she saw blue eyes like Ali's in a car. What if it was Ali/twin, and Jenna was hiding her?

Posted by LW on July 07, 2009 at 01:02 PM EDT #

<<<Spoiler Alert>>> okay so when i started reading perfect, a while back, i was thinking that spencer and ali are sisters, because someone (i dont know who, but i think it was ali) said she had sibling issues, and spencer and ali fought A LOT. Also, Spencer ''blocked'' out events that happened in her life, maybe she didnt remeber that she was ali's sister (twin) and that she had been adopted by the Hastings.

Posted by Karin on July 07, 2009 at 01:38 PM EDT #

SPOILER ALERT i Lovee this seriress but i cant believe what happned i think ali is alove cause jason was soo worked up that she didnt go thru the main entrancee and obiously if ali is the new A then shes trying to help themm and she doesnt want them to kow shes alive so she made sure she didt go thru the main entance so she wouldnt get seen .... and earlier in the book they said that the DNA results hadn t come back yet ,, but wow ..., cant waiit i just got the book yester day and i stayed up till 330 am reading it ... i lovee itt sooo pllzz someone respond to mee an tell me what you think bout my theroy ???? byeess kisses!! -A lol jks jks .. mii name is ashleey and A is my signature on my cell

Posted by A (ashley) on July 07, 2009 at 01:59 PM EDT #

Anybody know when the next one comes out?

Posted by Sam on July 07, 2009 at 02:37 PM EDT #

OMG im thinking that ali did have a twin and he twin was pretending to be ali all the time to get back at her and the parents only enrolled ali in school and one twin went to skool each day and it was the twin that had the affair with ian pretenfin to be ali to eget her in trouble and she pribably didnt mention her in her diary because iy was the one place where ali could e ali wthout anyone else in her life except her and her best friends and everytime "ali" threanted all them with there secrets it was the twin and the real ali is the new A and is trying to help them and that the real ali allways wanted them to be friends and the twin had ruined there friendship hence sibling problems ..and that made ali madd and she killed herrr and put her body in the hiole and framed ppl but i knpow i thi9nk way to ,uch but it all makes sence in MY headd..

Posted by Ashleeey on July 07, 2009 at 02:41 PM EDT #

its so mona!!! i bet its mona!!!!

Posted by preppygrl on July 07, 2009 at 03:44 PM EDT #

Spoiler alert(kinda) I think that it truly is Ali that the girls saw in the woods. Maybe whatever happened that night caused some memory damage so she couldn't recognize the girls. I think Jason has anger issues. maybe he is bipolar. Maybe Ali got hurt or knocked unconscious, but the boys thought they killed her. She could have just woken up later confused and disoriented.

Posted by Kit-Kat on July 07, 2009 at 04:42 PM EDT #

no preppygirl monas DEAD wowww. and sara shepard said this A is much much more sinister & NOT trying to help the girls

Posted by KK on July 07, 2009 at 05:53 PM EDT #

Heres a hint: I'm alive. luv ya- xoxo ~Ali~

Posted by Alison DiLaurentis on July 07, 2009 at 05:56 PM EDT #

omg!!!! i didnt belive the whole twin thing but reading other comments i totally do now. that book emily found was the sighn in sheet for people visiting the hospital i think. jason was visiting his other sister. (Alis twin). however im confused as to whos body they found. was it Alis or her twin? will someone please respond by answering my question? and someone made a comment on spencers mom cheating on her husband with mr. dilaurentis and thats why spencer looks like Ali and thats why her mom is harsher on spencer than melissa (because she feels guilty.) i think that idea is interesting and could be true. who do you guys think A is cause they keep hearing giggles and flashes of blond hair. ( Ali has blond hair but it cant be her because she is dead or is having memory loss). In wicked at the end of the book, when they were looking for spencer in the woods they kept hearing wimpering. DOGS WIMPER. AND JENNA HAS A DOG!! WHY WAS JENNA THERE IN THE WOODS? BECAUSE SHES A??? IDK. AND HANNA SAID THE GROUND SMELLED LIKE DOG POOP

Posted by jordyn on July 07, 2009 at 06:36 PM EDT #

omg!!!! i didnt belive the whole twin thing but reading other comments i totally do now. that book emily found was the sighn in sheet for people visiting the hospital i think. jason was visiting his other sister. (Alis twin). however im confused as to whos body they found. was it Alis or her twin? will someone please respond by answering my question? and someone made a comment on spencers mom cheating on her husband with mr. dilaurentis and thats why spencer looks like Ali and thats why her mom is harsher on spencer than melissa (because she feels guilty.) i think that idea is interesting and could be true. who do you guys think A is cause they keep hearing giggles and flashes of blond hair. ( Ali has blond hair but it cant be her because she is dead or is having memory loss). In wicked at the end of the book, when they were looking for spencer in the woods they kept hearing wimpering.

Posted by jordyn on July 07, 2009 at 06:37 PM EDT #

Okay remember in killer or wicked that Ian said that the police were hiding something, ithink that they were hiding the DNA evidence and that ali was really alive. It's just a theory.

Posted by Hanna Marlin on July 07, 2009 at 06:45 PM EDT #

Re Jordyn's question- I think that they found Ali, because (I think that) Ali killed her twin because she thought the twin was screwing around w/ her life. The twin was taking on her persona, and Ali hated that, so Ali just snapped and killed her. She ran away after she realized what she did, and came to the woods when someone sent her a note. Just my theory. Not sure what really happened.

Posted by LW on July 07, 2009 at 07:38 PM EDT #

How old is Mike Montgomery? And what happened to savannah and Lucas!!

Posted by katie on July 07, 2009 at 10:45 PM EDT #

omg i finshed it and was awsome!!!!! i think i no wwho killed ali or is she killed. please hurry up with the next one i need to read it soon!!!!!! thanks for writing these books they rule!!!!!!

Posted by rebecca on July 07, 2009 at 11:09 PM EDT #

SPOiLER ALERT:: omqqq!!! Ali is alive!!!! I think the DiLaurentis's have ALOT of secrets! .. or maybe Ali has a twin ... I think Jason was in love with Melissa, but she started dating Ian, which started the bitter rivalry between the two. I think on Ali's flag the "No J" stood for either Jason or Jenna[<---who btw. i think is A] Wilden was suspiscious from the very beginning. Well let me not spoil everything ... another thing... what's the point of Maya? she irks me. Ohh and I love Mike :-D! & hate Kate uqhh! this is torture ... when is the next book coming out?!

Posted by Tammi on July 07, 2009 at 11:40 PM EDT #

something that some people forgot is that ... Ali most likely is alive. there was NO proof she was dead because they identified her by her class ring besides that no real evidence. Its been how long and the DNA test STILL havent veen released or w.e. I think that's what Ian said the police are hiding. Also. it was a quiet private funeral/burial, why? Because she probably isn't dead. Like Jason said, their family is screwed up. I think Jenna is A, I think she either had temporary blindness or had laser surgery ..whether thats right or not she is suspiscious. I totally agree with the Ali's twin theory. As for crazy? Its Jason ... I think he's probably bipolar or something. Also, Melissa has something to do with everything.

Posted by Tammi on July 08, 2009 at 12:03 AM EDT #

LW, thats a good theory. i truthfully dont know what happened and its driving me insane!!! i want the next book to come out. haha. dont we all?!?!

Posted by jordyn on July 08, 2009 at 12:19 AM EDT #

SPOLIER ALERT! omg. wow. just wow. how great of a book was that? Okay.. my theory. I think that Jason is the psycho. Like maybe he had a jeckle and hyde thing goin on.. Also i think Ian told melissa everything and that shes A. its either her or jenna who i really dont believe is blind anymore. (does anyone else miss toby?) And i think that jason wanted melissa and when ian started dating him he was already mad. and then he some how found out about him and ali and got EXTRA MAD. and came to handle ian, but grabbed ali instead. but wow that whole thing at the end has me stomped! I thought twin, i thought it was like they took her to get her away from ian because jason's so over protective. BUT OMG ITS SO MUCH SARA SHEPERD COULD DO WITH THIS. The next book, Heartless comes out January 2010. CANT WAIT.

Posted by Antoinette on July 08, 2009 at 12:25 AM EDT #

1) I really hope Ali is alive and that she is going to be nice to them. 2) Jenna is SO not blind 3) I hope Ian is alive for real 4) I would yell and scream at Spencer's parents! they are rediculous.. 5) i knew something was up with Wilden a few books ago. He just seems guilty. 6) Does anyone else miss Wren? 7) THIS WAS THE BEST BOOK YET!

Posted by Mary-Roselyn on July 08, 2009 at 01:04 AM EDT #

I just finished the book and im speachless ! it was an amazinggg book from begining to end but after evert PLL book i read im always so pissed becuase im so confuse and i dont know what to think. after Whicked i had to wait SIX MONTHS for Killer to come out, im prayingggg that theres going to be another book though. Its the only thing i will willingly read haha.

Posted by Kennedy on July 08, 2009 at 01:54 AM EDT #

OMIGOD i already put two theorys on here yesterday but i totally agree with tammi

Posted by Ashleeey on July 08, 2009 at 10:46 AM EDT #

i agree with the theory about ali having a twin. and when jenna said ali had "sibling problems," it wouldn't necessarily have to be with jason. jenna could've known about the twin, and that's why she couldn't say anything more about the problem.

Posted by jess on July 08, 2009 at 11:36 AM EDT #

i think ali's flag said she wished there was no jason in her life (there was a wishing well and shooting stars, and then a no jason sign)

Posted by Kelsey on July 08, 2009 at 11:40 AM EDT #

YEAH, HOW OLD IS MIKE???

Posted by jessica on July 08, 2009 at 12:28 PM EDT #

i think Jess is righht. ali probably thought jason was going to kill her. he might have had mental problems and so he could have killed his own sister. i don't think she had a twin. we all think so, so sara isn't going to put something which we all thought would happen...does anyone know who a is? i have no idea. and ali has to be alive! but with this series a-n-y-t-h-i-n-g can happen... talk to me @ emilye31@gmail.com

Posted by emilyy. on July 08, 2009 at 02:16 PM EDT #

yayyyyyyy! Can't wait til Nov.9 thats when Heartess comes out! It said so on Sara Shepad's twitter page! WOOOOOOOHOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!! Ca't wait!

Posted by Grace on July 08, 2009 at 03:10 PM EDT #

ok Mike is in 10th grade and taking in that it was second semester. I'd have to say hes 16.

Posted by Antoinette on July 08, 2009 at 04:06 PM EDT #

Okay I REALLY think that Wilden is behind Ali's murder. Whether he is A, or maybe he was the one who helped kill her. I've had a creepy feeling about him for the last few books now and I know he is hiding something MAJOR. Anyone else agree?? Plus he is a cop, so he would know just how to make sure he isn't suspected, and how to cover up that he did something.

Posted by Stefani on July 08, 2009 at 06:14 PM EDT #

MAJOR SPOIL ALERT:~ OMFG! this book was amazing!!!(i just put it down after six whole hours) i really hope that ali is alive cause this whole time she's been this all-knowing ghost and i think that in the next book (if it is truely her) that sooo many questions will be answered. she knows absolutly every thing from , did jason her brother really go to a mental hospital? and why?She also knows what happened the night she "died"/disapered and who was actually in the woods with her. Did she actually have "sibling troubles" or was she just saying that to get to Janna? And i agree with Antoinette i totallly suspect Wilded but.....i dont think hes A i mean he's a grown men and it would be kinda noticable if he was following these girls around. But i do think he's hidding something and i also think he has something to do with A i mean think about it if A could manipulate them then A could definatly manipulate Wilden with what ever it is he's hidding.

Posted by GG on July 08, 2009 at 06:30 PM EDT #

oops i mean i totally agree with stefani (my bad)

Posted by GG on July 08, 2009 at 06:31 PM EDT #

FYI: HEARTLESS (BOOK 7) IS OUT NOVEMBER 9, 2009 NOT JANUARY!!!!! IF YOU DONT BELIEVE ME GO TO THE PAGE ON THE BLOG AND CLICK TWITTER SARA AND IT SAYS AO ON HER TWITTER!!

Posted by Domonick on July 08, 2009 at 07:45 PM EDT #

Spoiler alert: omg i just finished killeer. wow. its amazing. ok isaacs mums a creeper! imagine going to your bf's house and finding a pic of you with your head cut off! my bff always thought ali was alive. she thought that the body they found was liike alis long lost twin (XD tehe) or sumfin . she (my bff) sed : i think alis alive. cos they never took DNA so ya never noe. i think ali has a twin. leave it to Aria to hook up with a crazy XD tehe. ALways nnew sufin was up w/ wilden. and ii new ian didnt kill ali (hmm well the person they THINK is ali) altho i did think Melissa hadd somthing to do with it. i still do. kinda suspiccous how she leaves in a hurry huh? i cannot wate for the 7th book! i hate waiting. i wonder if itll be the last one... my frend avery thinks the last book shhould have an A on it. i hope alisalive cos shell be abloe to awnser everything. :) so happy aria helped her outa the fire. we still have to figer out wat that picture of ali, jenna and noami is about. kk gota go CANT WAIT TILL THE NEXT BOOK :)

Posted by neva495 on July 08, 2009 at 08:34 PM EDT #

Yeah Domonick you are right Heartless does come out in November. I was a bout to say the same thing HAHAHA And I just got Killer and I just started reading it i am sooo excited idk what to do with my self LOL.

Posted by LAN'EA on July 08, 2009 at 10:31 PM EDT #

OH.MY.GOD!!!!!!i was totally shocked! ali, still alive?TWINS?omfg.i cannot belive that.just ending like that is cruel.really.like chid abuse cruel.omg, i NEED Heartless.november?omg. questions! what about ezra?wren?is maya simply jealous, or is there more to her odd smirks?who the hell is a?actually, being so caught in the ali buisness, they havent thought at all about who a is. a is helping with the mystery-AND drawing the attention away from herself/hisself.i still have alot of questions for mona.and whats with ian?can we trust him?i hope we hear more from him.whos body was out there?where did it go?jason and jenna share a secret....and keep secrets from each other.maybe jason found out what she was hiding, and maybe that was why he was yelling at her.not sure about the whole twins thing....has anyone noticed that monas notes always implied that she was a girl?it wasnt even a question.with this new a, im no completely sure, but a is kinda b****y.dunno.i dont think itz wilden, though.doesnt feel rite.anyway, i cant wait 4 heartless.

Posted by Renesmee:-) on July 08, 2009 at 11:49 PM EDT #

I have 2 say, I don't think Spencer's blocking things out are all that unusual-people tend to subconsciously block out traumatic or horrifying events, so then later they have no recollection of it. I think it's basic psychology-the mind controlling the things a person does or doesn't remember. Remember in one of the books when Spencer was having dinner with her parents, and her mom was telling her something about when they (and Melissa) were mugged by a guy with a gun? She didn't remember it at all coz she was sick and her mind/body had too much else to cope with, so her mind shut out the memory of the mugging. Anyway, it's possible she erased this fight with Ali out of guilt or fear-think about the sleepwalk scene in Macbeth; Lady Macbeth does her best to consciously suppress the guilt she feels over Duncan's murder, yet she subconsciously reveals everything when she starts sleepwalking (unknowingly) in front of a doctor. All the guilt Lady M feels spills over unconsciously, but Spencer's bottling up her possible guilt could mean that she was so focused on how much guilt she felt that she blocked it out. Just an idea I had, and I know it probably doesn't make a whole lot of sense. But it's something I thought of when reading a few of the comments about Spencer's blocking stuff out.

Posted by SJ on July 09, 2009 at 06:11 AM EDT #

Ezra is out of the picture and looing for another job, I guess...

Posted by taylor on July 09, 2009 at 12:31 PM EDT #

WAIT LUCAS AND hannah are no longer together??? THey were cute.. how come?

Posted by Maddy on July 09, 2009 at 12:33 PM EDT #

Lucas broke up with hannah because he thought hannah was just obsessed with being popular. i dont want to spoil the whole thing so you just have to read it!

Posted by jordyn on July 09, 2009 at 01:48 PM EDT #

Alright so Killer is amazing, i haven’t been able to finish it because i have to keep reading the same sentences over and over again to make sure i get it all in. So i am wondering if Spencer cannot find her real mother because maybe A is just trying to fake her out by saying she has a mom out there when really, she isn’t adopted but A just wanted to make her crazy! I wish Mona was alive because there are so many questions i want to know... like if A was her or if maybe Ali just manipulated her into taking the blame for A!! And Jenna, SO not blind. She was creeping around Aria’s house like she could see in the house, and when Aria asked if she wanted something, Jenna looked like she did but didn’t say a thing! And what if Jason is metal! Then does that mean Ali wanted him out of her life cause he would get away with things and maybe not get blamed for them.. Sara you are amazing like every twist and turn is so MIND BLOWING i love it and cannot wait for Heartless in November!! (: (: (:

Posted by emm on July 09, 2009 at 02:53 PM EDT #

Ok two quick tings.....1) We need to figure out what the fight between Ali, Namoi and Riley was about becasue really this has been in pretty much all the books, but not enough to say why the stopped being best friends..cause a fight with close friends never screws up a friend ship right??....2) We still need to figure out what that picture of Ali, Jenna and Namoi was about! It could mean that Jenna and Ali were actually close friends but since Ali was so popular, she couldn't hang with a dork like Jenna...maybe the fight between Ali, Namoi and Riley was they were gonna tell everyone that Jenna and Ali were close?? I dunno let me know what you guys think PLEASE!!! :)

Posted by Mel-Locke on July 09, 2009 at 03:09 PM EDT #

SPOILER ALERT I agree that the fight between Ali and Naomi and Riley is important, but I doubt it's over the flag or anything. On Ali's flag, I seriously think the J being crossed out stands for Jenna, since if it was Jason that would be too obvious and I can't think of anyone else with a J name. But why is it Jenna? Maybe she was somehow involved with Jason in the past when Ali was still alive and everything. Remember when Aria saw the secretary tell Jason he had a call from his "sister"? And then Aria was like "i thought she would be beautiful and mature and someone you'd want to see" but Jason mumbled "not exactly". What if that girl calling him was Jenna? I don't know why Jenna would call him, but they had to be involved somehow. And I don't think Ali and Jenna were secret friends like the book wants us to think. Oh and then there's that theory that Jason was in love with Melissa. I'm thinking that's not true, but it's like the narrator wants us to think that it is. Who's really the girl that broke Jason's heart? The "Killer" and "Liar" signs on Spencer's family's property...what if those messages were for Melissa? She was like, "I have to get out of here" to Spencer There are also a lot of hints in the book that something's wrong with Ali's memory or something. Like she couldn't remember how to feed the cat and her mom got mad. At the end of Killer, I hope it's really Ali but she's probably just gonna have to disappear again.

Posted by May on July 09, 2009 at 04:33 PM EDT #

SPOILER ALERT I agree that the fight between Ali and Naomi and Riley is important, but I doubt it's over the flag or anything. On Ali's flag, I seriously think the J being crossed out stands for Jenna, since if it was Jason that would be too obvious and I can't think of anyone else with a J name. But why is it Jenna? Maybe she was somehow involved with Jason in the past when Ali was still alive and everything. Remember when Aria saw the secretary tell Jason he had a call from his "sister"? And then Aria was like "i thought she would be beautiful and mature and someone you'd want to see" but Jason mumbled "not exactly". What if that girl calling him was Jenna? I don't know why Jenna would call him, but they had to be involved somehow. And I don't think Ali and Jenna were secret friends like the book wants us to think.

Posted by May on July 09, 2009 at 04:35 PM EDT #

Oh and then there's that theory that Jason was in love with Melissa. I'm thinking that's not true, but it's like the narrator wants us to think that it is. Who's really the girl that broke Jason's heart? .... The "Killer" and "Liar" signs on Spencer's family's property...what if those messages were for Melissa? She was like, "I have to get out of here" to Spencer. There are also a lot of hints in the book that something's wrong with Ali's memory or something. Like she couldn't remember how to feed the cat and her mom got mad. At the end of Killer, I hope it's really Ali but she's probably just gonna have to disappear again.

Posted by May on July 09, 2009 at 04:38 PM EDT #

Spoil Alert: i soooo agree with the naomi and ali thing...there is deff something going on there.and i do think jason is a mojor creeper with a major secret! but the thought of ali having a twin is kinda far out....#1 how could she have keept her twin from everyone? and #2 the body in the backyard was never actually identified as ali so it could deffenitally be another person!\ GaBixoxox

Posted by GG on July 09, 2009 at 06:07 PM EDT #

ok so what happeneed in th eerlier book when they found her body??? so was it not her body or is it not her at the end????

Posted by Nicolette Ivy on July 09, 2009 at 06:17 PM EDT #

well the body is soooo decomposed that they cant really tell whos body it is...they just assumed it was ali's.(wonder whos it really is) GaBi xoxoxo

Posted by GG on July 09, 2009 at 06:23 PM EDT #

KILLER was so... weird? like i dont really understand the ending. like ali is alive clearly, like i always knew that, especially when the book was like oh yeah well we dont really know if that dead girl in the hole was ali cause they never did the otopsy.. a dur. and like A would have to know ali was still alive right? if he/she sent her a note to go to spencers house. so like who the hellll is A? and is there gonna be another book after this one cause i have sooo many questions still that KILLER did not answer in the end.

Posted by Christine on July 09, 2009 at 08:15 PM EDT #

ok so why did ali just drop naomi and riley for 4 losers??? and also whhat do you think jenna is up to or why is she so important??

Posted by Nicolette Ivy on July 09, 2009 at 10:27 PM EDT #

do you think that jason and wilden actually muredered ian and pretented to be him on like im, i mean how else could he fake that death??

Posted by Nicolette Ivy on July 09, 2009 at 10:29 PM EDT #

Love this book! I have a theory that Mona is A! ?????? Who agrees?

Posted by Renesmee on July 09, 2009 at 10:39 PM EDT #

I agree with you Renesmee Bcuz i was on wikipedia and i looked up pretty little liars an it gave descriptions of all the characters and it said Mona was A but who Knows??? By the way i just wanted to say I LOVE YOU SARA SHEPARD!! You are the best author ever!

Posted by Alexa on July 09, 2009 at 10:46 PM EDT #

oops ment i looovvvveee mike

Posted by breanna on July 09, 2009 at 10:54 PM EDT #

uhhh mona is dead.. she died in like the 5th book but yeah she was A, and now there's a copycat or something.. and this A is like nice? its weird but uh yeah is there gonna be another book ? and why is that girl aboves name renesme? haha twilightttttttt <3

Posted by Kristen on July 09, 2009 at 11:42 PM EDT #

OMG! Yah i totally agree with May that the J crossed out may staned for Jenna! I do however think that Jenna is involved with Ali and her family somehow,because why else would someone say Jason has a call from his sister?? I mean most people would go right ahead and think "oh Ali it's Ali" but that is way to obvious so yah maybe Jenna is like a family friend or maybe cousin?? I dunno but maybe Naomi and Riley knew and was going to tell people what the "secret" between Ali and Jenna was and so Ali dropped them like that! But the thing is...since Hanna is now somewhat "friends" with Naomi and Riley, i think Hanna will figure it out, maybe by listing to Kate or maybe it will slip out what the fight was between Ali, Naomi and Riley was about..or who knows, maybe Hanna will just ask!! (: (: (:

Posted by Mel-Locke on July 10, 2009 at 10:45 AM EDT #

that was sooooooo freaking awesome! holy god! when does the next one come outtt?

Posted by Heather on July 10, 2009 at 11:10 AM EDT #

oh my gosh! that book was amazing! i got it yesterday and finished it in one day!!! it was amazing! i can't wait for the next one to come out! and omg SPOILER ALERT i cant believe that ali is back! i don't want her back! she ruined all of their lives! and i hate waiting on the next books the next one is called HEARTLESS and comes out JANUARY 19,2010! thats like six months away :( that sucks! but killer was so great!!!!

Posted by emily on July 10, 2009 at 11:36 AM EDT #

oh one quick question... does anyone else think that these books should be made into a movie?

Posted by emily on July 10, 2009 at 11:47 AM EDT #

omg! SPOILER ALERT!!!!!!!!!!!! oMG! I cant believe it! i absolutely Love Hanna and Mike together!haha! i totally think wilden has something hes hiding and i think Ali IS still alive cuz i dont think that the police were sure if it was really her cuz the bones they found were lik too decomposed to tell or something like that. Oh and i Totally Absolutely Hate kate!!!! i wish "A" would like kill her or do something horrible to her so she would leave hanna alone. Oh and i want Jason and Aria to get together! ooh and emily's boyfriend's (or ex bf) mom is creepy! Aria's mom's bf is also creepy, and spencer... her life is so messed up, she has a family that lik hates her and wen she meets her birth mom she scams her, how sad. but i cant wait for the next book! haha! does anyone now wut the next one is gonna be called?

Posted by Brianna on July 10, 2009 at 12:50 PM EDT #

it cant be a twinn. sara wouldnt make it that obvious. okai, so im guessin Ali iss alive but im still wondering, who's body was it that they found? i dont think jenna is blind, and im thinkin wen ali fell she like lost memory or something, and maybe thats why she doesnt recognize the others. jenna & jason must be in on something, wilden is still frikkin strange he freaks me out, IM SOO CONFUSED! i cant frikkin WAIT for "Heartless" Jan. is too far away! <3 this frikkin series, i <3 them!

Posted by Urma =D on July 10, 2009 at 12:57 PM EDT #

Ok... heres my theory. I dont think there is a twin. I think that Jenna knew Ali was alive and was hiding her. BUT who is in the hole??? It said that there was never any DNA tests to prove who was dead but SOMEONE is dead. And I think Wilden and Jason accidently killed whomever is dead thinking it was Ali. I also agree that Jenna isn't blind... not 100% sure but it would make more sense. I think Ali doesnt recognize them because she hasn't seen them in YEARS. Think about how they were described as sixth graders compared to how they are described now... HMMMM. Too bad we have to wait til JANUARY 19th!!!!!

Posted by Katie on July 10, 2009 at 02:21 PM EDT #

Im almost done with Killer, and I think somethings seriously wrong with Jason, and Wilden with the propane tanks at the mall was weird, and now Ian's apparently alive in "California!" God I love these books. :D

Posted by MinAndrehaaa! on July 10, 2009 at 04:37 PM EDT #

i really think that jenna knows more than shes telling and i think shes the new A. she really wanted 2 tell aria that day that it was her but she didn't. And maybe it was jenna they saw risin frm tha ashes nt ali. cuz she knew 2 much. I ttly knew who "they" were it all pointd 2 them for the longest and mel, knew sum things 2 dat happened that nite bcuz she went lukin for ian..... and every1 knows dat uscmidfielderroxx is jenna it all adds up.

Posted by quita on July 10, 2009 at 05:22 PM EDT #

and i think sum1 fell over a plant and fell n2 the hole bcuz aria and emily had a dream about it

Posted by quita on July 10, 2009 at 05:26 PM EDT #

OMG!!!!!!!!!I just finished it and it was so insane in an amazing sort of way!!!!I can't believe Ali is still alive!!!!!!i mean where would she have been all this time and how would she not have seen all of the events going on in Rosewood on the news and about Aria,Spencer,Emily,and Hannah????I can't even wait for the next one I think I'm going to scream many times!!!!Oh and now A seems to be helping them and I almost want to think it's mellissa because she hasn't been around for a while but also Jenna seems to be suspicous too.

Posted by ashley on July 10, 2009 at 05:31 PM EDT #

n i also think that j was for jenna cuz when she was standing outside of her house aria heard her say " i wish she was out of my life forever"

Posted by quita on July 10, 2009 at 05:37 PM EDT #

ok if spencers dad was with alis mom....and spencer and ali are the same age so how does that work???

Posted by Nicolette Ivy on July 10, 2009 at 05:51 PM EDT #

there is alot going on here. idk if ali is dead but she can also hypothis people and w.e and her family is hidin sumthin cuz jason gt soooo mad bout aria goin n2 da main house. N remeber wen ali was n2 'bad bois' yep n spencer i think spencer's father might b mr.appleton the principal idk bt just sayin cuz her father was arguin with them n plus she was suppose 2 b kikd out. Yeah melissa knows alot i think she planted ians body and put the ring in the dirt to think that he was dead hopin sum1 found it. She is smart. i think kate is gud at heart if hanna ever gave her a chance. They need to go to the hole where the body was found like quita a plant. jenna sooo nt blind i luv TOBY.. AND ISAAC bt yeah dnt think there was a twin... plus i think ali and jenna made a deal ali help jenna and jenna help her. i kinda dnt think jason had it n him 2 kill her but mad a mistake bt darren did.. Soo much is goin on in mi mind n alis bf matt did nt show her hypnosis mayb jason shrink did... or jenna just maybe i have alot of theorys just can't wait 4 da next book..Luv ya pll fans

Posted by shaqucia on July 10, 2009 at 06:06 PM EDT #

Hey, fellow PLL fans! First off, Heartless is released in NOVEMBER, 09! Just check it out on Sara's twitter page! Secondly, the new A is a lot more sinister and evil. He or she really wants to ruin the girls both mentally and physically. This is mentioned in Sara's podcast! And if we thought that old A was bad, hitting Hanna with the SVU, (some people have not read all of the books that are out. That's why I didn't say whom old A was.) then I can't wait to find out how this new A is! Killer rocked! =)

Posted by Ali on July 10, 2009 at 06:06 PM EDT #

spencer's dad is mr.appleton the principal cuz her dad had an argument wit him n her grandfather n her luk alike sooo duh...

Posted by shaqucia on July 10, 2009 at 06:14 PM EDT #

Does anyone else think that Ali and Wilden were in some relationship? Because in Flawless Emily recalls Ali saying she was going out with an older guy, who was like a bad boy. And Wilden did have that kind of rep.

Posted by May on July 10, 2009 at 08:28 PM EDT #

OKay im readin Killer Now and as I was reading Sara Mad a Mistake at the begining... unless its fixed at the end ahahha.... gosh i forgot wat the mistake was but all i remeber is that one of the girls said they didnt do sumthin or never seen sumthin when they did. If you can remember what it it remind my pleaz. cuz im not gona go back through the whole book to find it. HAhAHAHHA But killer in real good im in da middle of the book and soon as i stop typing this imma keep on readin LOL!!!!

Posted by LAN'EA on July 10, 2009 at 08:44 PM EDT #

I'm having a WTF moment. right now. I just finished the book and i cant believe it. And i hate that i have to wait until the next book to figure out what happened!!!!

Posted by Erica on July 10, 2009 at 09:19 PM EDT #

WHOA! did not c that ending coming! i mean, ali showed up!(sorry if you just started to read the book) i can't wait until the next book. does anyone else think either maya or jenna is a? i used 2 think jenna was a, then it turned out to be mona. so now i'm kinda hopeing that it's jenna.

Posted by Jane on July 10, 2009 at 09:44 PM EDT #

okay so i think jenna is A cuz at the end of wicked it says that 'these pretty little bitches got everything i wanted' and then emily got that pic with jenna and ali and i think that maybe they had a secret friendship (or something weird like that) cuz jenna was a loser back then and ali didnt want people to know. but jenna wanted to be friends with ali like spencer, hanna, aria, and emily were. so now shes pissed at that and the fact that they sorta, oh i dont know "BLINDED" HER! but it also says that 'I'll be watching' which she was watching aria at that baby shower. and i dont care if they say shes blind cuz if she was how the freak would she know that she's looking through a window and not just randomly at some wall!!!! i mean hello!!!! she cant be blind!!!!!...and that is all i have to say =]

Posted by LYSSA!!! on July 10, 2009 at 09:54 PM EDT #

I cant believe the ending! It was soooo shocking. I cant wait till the next book. I think Mona had someone else working with her. I wonder why Ali dosent remember the girls?

Posted by allie on July 10, 2009 at 10:30 PM EDT #

Okay, the ali twin theory is good. But the theory of Mrs. Hastings & Mr. DiLaurentis being Spencer's biological parents is crazy. How would they even know each other since the DiLaurentis didnt move to Rosewood until Ali & Spencer were already in school. Back to the twin thing. It would explain why Jason was visting the Radley. It would also give the DiLaurentis family a good reason to move to Rosewood. Rosewood was close to the Radley & they could send Jason and Ali to school. Also, noone in Rosewood would know anything about the family prior to the move. I think that Jason may have told Wilden about his other sister (assuming that there is another twin sister). If there is a twin I believe that the body in the whole was hers, not Ali's. We all know Spencer heard a crack and saw a few blondes. The crack may have been Ali's head ,but I think that the actual body was the twin's. Maybe Jason thought the twin was actually Ali? Assuming, again, that Jason is the murder. I also belive Jenna is "A". I can't really think of anyone else who would be able to pull that off. I think that she most likely had help from Ali (or her twin? if infact the body was real Ali & not the twin). It would be very hard for Jenna to be able to know what was going on in the girl's lives if she was blind. Not impossible, of course, but very very difficult. So maybe as an explanation for that Ali/Ali's twin may have been an accomplice in the "A" hoax. On to the subject of couples. Firstly, I think Lucas's mom is hiding something. She seems oddly overprotective of her son. Secondly, Andrew & Spencer are a perfect match. There is no doubt about it. But, I would worry about getting Andrew tangled into Spencer's complicated life. Thirdly, Mike & Hanna. I'm still getting used to the idea of them being togeather. Seems a little odd. Although, Mike isnt that much younger then Hanna. Only a year or so right? Hanna's a junior; Mike's a sophmore. They seem to be a cute enough couple. With the way they social climb those two could be the most popular (and best looking) couple in Rosewood

Posted by blair on July 10, 2009 at 11:27 PM EDT #

SPOIL!!!!!! LOVED THE BOOK AHHH SO GOOD before i spoil i have 1 ? do u know when the next book is coming out or what its going to be called? ok here is my therey about what happend ok right before ali was going to talk to ian jason came in he did not like ali and ian dating but because he was so close to ali he did not want to kill her so he threated her to stay under cover for a long time like 5 years (i think) i know its lame but wat ev

Posted by tracy on July 11, 2009 at 01:38 AM EDT #

OMG I KNOW I POSTED LIKE 2 SECS AGO BUT I KNOW WAT HAPPENED OK U KNOW WHEN SPENCER GOT HER MEMORY BACK SHE REMBERS PUSSING ALI INTO A WALL WELL U KNOW WHEN SOME PPL GET HIT ON THERE HEAD THEY LOSE THERE MEMORY SOOOOO SHE WAS PROBLY IN THE WOODS THE WHOLE TIME!!!!!!!!

Posted by tracy on July 11, 2009 at 01:44 AM EDT #

so i recall a couple people saying here that they wish that the flag was of bigger importance ? and in one of the books they said sometime along the lines of the killer is on the flag or sometnhing ? well if the j stands for jason it could mean the killer is not jason ! and if the theory about jason hiding ali is far fetched but could work . when emily almost hit his car she couldve been in the trunnk ! and then in the house later . and you know when aria is leaving jasons house she sees someone with a dog leaving at first i thought it was wilden ...but if him and jason were team he wouldnt do that unless the not jason thing is true. but maybe its jenna but than again maybe there working together but i have no idea i just love these books soo much :)

Posted by annnaaa clairee :) on July 11, 2009 at 01:59 AM EDT #

about my above post when i said she was in the car i mean ali !

Posted by annnaaa clairee :) on July 11, 2009 at 02:09 AM EDT #

I just got Killer today and oh my God, Ali is alive?????? That can't be true. They found her body in her backyard though! I mean sure, the only way the forensics team could identify her body was by the ring that Ali wore but where could Darren and Jason have found a spare body to dump in a hole???? Maybe she had a twin and that's why it said Ali didn't recognize them?? Haha I don't know, it's just so bizarre that Ali's alive. And I knew Wilden was behind something, but didn't know about Jason 'til the book got into detail. I don't know how I'm going to wait for the next one. Ugh.

Posted by Brooke Nicole on July 11, 2009 at 03:51 AM EDT #

okay so i think jenna is a cuz at the end of wicked it says that they got everything she wanted and then emily got that pic of ali and jenna and maybe they had like some secret friendship thing (and yes i kno thats weird but w.e) and what she wanted was to be friends with ali like spencer emily hanna and aria were. then it also says i'll be watching. then she was caught watching aria and i dont care if it says she's blind cuz if she was blind why would she even be near a window!!! and plus they "blinded" her during the jenna thing and that probably wasnt part of the plan so she's prob really mad about that

Posted by LYSSA!!! on July 11, 2009 at 10:15 AM EDT #

Okay? What is up with this? Pretty little liars has a NEW series, [ same books? ] But with diffrent covers? =S Can anyone tell me about this? And are the books that we bought still avaible? Or is this the new book cover? can anyoen tell me? im really confused.

Posted by Ninaaaaa <3 P.L.L # 1 fann! on July 11, 2009 at 10:24 AM EDT #

OMG! annnaaa clairee :) you are soooo right! Ali could have been in the trunk! i never thought of it that way. I always suspected the house but gosh no not the trunk haha. At first i tthought jason might have a twin but nooooo he was worried about Ali. wowwwww thats a gooooooood theory! :D cant wait til heartless<3(:

Posted by Morgan(: on July 11, 2009 at 10:40 AM EDT #

Okay first off, i don't think Jenna is blind. Well maybe...idkk. but i think A is trying to set Jenna up to make Jenna look like A. I did think it was weird how she was staring into the window from the babyshower....creepy. oh and the books always leave off at some kind off party or dramatic scene lol. AND ALI PROBABLY DOESNT RECONIZE THE GIRLS CAZ THEY ARE 3 YEARS OLDER!!! or wen she hit her head (wen spencer pushed her) Ali lost her memory and can't remember them at all. there is my theory well some.... (:

Posted by Morgan(: on July 11, 2009 at 10:55 AM EDT #

I think A has been going on for a while. I think A was sending Ali messages too. The girl (Ali) said that a message told her to go there. A is def not ali. I dont think Jenna is blind.

Posted by KiKi on July 11, 2009 at 11:48 AM EDT #

OK BUDDY i GET IT THATS COOL. I LOVE THESE BOOKS

Posted by TAYLOR on July 11, 2009 at 12:05 PM EDT #

I think Ali does not remember the girls because yes it has been three years but also when she hit her head! My theory is Jason and Ian were fighting in the woods about Ali (cause Jason didn't aprove of them dating) and when they saw Ali maybe they started to talk to her and things got out of hand and by mistake, Jason pushed Ali into the rock wall instead of Ian and so Ali lost her memory that way! Maybe Spencer just remembers the crack but not how cause in Killer Spencer says something like i'm not sure that is what happened, so maybe she didn't push Ali, she was just there and saw Jason push her! Jenna is A, i'm almost sure if it (;

Posted by Mel-Locke on July 11, 2009 at 03:09 PM EDT #

It could be possible that ali just does'nt recognize the girls i mean last time she checked Hanna was a fat brace face now shes a heart throb.i soo think janna is A 2 though! xoxoxoxo

Posted by GaBi on July 11, 2009 at 03:26 PM EDT #

Omg i just finished killer( i know i'm late) It was amazing in every way. At the radley party A didnt send the ghirls a message it was wilden or Jason. when A sends messages in the books the font is always blocky, black, and bold, but the message they got at the party was light and in italics. I think it was a plan to lure the girls in one spot to kill them all (ali too.) i still dont know how shes alive or whats going on with Jenna and Jason.

Posted by Domonick on July 11, 2009 at 04:09 PM EDT #

Ohmagawd. That was sooooooooooo amazing blazing! *spoiler!* If you flip back to the part where Em visits Ali's grave it says that Ali's parents wanted to wait till the DNA came back before they burried Ali. But they went ahead and burried her before the DNA came back! So it might actually be Ali that came back! She might have ran away from Jason and now she's back! Any thoughts?

Posted by Kaylee on July 11, 2009 at 04:16 PM EDT #

P.S.It seems normal ali doesn't recognize them she hasnt them in three years when (i hate to say it) they were four geeky losers now they are the prettiest girls in rosewood! I think they will talk to her and her memory will return. eithier that or Jason and wilden did something to her memory. If either one of them did any thing to ali they are scum just like spencers scamming mom (olivia)

Posted by Domonick on July 11, 2009 at 04:17 PM EDT #

Ali is still alive cuz this book is messed up

Posted by Lea B on July 12, 2009 at 01:07 AM EDT #

Can't wait til Heartless comes out! And yayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy! It comes out November 9th!

Posted by Gigi! on July 12, 2009 at 01:01 PM EDT #

whats with ali forgetting everything? the time capsule piece, the cat food thing with her mom, when she changed her outfit, etc. and aria sees jason as being hurt by ali and emily sees ali being hurt by jason... maybe they were the seperate twins and the real ali hated jason because he always visited her twin at the radley? he def has another sis cuz of the call from school. i thought a was melissa because of the flashes of blond hair. maybe shes mad at the girls for getting ian arrested. but a is trying to help now so who knows.. ppl think its jenna and that would only work if jenna was secretly not blind! in one book aria said when she was painting it seemed like she could really see what she was doing.

Posted by kel on July 12, 2009 at 01:46 PM EDT #

so is ali really dead and was it her twin there? who sent the message telling her to go to the woods? and i wonder if a is misleading everyone.. or a can be ali's killer if shes even dead and trying to cover up. but wilden did have propane. and IS IAN ALIVE??? and spenc and ali have to be related. alis dad spencers mom it makes alot of sense with the sister game her mom got mad at. ps i love mike and hanna and cant wait 6 months

Posted by kel on July 12, 2009 at 01:47 PM EDT #

OMG! I was out of town and had preordered Killer at another bookstore so I had to wait to get it. And I got it today and OMG! I am soooooo shocked at the ending! I got my bestfriend to start reading the series, and *SPOILER* I told her it was the cop all along! It just seemed tooo fishy for local bad boy to suddenly become a good one. And ALI! Is that even her?! Does she have a twin or another sister?! And what does Jenna have to do with all this?! I am soooo confused, but in a good way! I cannot wait for the next book! :D Please hurry Sara!!!!

Posted by Jessica on July 12, 2009 at 02:47 PM EDT #

im in the middle of reading killer rite now!! its SUCH a gr8 book!!!!! :] sara is an amazing writer

Posted by Brooke on July 12, 2009 at 03:27 PM EDT #

i dont think jason was bad. he is definitely hiding ali in the main house. so he obviously didnt kill her. but it doesnt make sense that he got a call from "his sister" and all the other weird things that suggest ali has a twin. alot of ppl are saying she definiely dosnt, but who knows. if a is good then a is jenna(WHO CAN SEE) but if a is trying to frame wilden and jason then a is the real killer. but ali is alive so there really is no killer! this is so confusing. i guess wilden was trying to kill ali at the end, including the 4 girls. but why because it doesnt seem like jason is bad anymore after reading some of the posts. and the jason visiting ali twin at the radley makes sense. and spencer is somehow related to ali, definitely

Posted by bri on July 12, 2009 at 04:12 PM EDT #

where did melissa disappear to all of a sudden? and whats up with ians i.m.s being from rosewood. someone is hiding him or faking being him...

Posted by ali on July 12, 2009 at 04:35 PM EDT #

********SPOILER ALERT********** okay so obviously Killer was AMAZING ! But i have some theories that I took from a bunch of other theories. Okay so first of all I don't think Spencer was adopted, I think her parents wanted the all American family of four so they wanted another kid but they couldn't get pregnant so they either did invitro or like test tube baby or whatever. That would explain why the grandmother didn't approve of Spencer and didn't give money to her because she wasn't "natural born". Next, I think either Ali or Jason had a twin that was mentally unstable because Jason looks so much like Ali that if he had a twin it would still look a lot like her. It would explain why Jason was always visiting the Radley and why he got upset when Aria showed him the invitation. And I think the twin killed Ali because she was mentally unstable and it did say in Killer that there were two people with long blond hair in the woods. Then when Aria reads Wilden's in the yearbook that says "I still can't believe what that asshole did" it might have something to do with Ian saying something or doing something that had to do with the twin. It would also explain Jason's dirty looks to Ian and the phone call from his sister when Aria says she had just seen Ali at school. Also if Ali had a twin that would explain why Ali looked puzzled when the girls brought up certain things. Also it could be Ali's twin in the picture and not Naomi. As for the twin not ever being heard of I agree that the Dilaurentis' have been hiding the twin in the main house and that's why Jason freaked when he thought Aria had been in the main house. I think they're hiding her because they don't want her to get in trouble and they hid her before the murder because they were ashamed of not having a "perfect" family. As for A .. I'm not sure. I don't think Wilden or Jason have to do with the murder or being A, they're just sketchy because they are the only people who know about the twin. I don't think they lit the barn on fire either. I think it was A .. whoever that is. This theory would explain a lot like the flashes of blond hair and the girls swearing they see Ali. But .. you never know with PLL (:

Posted by Ally on July 12, 2009 at 05:50 PM EDT #

this should deffinatley should be a movie!

Posted by ali on July 12, 2009 at 06:07 PM EDT #

AH! What is this?! Will there be another book? I can't believe this!! Although I'd been saying all along "Ali is probably still alive" and "Maybe she has a twin!" this CAN NOT be the end of the series! AHHHH!

Posted by Emily on July 12, 2009 at 06:09 PM EDT #

SPOILER ALERT! Whoaa! okay so i'm totally confused. Ali. Alive. noo way. if she was alive then why would darren and jason want hannah emily and aria dead? the only reason they would want them dead would be so they couldn't figure out that they had killed her accidently so that she wouldn't get involved with ian. god, this is annoying not knowing! can't wait for the next one!

Posted by Delaney on July 12, 2009 at 07:27 PM EDT #

what if jason is like really messed up and pretending to be ali? i mean he looks just like her, and it was dark when they saw her. and aria thought it was a boy when she first saw ali.

Posted by carlie on July 12, 2009 at 07:47 PM EDT #

...cuz i mean somebody is dead. they found somebody's body. and no one else is missing, so either there's an extra person around, or somebody's pretending to be somebody else.

Posted by carlie on July 12, 2009 at 07:55 PM EDT #

ok...i finished killer in 2 days!!!! some ending!! :] *SPOILER ALERT*- how can allie be alive???? that was SO shocking! and i thought wilden was suspicious....jason was acting weird 2. no wonder he was in that crazy peoples house. i cnt wait 4 the next book!

Posted by brooke on July 12, 2009 at 07:56 PM EDT #

i didn=t like this book as much as others because a wasent in it as much and it was a little boreing but by the end it was totally worth it i tatally think and always thought that ali was alive

Posted by sarah on July 12, 2009 at 08:24 PM EDT #

omg. SPOILER:i just wanted to say i KNEW ali wasn't dead! i always suspected melisa though... but jason i saw that one coming ughhh why didn't ali reconize them..could it truely be ali however...? ugh and whens the next book i can't waittttt

Posted by rachel on July 12, 2009 at 08:44 PM EDT #

i just finished killer i just want to say i knew it all along like jason and wilden and then ali the next thing i think that will happen is that jenna has something to do with all of this like thats who they thought was ali in the hole that jenna is actually dead and that ali was posing as jenna all these years... thats what i think.

Posted by Haley Manry on July 12, 2009 at 10:51 PM EDT #

okay for all the people who don't want ali back because she supposedly "ruined all their lives"...you're wrong. ali didn't ruin their lives. Mona did. Sure ali wrote all that stuff down, but if the theory is right that she had memory problems...then maybe she wrote it all down so she could remember. i still don't know if i believe all the stuff about ali having a twin, or if ali really is alive and everything. this book was sooooo good! but it did leave a lot more questions than answers. cannot wait for november :)

Posted by mariah on July 12, 2009 at 10:51 PM EDT #

i just finished killer, i expected that! it was obvious. but when is the next book coming out!!!!!!!! i neeeeeeeeeeed ittttttttttttttttt.

Posted by ahhhhh on July 12, 2009 at 10:58 PM EDT #

OMG! i knew it waswilden and jason from the beginning of Killer. and the end of tht book? i hadto read it 5 times! cant believe ali is ALIVE!

Posted by morgan on July 12, 2009 at 11:39 PM EDT #

i dont think anyones said this (sorry if i just didnt see it) but what if ali and her twin were fighting, spencer saw two blondes, and they would be leaning together being siblings. Maybe one of them killed the other, maybe the twim if she had problems, or Alo and thats who did it, also if ali killed her twim they just said it was ali because no one knew about the twim, but then why didnt they recover the body right away? maybe thier fraternal not identical and the body had to decay, maybe the twim pretended to be ali? other way around? who knows ok next thing maybe the J on ali's flag stands for jenna, idk why it would but who knows anymore just throwing things out thier

Posted by Shianne on July 13, 2009 at 03:52 AM EDT #

What about these dolls, is thier a bigger meaning behind them? thier on every book cover twice im guessing since thiers 8 books total and in the one book i cant remember which or who said this but it was something like ' its like we were her dolls, or puppets, ' does that play into it more? idk i cant remember my other theories right now lol its 4 am

Posted by Shianne on July 13, 2009 at 03:52 AM EDT #

OMG!! I got Killer Saturday and I just finished. I cant believe Ali could be alive or that Jason and Wilden could be her death/ disappearance. I cant wait till the next book comes out!

Posted by Gabrielle on July 13, 2009 at 04:33 AM EDT #

Coolio i have an idea! Remember when, i think Spencer, thought about how her family and Ali's family used to always go to partys and stuff and Jason was never there, well maybe that IS because he was in the mentil instatution but he only went on Sundays so that is why he was never with Ali and her family on Sundays. And also, he spent a lot of time to his self prob cause he was so...weird lolol. And about that call from Jason's "sister" well you know that the only way he could get the call was if it was a family member so it could have been anyone who called! (my guess Jenna cause when Jason and Aria were at the bar and she said he got a call from his sister and she said he would have rather have talked to to his girlfriend he said not excacly...) So maybe it was just Jenna wanting to tell Jason about Ali?? LET ME KNOW WHAT YOU GUYZZ THINK!!! (: (:

Posted by Mel-Locke on July 13, 2009 at 10:23 AM EDT #

i think when she sw jenna and jason ,jason was telling jenna not to call the fire department when he set the fire but then i think she felt bad and did it any way

Posted by sarah on July 13, 2009 at 12:06 PM EDT #

Wow. Really? Killer is the prefect name for this book. It's killing me thats for sure. I never liked to read until i started reading Pretty Little Liars. thanks for getting me hooked! Becaues i know i'll have to wait a while until the seventh book comes out, I am planning on re-reading the series. This book is SO good. I can't believe the things you come up with. It's amazing what an imagination you must have. Keep the agonizing books coming! They're really great!

Posted by Emily on July 13, 2009 at 12:14 PM EDT #

SOO .. Jason said that his entire family was messed up .. that meant his parents to ..what if, like Spencer's parents, Ali's parents didnt like being embarassed and they are the ones that faked her disappearance bcus her mental problems were getting out of control. It was her in the mental hospital not Jason ... i think he was signing in and out of a visitor log. I also dont think Jenna is really blind and she plays a big part in this.

Posted by Bek on July 13, 2009 at 01:35 PM EDT #

when does the next book come out?! i LOVED killer!!! i'm so confused... how is ali alive?!?!

Posted by molly on July 13, 2009 at 02:20 PM EDT #

I loved Killer! It was amazing; I kind of knew Wilden and Jason were in on something, but I thought Ian had something to do with everything too but idk anymore. I think that the new A is actually trying to help the girls out, and im not totally sure, but i think that maybe Melissa is the new A and she is actually with Ian and helping him hide from everyone.

Posted by Ally on July 13, 2009 at 04:00 PM EDT #

Everyone the next book is called heartless and it comes out NOVEMBER 9th

Posted by Domonick on July 13, 2009 at 04:16 PM EDT #

omg the book is awsome!!!!!!SPOILER- i new jason killed her! i mean he said his family was messed up and that stuff. plus he mocked her and like took her flag!!!! i was totally freaked about the alley thing at the end. and i think that spencers sister is going to meet up with ian at her townhouse. i think melissa is the new A cause she could be with ian

Posted by venus on July 13, 2009 at 04:40 PM EDT #

I love this series! And I absolutely cannot wait for Heartless and Twisted! lol. I finished Killer in one day.. and.. SPOILER ALERT... I think the Ali they saw at the end was her twin (I agree with the theories of Jason visiting the twin in the mental hospital, and that Spencer and Ali could be related) but what if, say, the night of Ali's "death", Ian and Jason could've gotten into a fight over Ali or Melissa (because remember, Jason was apparently in love with Melissa), so Ali's death was an accident? Or what if Jason brought Ali's twin to visit and she was the one that was accidently killed? I can see why the DiLaurentis' would hide the twin. They have reputations to protect, and it was destroy everything if people found out they had a mentally deranged child. Also, there's another possible theory I've been thinking about. What if A is an unreliable narrator? A basically tells the story, but what if some of these events were made up or false leads were purposely put there? What if the girls are seeing things that aren't really there? Like what if they're seeing the ghost of Ali, and maybe part of the reason Jason was in the mental hospital was because he was seeing things too. All in all, this series is suspenseful, witty, and it all-around rocks. :) Sara Shepard is one of the best writers I know. Why? She leaves us all wanting answers. :)

Posted by beautiful liar on July 13, 2009 at 05:19 PM EDT #

What if A is an unreliable narrator? And what if all the girls are seeing things that aren't really there? This series has really stumped me.. (which is why i love it! :D). I do think the twin theory is possible. So is the Ali/Spencer being related theory. Errggg.. I can't wait for Heartless!!!

Posted by beautiful liar on July 13, 2009 at 05:22 PM EDT #

So ya Heartless comes out November 9th and i'm really excited! As for A.. Maybe Jenna but it cannot be Maya because A grew up in Rosewood and Maya didn't so that blows Maya out.. But Jenna..hmm could be and I am for sure she isn't blind because of the baby shower thing, where she was outside Aria's window. I think a lot of people are weird but not sure as if that means anything..like Melissa, she has been acting suspcious but i do not think she killed anyone or knows anything about A. But i wonder who has been IMing her because IAN IS DEAD!!! I dunno maybe she knows who A is oh oh or... member how she told Spencer she coucld use her laptop MEANING MELISSA KNEW IAN WOULD BE ON AND TALK TO SPENCER MEANING MELISSA IS IAN!! IT SAID IAN WAS SOMEWHERE IS ROSEWOOD AND MELISSA IS IN ROSEWOOD AND SHE KNOW SPENCER WOULD BEEN ON AND SHE LEFT!!! OH MY MELISSA IS PRETENDING TO BE IAN!! that makes sence right???

Posted by emm on July 13, 2009 at 07:51 PM EDT #

Do you have guess of who A is???? Do you think Ali is really alive??? Post your comments!!!!! AND THE NEXT BOOK COMES OUT SOMETIME AT THE BEGINNING OF 2010

Posted by Braden on July 13, 2009 at 08:44 PM EDT #

SPOILER ALERT! Okay so at the end of Killer when Ali comes back I think that she has lost her memory or something because Emily says (I think it was Emily) that she recognizes Ali but Ali doesn't recognize them! Well that's my theory. And just wanted to say Sara (if your reading this) I live in Atlanta and am SO exited for you coming to the Decatur bookfest! I go every year!

Posted by Mermer on July 13, 2009 at 09:59 PM EDT #

**SPOILER ALERT** OMGOSH!!! OKAY SO ALI MAY BE STILL ALIVE BUT LOST HER MEMOERY BECAUSE I REMEBER READIN IT AND DEY SAID THE DNA TEST HADDENT CAME THROUGH (JUST WHAT I SAID B4 KILLER CAME OUT) AND YEAH SO JASON A DAT COP SURELY KNOWS ALOT AND IAN KNO WHAT THEY KNOW... AND JASON AND WILDEN KNO THAT IAN KNOWS AND THEY ARE TRYING TO KILL HIM OR SUMTHING(KEEPIN UP?? lol) AND YEAH WEN HANNAH HAD THAT DREAM ALI GAVE HER SO MANY CLUES THAT I GOT. OH AND I THINK DAT COP LIKE ALI AND HE HATED IAN.. MAYBE JASON AND COP BOTH HATED HIM AND WEN THEY FOUND OUT HE WAS WITH ALI DEY WEN CRAZY!!!! BUT I ALSO THINK THAT THE PERSON WHO LOCKED IAN UP WAS WILDEN SO THAT HE COULDNT TELL THE COPS WHAT HE KNEW!!!!

Posted by LAN'EA on July 13, 2009 at 11:06 PM EDT #

OOOH YEAH AND THE NEXT BOOK COMES OUT ON NOVEMBER 09 2009! AND ITS CALLED HEARTLESS! AND I WAS LOOKIN AT ALL THE BOOKS 2DAY AND I REALIZED THAT THE DOLLS REPEATED AND THAT THE TITLE COLORS ARE REAPEATIN IN THE ORDER OF PINK, YELLOW, GREEN, PINK, YELLOW, GREEN.... SO THE NEXT BOOK SHOULD HAVE HEARTLESS IN PINK COLORING AND I WONDER WHAT COLOR THE WHOLE BOOK IS???? CUZ SHE USED PURPLE, BLUE,GREEN,ORANGE,HOT PINK AND YELLOW!!!!!! AND *SARA SHEPARD* IF YOU REASD THIS ONE I LIVE IN MARYLAND CAN YOU PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE HAVE A BOOK SIGNING OR SUMTHIN HERE I GOTTA GET YOU TO AUTOGRAPH A BOOK OR SUMTHIN!!!!!!

Posted by LAN'EA on July 13, 2009 at 11:12 PM EDT #

**SPOILER ALERT** OKAY I JUST HAD ANYOTHER THOUGHT!!! REMEBER HOW EVERYBODY KEPT ASKIN IS THE POLICE HIDING SOMETHIN! MAYBE ALI IS ALIVE AND THEY DONT WANT PEOPLE TO KNOW BECAUSE THEY WOULD GET IN TROUBLE IDK WHY THOUGH AND DATS WHY HER FAMILY MOVED AFTER THEY "FOUND HER BODY"!!! . AND JENNA HAD TOO MY FACIAL EXPRESIONS IF YOU ASK ME.,.,.,.,.,. I THINK SHE CAN SEE AND JUST HIDDIN IT OR SUMTHIN CUZ WHY IS SHE OUT AT NIGHT BEHIND (I FORGOT WHOS HOUSE) BUT YEAH. DATS KINDA FISHY TO ME! AND DONT FORGET MAYA SHE HAS TO HAVE SOMTHING TO DO WITH SOMTHING IDK YET BUT SHE DOES BCUZ SHE KEPT LOOKIN AT EMILY LIKE SHE KNEW SOMTHIN MAYBE SHE AND JENNA ARE FRIENDS AND SHE TOLD HER LIKE EVERYTHIN AND THE ARE A TOGETHER BECAUSE REMBER HOW JENNA SAID HER AND ALI WHERE KINDA FRIENDS OR WATEVE MAYBE ALI TOLD JENNA SUM SECRETS SO SHE KNEW STUFF AND SINCE HER AND MAYA ARE FRIENDS SHE TOLD MAYA 2 AND SINCE MAYA AND EMILY ARENT COOL AT ALL MAYBE SHE WANT TO GET HER BACK FOR GOING WITH A BOY!!!!!!!!!!!!!! JUST THINK ABOUT IT THIS IS ALL COMING TOGETHER TO ME!!!!! YOU GUYS TELL ME WHAT YOU THINK!!! --- LAN'EA

Posted by LAN'EA on July 13, 2009 at 11:24 PM EDT #

*KINDA SPOILING* I THINK THE COPS ARE HIDING THAT ALI IS ALIVE AND THATS WHY THE FUNERAL IS PRIVATE AND THE DNA IS READY YET!!! AND I THINK THAT MAYA KNOWS SUMTHIN BCUAZ HER AND JENNA ARE FRIENDS. AND SPEAKIN OF JENNA I THINK SHE ISNT BLIND ANYMORE CUZ SHE WAS IN TO MANY PLACES THAT BLIND PPL SHOULDNT BE LIKE CREEPIN BEHIND HOUUSE AND STUFF. AND I THINK SINCE SHE WAS KINDA FRIENDS WITH ALI THAT SHE WAS TOLD SOME SECRETS ABOUT THE GIRLS AND SHE SHARED THEM WITH MAYA AND NOW THEY ARE BOTH THE NEW A TOGETHER..... AND I THINK IAN IS WITH MELISSA BCAUZ THEY CANT FIND BOTH OF THEM AND SHE LEFT RIGHT AFTER IAN WAS FOUND "DEAD"....... i MEAN COME OON THINK BOUT IT!!!! YOU GUYS TELL ME WHAT YOU THINK! DO YOU AGREE??? ---- LAN'EA

Posted by LAN'EA on July 13, 2009 at 11:31 PM EDT #

SPOILER ALERT : i dont think ali has a twin it said clearly that jason used to have long blonde hair to . so it wasnt a twin it must be ali . but i do think ali fell in the hole and thats why there was dna there and i think she got into a coma. but the cops are hideing something maybe jason accitdently did that to her and widern has been covering for him scince he was the black car in the drive way etc.. . i think alir way in a coma and they had a fake funeral to make ali seem dead so no one else would know . like when ali came to hanna in her dream telling her that coma patients should be together .

Posted by carly on July 14, 2009 at 12:11 AM EDT #

maya and jenna are definitly hiding something. maya could have found out the girls secrets the same way the old a did, is by lookin through ali's old stuff. and jenna looks guilty like she knows something but isnt sharing it, maybe out of fear. ali has had to have some help, because all her stuff was thrown away, so someone has to be giving the girl a place to stay, food and clothes. plus the ali at the end of the book seemed less ali like, the one we've come to know as confident, controlling, and never backing down. in the end of killer ali seemed vulinerbly, scared, and ready to beg for forgiveness from her former friends. cant wait for the next book. there are alot of books out their that deal with rich girls with problems like gossip girl but this book is soo much better, and hooks you in instantly. face it a girl's life is nuthin without allitle drama, and in this book you have four girls filled with drama. this book was a thriller and keeps you guesing and guesing and no matter what we guess the ending always takes us by surprise and thats what a good book should do. it keeps you jumpy.

Posted by Naomi on July 14, 2009 at 01:20 AM EDT #

*SPOILERS* I can't believe it!!!!!!!!!!! I'm shocked. I can't wait for the next one!!!!!!!!!! It's killing me. It was BEYOND good. I don't think that Ali is still alive. Where could she have been all these years????? Doesn't make sense to me. And Plus it never mentioned if she grew or not. If she did it could have been a person who was supposed to be like here. Just watch in the next one someone will say "Ali?" then the girl would say something like "Who the hell is Ali?" If it really is her then I probably will scream for a half an hour. Or tell everyone. From halfway through Wicked and throughout Killer I knew Warren was in on it. He seemed really odd. OH MY GOSH. Excited for the next one. Don't know what to read in the meanwhile. Any suggestions?

Posted by Kylie on July 14, 2009 at 03:07 AM EDT #

Ok really though Widen and Jason are mentioned way to early in the book to have anything to do with murder or A. Like why would Sara mention them now as the killer you know?? Just seems off to me, my guess is that they just know where Ali is and maybe the Killed Ian?? Nah i think Melissa killed Ian (thx to emm) Doesn't it seem weird that Melissa just told Spencer she could use her old laptop KNOWING that Melissa's msn thing would pop up..And since it said it was coming from Rosewood and Melissa just "Vanished" (well left) SO either she killed Ian to cover up something or he is alive and Melissa is trying to fake Spencer out!! A is soo Jenna i just have to say lolol And if Ali is alive then someone pushed her into that rock,made her loose her memory and maybe put her in the hole?? but she got out?? Haha no clue let me know people!!

Posted by Mel-Locke on July 14, 2009 at 10:04 AM EDT #

SPOILER ALERRT!::::::::: well i think that they actually did find ali and because they said earlier on that th DNA wasnt sure if it was ali or not. but where could she have gone all this time? and why would she do that? but i still think that something suspiceus is going on with Jenna wilden and jason. but i wish it isnt i love jenna! but i also think that maybe Jenna isnt blind. think about that!

Posted by missy on July 14, 2009 at 10:04 AM EDT #

************SPOILER ALERT**********You guys did any of you guys think that the mind is the one playing the trick? It's what the girls hearts want. They want Ali to be alive. And so I believe that smoke got to their heads a little and imaging Ali,though this person really isn't Ali. I do believe that Jenna is able to see a little. I mean if you have a dog to help you do you really need Gucci glasses? You guys I'm not even kidding how badly I want to believe she's alive. But I'm sticking to my theroy. I think in Heartless Aria will get the nerve to tell her mom that she used to have a crush an Xavier. I sort of feel bad for Spencer but not really. She is rude. She didn't care who she was hurting as long as she got her way. My second reason is because of the foreshadowing done. Andrew is THE SMARTEST one in their class. HELLO?!?!?! Isn't that some sort of sign something is going to happen. But I feel bad because she's a victim. Just like the rest of them. At first I wanted to say Maya was A because when Emily dumped her Maya could have been heartbroken and wanted to get revenge. Then she was helping so I'm no longer sure. It will NOT be Jenna. Okay I'm done ranting now. Sorry.

Posted by Kylie on July 14, 2009 at 11:10 AM EDT #

*****SPOILER ALERT***** Did anyone ever think that the MIND is playing the trick???? Think about it...... The girls Hearts wish so badly for Ali to be alive. So the smoke did something to their brain and made an illusion of Ali though the person isn't Ali at all. Then with Jenna thing? Well I think she's partially blind. Why would you need big old Gucci glasses when you have a dog with you where ever you???? Something up with her. But I don't think She's A. I wanted to say Maya was in the beginning to get revenge on Emily but then She was helping so I'm not sure.

Posted by Kylie on July 14, 2009 at 11:21 AM EDT #

****SOME-WHAT SPOILER**** I think Aria might tell her mom About what happened with her and Xavier in the next book. I felt KIND of bad for Spencer. She's been nothing BUT rude to Andrew. She only cares for herself. It was obvious to me that something was going to happen with her.I consider it foreshadowing but..... I MEAN HELLO?!?!?!?! Andrew is the SMARTEST one in their class. Don't you think you should listen to THAT guy you've know for MOST instead of trying to be close with this so called "mom" you've only known for a COUPLE of hours. For some reason I say that Jenna is not A. It seems a little obvious. Sara wouldn't do that. So those are my guesses.

Posted by Kylie on July 14, 2009 at 11:31 AM EDT #

****SPOILER**** I think the body that was found in the ground could have been Ali BUT I have abother guess now the person was one of Ali's old friend and then Ali gave her the bracelet then when it was dark someone saw the bracelet in the moonlight and thought it was Ali. So they pushed her in the hole covered her up in dirt so the workers wouldn't see her. Some guesses. I'll stop. For now anyways.

Posted by Kylie on July 14, 2009 at 11:43 AM EDT #

Okay sorry I got the object wrong in my nlog thing the ring. orry I put bracelet. I get confused a lot with my books I'm reading one with something that involves a bracelet so.....

Posted by Kylie on July 14, 2009 at 01:04 PM EDT #

Naomi put yourself in this 'Ali' Shoes sure you may be confident about other things but wouldn't you panic??? EVERYONE loses their cool at some point. Probably most of their time is when they might die. So she probably would be scared if that is Ali.

Posted by Kylie on July 14, 2009 at 01:11 PM EDT #

I like the theory about Ali having been in a coma this whole time. It makes a lot of sense. I have a bad feeling about Jenna to. I hate not knowing if Ali is the victim in all this or if she brought it all on herself.

Posted by Bek on July 14, 2009 at 01:23 PM EDT #

Whats the deal with the flag piece?? What does it mean .. Ali lied about putting a manga frog on it and instead she put a J ... why would she put a J?? J for Jason as in they are close ... J for jason as in hes trying to kill her ... J for Jenna as in her best friend that no one knew about ...

Posted by Bek on July 14, 2009 at 01:27 PM EDT #

Hmm I have a few questions that i need answered so if you can, please answer them!!!! 1. We need to know what the picture with Ali, Naomi and Jenna was about..maybe That wasn't Naomi because member it said that it looked like her but it was kinda dark so maybe it was like Mona?? Namoi has blond hair and if it wasn't her maybe Mona at the time?? 2. Whats up with Jason like why was he never with his family on Sundays?? Maybe Sundays was when he went to the mental insatusion and Ali was just covering up for him by saying he went to the beach house by himself!! 3. The fight between Ali, Namoi and Riley?? Hmm.. Maybe Ali was hanging out with Mona and Jenna and so.. i dunno?? Help me otu if you cannn!!!

Posted by Mel-Locke on July 14, 2009 at 03:24 PM EDT #

Mel-Locke= i think that it wasnt namoi, i never did think that. i was also think it was mona. at first i was like omg your right about jason on sundays! but it cant be. because after the girls became friends jason stopped going to the mental insatusion. so i have a question also what is up with that frog thing on the flag?! if its what i think it is, i was thinking that ali just told the 4 of them that it had all these symbols and it didnt to maybe befriend them. i DO NOT think A is helping them. she is tricking them! i think ian is dead and some one is covering up for him. i think that "liar" and "killer" was meant for milessa not spencer. i was thinking that when that person who came back looking for something on the ground was melissa. and maybe she was sneaking around with widern or something. i dont like him. and the ALISON song he was singing... has anyone listened to it before!?: "Sometimes I wish that I could stop you from talking when I hear the silly things that you say. I think somebody better put out the big light, 'cause I can't stand to see you this way. Alison, I know this world is killing you. Oh, Alison, my aim is true. My aim is true." i think the thing about the J with a line threw it is that it had something to do with jason as in she hates him! like no more jason or something.

Posted by Beckay on July 14, 2009 at 04:14 PM EDT #

Mel-Locke= i think that it wasnt namoi, i never did think that. i was also think it was mona. at first i was like omg your right about jason on sundays! but it cant be. because after the girls became friends jason stopped going to the mental insatusion. so i have a question also what is up with that frog thing on the flag?! if its what i think it is, i was thinking that ali just told the 4 of them that it had all these symbols and it didnt to maybe befriend them. i think the thing about the J with a line threw it is that it had something to do with jason as in she hates him! like no more jason or something.

Posted by Beckay on July 14, 2009 at 04:15 PM EDT #

i DO NOT think A is helping them. she is tricking them! i think ian is dead and some one is covering up for him. i think that "liar" and "killer" was meant for milessa not spencer. i was thinking that when that person who came back looking for something on the ground was melissa. and maybe she was sneaking around with widern or something. i dont like him. and the ALISON song he was singing... has anyone listened to it before!?: "Sometimes I wish that I could stop you from talking when I hear the silly things that you say. I think somebody better put out the big light, 'cause I can't stand to see you this way. Alison, I know this world is killing you. Oh, Alison, my aim is true. My aim is true."

Posted by Beckay on July 14, 2009 at 04:16 PM EDT #

OMG!!! i just fininshed reading the book and *SPOILER ALERT* think that Jason found out about Ali and Ian and since he already hates Ian for stealing the love of his life got mad at Ali too. And remeber when Ian said he thought Ali was just flirting w/ him to make someone mad... she was probably doing it on purpose to make Jason mad! and I think Jenna had something to do w/ this whole thing because she HAD to have been peeved that Ali blinded her when the mission was to hit/scare Toby. Also the whole twin theory is questionable because if ALi had a twin her parents would have known about it (obviously) and people would have seen her. It's possible she might of had a twin when she was born but it died it would not be able to look like a preteen Ali it would have been a baby Ali. Also remeber that Ian was able to fake his death so Ali must have done the same and Jason and Wilden mustof thought she was dead and got freaked out to have murder on their phsycotic-stalker hands. But then Ali eneded up not being dead and they had to make her "disappear" and mybe dug up another body put it there and covered it up who knows. then when they realized people were starting to catch on they got Ali to come to the woods by Spencer's also knowing that Spence, Aria, Hanna and Emily would all be there and get burned to ashes taking their secrets with htem forever. but thats just my theory... (btw this is the best book out of the series i love it!!!:)

Posted by Jasmine on July 14, 2009 at 05:47 PM EDT #

OMG i luvlluvluvluvluvluvluvluvluvluvluvluvluvluv these books they r like my fav series ever they r SOOOOOOOOOOO much better than twilight and harry potter! i can NOT wait 4 the next 1 (does anybody know wat it will b called?)

Posted by Vicky on July 14, 2009 at 05:51 PM EDT #

Ok first off this is the best book in the series!!! and *SPOILER ALERT* i think that Jason and WIlden are the true culprits and that Jason found out that Ian and Ali were dating and since Jason already hated him for stealing the love of his life Melissa he got mad at him even more. And remeber Ian saying that he thought Ali was just flirting with him to make some one mad? She probably did ti to make Jason mad.

Posted by Jasmine on July 14, 2009 at 05:51 PM EDT #

*SPOILER ALERT* and ALi knew that but not knowing that her psychotic brother and creepy stalker lover would accidentally push her into a hole. maybe Jason was trying to give her a hug and she took a step backwards into the hole?? And Jason & Wilden thought she was dead and were afraid they would have murder on their hands. But then they realized Ali wasn't dead and knew they had to hide her away or make her "disappear" so that hteir secret owuld be safe. I also think Jenna might have something to do w/ it because she had to have been peeved that ALi blinded her when all she asked her to do was scare her brother.

Posted by Jasmine on July 14, 2009 at 05:56 PM EDT #

*SPOILER ALERT* also the twin theory that some people have been suggesting I dont think is the answer because if Ali had a twin her parents would have known about her. I mean do you think she put Ali's identical twin Cali in a closet or something for 13 years?!?! If she did have a twin (which is unlikely) it must of died at birth and Jason and Wilden couldn't of put her in the hole because thats twin BABY not twin PRETEEN Ali. they might of just done what Ian did and faked a body. We'll find out when the DiLarentis get their body DNA test back. unless Jason kills hem first because he has been in the loony house for a couple of years now... And im about 99.9% sure that new A is Melissa and she's trying to help them and make their lives missereable at the same time!

Posted by Jasmine on July 14, 2009 at 06:02 PM EDT #

*spoiler* okay so this might be a little far fetched but what if jenna is the one in the hole...ali could have dressed up as her and wore a wig so she could finally run away like she wanted to. i mean jenna was blind and she could have wondered back there when ali "died" or maybe she wanted ali dead or something like that and she ended up in the hole, all they had to do was put ali's ring on her finger. and they always say how big jenna's glasses are and those could easily cover up ali's blue eyes. also it would sorta explain why she was looking into aria's window. but if ali was jenna then she would have to be living with jenna's parents so then what would actually be in the main house where jason lives? and jenna's parents would probably know their daughter...okay so there's some holes but im not very fond of the twin idea. anyway most of the idea's prob arnt the right one cuz in the 1st 4 books it lead us to think that maya, melissa and other people were A when it was really mona sooo things will prob change...and thats also a reason why these books are so amazing!!!! haha

Posted by LYSSA!!! on July 14, 2009 at 06:08 PM EDT #

Bek and Mel-Locke : is ooo agree i also thought that the perosn w/ the blonde hair who looked like naomi could be mona or Jason and Ali and Jenna were taking a pix unknowingly that Jason was rigth behind them! that would be the person that does not belong or fit and yeah wat was the fight w/ naomi and riley about?!? and the manga frog is a symbol of peace which maybe Ali told them that instead of the no more Jason sign because she wished she had peace with her family and mainly her brother???

Posted by Jasmine on July 14, 2009 at 06:08 PM EDT #

i think carly is right. i think ali was in a coma and had amnesia or something. jason accidentally did it so it was being covred up by the family and the cops. but why would someone try to kill her in the woods in killer? but also i believe that jason or ali having a twin is a valid theory

Posted by kelly on July 14, 2009 at 06:16 PM EDT #

*spoiler* okay so i have a far fetch idea...jenna is in the hole. she could have been there when ali "died" either cuz she just wondered back there or she wanted ali dead but she fell into the hole. ali could have been pretending to be her so she could finally run away. all she had to do was put the ring on jenna's finger and put on a wig and sum big sunglasses which would cover up her eyes so no one would recognize her.also it would explain why she was looking into aria's window. and told aria that she had family issues.

Posted by LYSSA!!! on July 14, 2009 at 06:23 PM EDT #

i really hope that Aria just tells her mom that xavier is a bad person whose hitting on her! She should like hide Ella in a closet and have Xavier come in and listen in on all the flirty stuff he says to her!! and i really hope things start turning around for Spencer because her life really stinks so far. Her parents are being real meanies and need to just swallow their pride and remember that their the ones who adoptes Spencer and need to fullfil that role as a Parent instead of being little babies. Ok she embarresed the family whine pout then get over it! Also i am soooo proud of Emily for standing up to Isaac and not just jumping when he said he'll take her back. I know that's his mom but u should have an open opinion. Be on the fence call them both innocent until proven guilty. And im glad things for Hanna are working out ok even though i still think Kate is planning to do something evil i just dont know what...

Posted by Jasmine on July 14, 2009 at 06:24 PM EDT #

but if ali is jenna she'd most likely live with jenna's parents so what would be in the main house where jason lives? but jenna's parents would kno that she isn't their daughter to...unless they have something to do with it all...haha, anyways there are a few holes but like i said its far fetched and im not that fond of the whole twin idea =/ srry...and plus in the 1st 4 books we were lead to think that maya, melissa and other people were A when it was really mona so things are prob gonna change...and thats why these books are so amazing!!!!

Posted by LYSSA!!! on July 14, 2009 at 06:24 PM EDT #

to LYSSA!!: omg yeah i see wat u mean! and thats y Jason was yelling at "Jenna" because that's really Alison and they still have problems with each other. and like back during ALi's funeral you see "Jenna" and then she's gone and you see a big pair of blue eyes looking out of a window which could be "jenna" but really ALison looking back. also she has to wear glasses if Jenna is really Jenna and blind because without them ur eyes just look sunkien in and scary so instead of having people stare she puts on sum fab glasses

Posted by Jasmine on July 14, 2009 at 06:31 PM EDT #

where did melissa go? she is with ian somewhere, or is pretending to be him. like some ppl said, what if the KILLER and LIAR were meant for her? what if she killed ian and is pretending to be him? she gave her laptop to spence. maybe she was mad at him that he was with ali, but idk he could still be alive. and why was wilden searching in the woods after ians body disappeared?(he was missing so maybe he had something to do with it.) its so confusing. it is too obv. now that jason and wilden are the bad guys. a could just be framing them, and a could be the bad one. what doesnt make sense is wilden buying propane and being at jennas and alis. ppl think jenna is a... then that could mean jenna is actually a bad person and trying to trick them. and i somehow feel an wanna believe jenna is good. but she must be mad at the girls for blinding her, but she is definitely not blind. also a could be melissa, trying to cover her tracks and blame it on the others.

Posted by jess on July 14, 2009 at 06:39 PM EDT #

LYSSA!!!: i just read yours and it makes alot of sense. jenna couldve been really mad at ali and was somehow there. then ali thought it would be so easy to run away. mayb when she visited hanna in the hospital and the girl in the car with the blue eyes couldve been her without the wig and glasses. because it is unneccessary to wear glasses at night and in your house where no one else would be. haha you just gave me 50000 other ideas now. and jason could know shes being jenna and is mad at her.. but like you said whats in the main house?

Posted by jess on July 14, 2009 at 06:45 PM EDT #

to LYSSA!!: omg yeah i see wat u mean! and thats y Jason was yelling at "Jenna" because that's really Alison and they still have problems with each other. and like back during ALi's funeral you see "Jenna" and then she's gone and you see a big pair of blue eyes looking out of a window which could be "jenna" but really ALison looking back. also she has to wear glasses if Jenna is really Jenna and blind because without them ur eyes just look sunkien in and scary so instead of having people stare she puts on sum fab glasses

Posted by Jasmine on July 14, 2009 at 06:51 PM EDT #

Ok jess you stole my idea..thanks. I was the one who said what was up with Melissa leaving (look above for my other comments if you don't believe me) I said that she gave her old laptop to Spencer KNOWING that her msn thing would come up so she talked to Spencer pretending to be Ian... IAN IS DEAD AND MELISSA IS PRETENDING TO BE HIM.. and whoever was the first to say that the KILLER AND LIAR was ment for Melissa is a very good Ian... Jess read before you steal other peoples ideas thanks...

Posted by emm on July 14, 2009 at 08:42 PM EDT #

Alright first off Beckay, thanks for agreeing with me :p and yah i was just thinking maybe about Jason but yah he did stop going to the mental instatuion when the four girls became friends (just remembering that) And i totally agree with Beckay when you said that A is soo not helping them! Sara did say that A in the next book is way more sinister so i can't wait!!! lolol Also to whoever said that when Ian said Ali was just flirting with Ian to make Jason jellious.. I soo agree but maybe Melissa and Jason dated?? I dunno and yes emm and i came up with the idea about Melissa knowing Spencer would go on her laptop thing and yah maybe LYSSA!!! is right about Jenna being Ali, it does make a lot of sence!!!

Posted by Mel-Locke on July 14, 2009 at 09:02 PM EDT #

emm- i said "like some ppl said" before i wrote all that stuff. so that means i was agreeing with what you said. sorry that i didnt directly quote you because i saw that idea in like like 2 or 3 earlier posts and thought it would be easier saying some ppl instead of finding the names through the 300 posts. sorry

Posted by jess on July 14, 2009 at 09:20 PM EDT #

spoiler alert!!!! Im in love with these books but i have many questions! 1: whats ian doing? Is he dead or alive? 2: Was spencer's mom a fake or did A steal the cash somehow? 3: Is jason a phyco? And did he help with her "murder"? 4:Is the book emily found a fake or what? 5:Did wilden seriously just try to kill the girls? 6: WTF dose jenna have to do with any of this?!?!?!? 7:Is A helping the girls or making all the bad stuff happen? 8:and last but not least... Ali. -where has she been?? - is this really ali? -if so, who was found in the hole in the dilaurntis' backyard and whats her/his backstory? - is ali brainwashed? too many questions that need to be answered but i LOVE this book! cant wait for the next one! :))) job well done to the author!

Posted by jordan on July 15, 2009 at 02:21 AM EDT #

Okay you guys I know this idea is far out but do you think that in the main house there could be a bunch of pictures of Aria? Or video cameras around Rosewood and that he might be the one stalking the girls??????? Okay I saw someone saying that Ali was in the mnetal institution. But they didn't mention the twin theroy. That woul make the guess invalid. Because if you remember the girls were always at one anothers house on the weekend. So Ali couldn't be in the mental institution.

Posted by Kylie on July 15, 2009 at 03:17 AM EDT #

Then the whole Twin thing???? There is probably a good chance that is NOT true. Because A LOT of people are saying that. So Sara won't go for the obvious. And I agree with LYSSA!!!! She is totally right. She is smart just like Andrew!

Posted by Kylie on July 15, 2009 at 03:18 AM EDT #

First of all, I would like to say that these books are absolutely amaziing ! Second, everyone posting and reading these theories is only making them crave and more desperate for the next book to come out.and Third. wth i will add my own theory. I think that the girl in the woods probably isnt ali but her twin. Or that it is completely and purposely misleading and won't be either. for some reason i think jenna is a and she isnt really blind, and remember those pictures aria found of jason and a girl with dark hair and glasses, i think that it might be jenna and they may have dated. These books are awesome and sara shepard is really good at twisting and leaving cliff hangers. Suuuper excited for heartless !

Posted by Lauren on July 15, 2009 at 04:03 AM EDT #

Spoiler Alert! OMG! Killer was the best book by far! I read it in one day and I can't believe the ending! Ali maybe being back is going to make the next book so good! But I think the twin theory or the memory loss theory is really good! But the whole Jenna thing is super confusing! But I agree with Kylie that I think Jason and Jenna dated. I cant wait for the next book, it comes out on January 19, 2010 and is called Heartless. Cant wait!!

Posted by Meredith on July 15, 2009 at 12:06 PM EDT #

Oh my god! I just finished Killer last night, SPOILER: Ali's alive ?!??! And now we have to wait FIVE months for Heartless! Ugh! I really want to know if that was Ali or not. Jenna deffinatly knows something, and about JD and Wildon...what was the"my offer still stands" thing all abotu? maybe wildon was offering to kill ian...and it went really wrong, Ali could have tried to protect ian in the woods that night if her brother and Wildon came after him. Honestly though...i dont think that was Ali or her twin...it could be a dream or somethign like that because in the 'what happens next' it says it could all be smoke & mirrors. well who knows? i guess anything can happen. I WANT TI TO BE JANUARY 19TH already! heartless cant come out soon enough

Posted by Gina on July 15, 2009 at 01:13 PM EDT #

**SPOILER** Wowwww, by far the best book out of the series!. And not to sound like a know-it-all or anything..but I kind of suspected Ali to still be alive this whole time. Because they had never actually gotten back the DNA results. Also, Sara makes Ali sound like suchh an interesting character that I feel like she kind of has to have some part in the book and all. I'm just confused as to who was actually in the hole, because i'm not exactly sure of what i think about the twin theory yet. It's possible, but i sort of doubt it.. Sara wouldn't go for the obvious and a lot of people are saying that, again - i still dk.

Posted by Lo on July 15, 2009 at 03:45 PM EDT #

Oh, & as for Jenna, something is up with this girl. I dont think she's fully blind or maybe not blind at all. I cant figure her out but i think she's behind this whole thing obviously I was thinking she might actually be A but i feel like A is trying to help these girls sort of...and i dont think Jenna wants to help these girls at all. Idk though, it's hard to say but something isn't right about her..

Posted by Lo on July 15, 2009 at 03:46 PM EDT #

Alright baybays it's Mel-Locke and emm here! First off jess, we didn't know that is what you said, we didn't see it anywhere but thanks for apologising! Second, Kylie that is a pretty good theory, we both have to agree (:, But we are still thinking that Jason might have been hiding Ali in the house! Ok and everyone HEARTLESS COMES OUT NOVEMBER 9th NOT JANUARY 19th CHECK SARA'S TWITTER PAGE AND SEE!!! Also we do like the twin theory but we are not to sure if it is acurite because people are saying that since everyone is talking about it, it will prob not happen but we all no this is Pretty Little Liars..(: Jenna is A we are both pretty sure and Melissa, we think she killed Ian and is now pretending to be him by going and talking to Spencer on Melissa's msn thing! And we both agree with everyone who said that Liar and Killer were ment for Melissa! XXooxOxoxOOxo -Mel and emm

Posted by Mel-Locke/emm hun on July 15, 2009 at 06:05 PM EDT #

OMG ***spoiler alert*** okay so i know this is gonna sound crazy but from the begginging (like 1st &2nd book) me and my friend have thought that ali had a twin sister. and thats who they kept seeing when the thought they saw ali,,, so now that ali comes out of the woods in the end im starting to think that really is what happens,,,because if you think about it in one of the books it says they were talking to ali, then she came back down wearing completly different clothes... do you know what im talking about???? and i ALWAYS knew wilden was in on it. and i saw the whole "jason=physco" thing from the beggining of the book. and when aria invited him and he flipped out i knew he had been there!!! i offically can NOT wait for the next book. im obsessed!!!! YAYY

Posted by Becca M. on July 15, 2009 at 07:09 PM EDT #

i dont think the twin theory is right because if ali did have a twin wouldnt the girls have seen her at least once because of all the times they spent with her back then and if there was a twin why wouldnt have she lived with them

Posted by Alina on July 15, 2009 at 10:40 PM EDT #

Sweeet Heatless comes out on my birthday!!!!! Yay! hehe So o do somewhat agree with Alina that the "Ali has a twin theory" is a bit far fetched but if she did have a twin, the girls wouldn't have seen her because Jason or maybe Jenna has been hiding her. But that could also mean that they have been hiding Ali all this time so really, I just think they have been hiding Ali, not her twin. Jenna is up to something which sucks because i love that girl. And whoever had the theory of Ali pretending to be Jenna and that was really Jenna who was killed and Ali is now pretending to be her i sooo agreee it does make sence! Good theory!

Posted by Rachel G. on July 16, 2009 at 10:09 AM EDT #

SO i read some theories about how Jason stopped going to the mental institution once the girls became friends .. what if he just STOPPED visiting Ali when the girls became friends ... as in she stopped going to mental institution .. she lied about putting the manga frog on her flag piece and someone said it stood for peace so it must have meant something to her ... she was looking for peace .. maybe them becoming her friends brought her that peace ... as in someone else had been harassing or bothering her ... and i still think the J stands for Jenna NOT for Jason ... I like the theories about Killer and Liar being meant for Melissa as well .. that didnt occur to me while i was reading .. also .. i dont ppl should get mad ...no one is stealing ur ideas ... they just dont have time to read the 400 comments before they post theirs ...

Posted by Bek on July 16, 2009 at 11:39 AM EDT #

SPOILER ALERT: I just finished this book..I got it yesterday and have not stopped reading it..best one yet! I am so glad we found out more about her killers..I always suspected Jason had something to do with it, but never Wilden! I cannot believe that Ali is coming back into this..could it actually be her? Doesn't seem possible but with these book we really never know! I NEED ANSWERS! can't wait for the next book!!!!!! :]

Posted by Mare on July 16, 2009 at 12:07 PM EDT #

i just thought of something and had to run it by a few of you ... what if Wilden was the relationship ALi was in with an "older guy" and not Ian ... he and himself said what they had was basically nothing she was just suddenly interested in him ...i think its because Wilden was an obsessive boyfriend and she wanted Ian for protection to scare him off. In the song he was singing "Alison" the guy singing is a jealous obessive EX boyfriend. Also in the photo from a few books back of the day they announced the time capsule it was Ali, and Jason and Ian and their confrontation ... it shows Ali looking frightened ... we just recently learned that wilden was in a black car only a few yards from her (the one Jason hops in) and they "speed off" they speed off bcus Wilden is mad about seeing Ali with Ian.

Posted by Bek on July 16, 2009 at 01:10 PM EDT #

Now ... reasons why i think Ali was the one in the mental hospital. In book one she hynotizes the girls and said she learned from her older field hockey friends--therapists hynotize u when they are trying to get u to remember or talk about supressed memories ... also, in the dream hannah has while she is a coma .. memory of them all in Ali's backyard .. Ali says something to the extent of i wish she would stop ruining my life or trying to take whats mine i think she was ...she could have been referring to voices or an alternate personality ... also once again the song Alison the part where is says "sometimes i wish i could stop you from talking when i hear the silly stuff u say" could refer to her crazy person babbling she did that wilden remembers ...and thats why he relates the song to her ... bcus of his crazy love obsession for a crazy little girl ... the word "silly" in the song also implies that the singer sees the girl as a child .. which again relates wilden to ali ..

Posted by Bek on July 16, 2009 at 01:20 PM EDT #

Also, I think she confided in Ian what was going on ... in Arias video clip ... Ali and Ian are seen holding/locking pinkys ... kinda like he was saying i promise ill protect you ... heck maybe thats where Ian really went ..not to college .. he and Ali successfully ran away together ... might love related .. but maybe just out of protection for her ... and maybe he came back to rosewood to try to take Wilden down ... found out he was a cop ... ian was obviously investigating the cops--especially Wilden

Posted by Bek on July 16, 2009 at 01:30 PM EDT #

OH MY GOSH!!! that was the best one so far!!!(killer) but im so confused!!! i semi hope ali didnt come back she was not very nece. but wat about jenna?!!?!?!?! WHAT THE HECK IM SO CONFUSED I NEED THE NEXT ONE TO COME OUT.....now. does anyone kno when it comes out i will love you forever!!!!

Posted by Gabriella Blaise on July 16, 2009 at 06:27 PM EDT #

Hey! I haven't read killer yet but people I know have and they say it's amazing =) When is the next book coming out?

Posted by Rosie on July 16, 2009 at 07:35 PM EDT #

dude this book is making ME go insane!! lolol. wow i NEED the next one to come out like soon im killing myself trying to figure it all out!! plz plz hurry ...noo rush ...but hurry plz!! lolol. its really shocking but i love it. its soo twisted && genius!! gahhhh i want to read the next one already i cant wait any longer!!!!! well i love how the whole plot ended in killer though it was the perfect ending to the book no one would have guessed!! my face was seriously like :O :O :O :O lolol. yeah well i cant wait to see whats next!!! -xxoxx, MaKaYlA

Posted by makayla on July 16, 2009 at 08:42 PM EDT #

It would kind of be hard for Jenna to be A considering she's blind, how would she get the pictures and most things A text abouts is things that had to be seen.

Posted by Taylor on July 16, 2009 at 09:28 PM EDT #

SPOILER ALERT!!!~I stayed up all night reading Killer the day it came out! How could Ali be alive?! The next couple months are going to be torture, but I just cannot wait for Heartless! xoxoxo Jenn

Posted by Jenn on July 16, 2009 at 10:11 PM EDT #

SPOILER ALERT!! how could Ali be alive? whose body was it that was found in her back yard? where did Ali go for 3 1/2 years? if Jason and Wilden didnt kill her, what are they hiding? i cant believe Spencer's faux mom would do that..and that Spencer would believe her. and Hannah and Mike? Wow...but maybe it will work out! i think Isaac deserved that..i dont know if i want Emily and him to get back together. i didnt really want Ali back because i loved how the whole story was based around her best friends who tried to discover her secrets and find out what happened the night she disappeared. but its also good she is back because they can finally find out the truth. and no offense, but my opinion is that Ali doesnt have a twin. and i think Ian is alive and he rean away so he wouldnt be blamed but he got the wrong info about Jason and Wilden. and by the way, Heartless comes out in Nov. 09

Posted by hannah..my real name on July 17, 2009 at 03:11 AM EDT #

SPOILER ALERT! and also i dont think that Jenna could be A because when she was in the art class with Aria, she spilled all that stuff to Aria. and i doubt A would do something like that. and i dont know if she would fake being blind..that would be hard.

Posted by hannah..my real name on July 17, 2009 at 03:32 AM EDT #

Hmm i do think Bek had a good idea as too Ali secret boyfriend being Wilden! Maybe instead of Ian being the one to protect her, it could have been she was trying to make Widen jellious by pretending to like Ian so like when Ian and Ali locked pinkies, it was just because he thought they were together..and when she looked so depresed, she was probably thinking of Widen and maybe Widen was who she was texting! I dunno possibly. And i do think Ian is dead and Melissa is pretending to be him. She told Spencer that she could use her old laptop KNOWING that Melissa's msn would pop up and it was coming from Rosewood, meaning Melissa is in Rosewood pretending to be Ian!

Posted by emm on July 17, 2009 at 10:23 AM EDT #

Also i'm am wondering if Jason or Ali was in the instatution? I am not sure! I really feel bad for Hanna, I mean great for her and Mike, but Kate..what a be-och like really though and i know she is up to something but i know she is not A for sure I know that. But you know how Ali and Kate were friends?? Maybe if Ali is alive that was who Kate was talking to on the phone in Wicked.. Aria, well Jason is odd and she needs to tell her mom about that creap of a man her mom is dating.. Emily, i was soo mad about her and Isacc but then again his mom is a freaksoyed so see ya bye Isacc! And Spencer! Man her life SUCKS!! She just can't win.. And if Ali is alive then will that make all there lives better of worse?? A lost of questions lolol

Posted by emm on July 17, 2009 at 10:31 AM EDT #

I don't like Mike and Hanna together.. I think Mike is too disgusting and mean to girls. I don't like him at all.

Posted by Jenna on July 17, 2009 at 01:31 PM EDT #

SPOILER ALERT! Alison can't be alive! I hope she isn't! But the police people didn't do a test on the persons body in Ali's old backyard to make sure itsreally her. So she could still be alive. But how would she make it i think like 4 or 5 years on her own without money. She didnt stare & why would she not go to the police or her parents or somebody to tell them she is alive. It doesn't make sense that she would hide that she is alive & live on her own! omg. i can 't believe Emily&Isaac broke up. They were so adorable together! Hanna is annoying me, she's such a bitch to everybody. I think Kate is trying to be her friend! I like Mike and Hanna together though, I think they are cute. I want Ezra to come back! Him & Aria were so cute together! I miss him in the story!!!!!!!!!!! Spencer should get over the mom thing I would flip out on my parents if they treated me like the way hers do to her. There's no way i would let them do that to me so many times. She should really say something! It has to be wilden & jason! i mean they are both deffidently hiding something bigg! They always look like they were doing something bad & they were old friends talking bad about Ian. & Ian did say people were after him! UGH. this book is so confusing&addicting!!

Posted by lexi on July 17, 2009 at 05:35 PM EDT #

Bek i like your idea of ali secretly dating wilden! it makes sense because like you said the song he was singing, and also he's a bad boy and somewhere it was said she was dating a bad boy? idk but one thing im confused about is the beginning of killer. so ali and jason(apparently?) were fighting and he shoved something(maybe her) and there was a crashing sound. then he runs off angry with her flag piece. so ali keeps looking back at the woods like shes looking for someone. and the upstairs light turns off.. then ali goes in her house right when she sees her mom turning down the street and the upstairs light turns right on again. does anyone else think someone was in her room before that? maybe it was wilden because hanna saw his car in front of the house after she went inside. i was always confused about it but maybe its nothing. does anyone understand what was going on there? and also what reason did jason have to take her flag piece?

Posted by jess on July 17, 2009 at 06:05 PM EDT #

this is totally off topic but i want to know what others think...do u want emily to get back together with isaac or maya?

Posted by shadow on July 17, 2009 at 07:32 PM EDT #

One of the BEST series I've EVER read!! (and i read alot) It is soooo amazing I can't wait for the next one to come out!! I wonder if Ali's really back... and if she is then who is in her grave?!?!

Posted by Alexandra on July 17, 2009 at 07:38 PM EDT #

did emily and isaacs have s-e-x or just slept in bed together? and i think emily and isaac should get back together

Posted by alex on July 17, 2009 at 07:42 PM EDT #

When Ali hypnotized the girls, they all has a dream about her falling into a well, and that was what was on her flag.

Posted by Abbi on July 17, 2009 at 08:56 PM EDT #

SPOILER. wow! i reallllly like killer. i think that ali is really alive, but the only thing is that when they were digging the whole in the backyard at alis house, they found her body so that confused me. but i think that maya and jenna are A cause throughout the book, mayas around watching the girls, and the girls are always hearing giggles, so a is obvoiusly a girl. im super excited for the next book!! (:

Posted by halle on July 18, 2009 at 01:59 PM EDT #

SO SIKED FOR HEARTLESS(next book). Just finished killer, and i loved it! but the ending how is it possible? I NEED TO KNOW. only a couple more months*sigh*. I bought the book read it finished in one day. I have never been so drawn to a book before. Pumped for January 9th :)

Posted by scarlett on July 19, 2009 at 12:44 AM EDT #

Okay, I'm pretty sure I have it figure out. But then again, whenever I think that, I'm never right haha. I'm like 99.9% positive that Ali has a twin. It makes complete sense when you read the book, and explains why Ali didn't recognize them when they saw her at the end of Killer. Idk, just a theory i guess (:

Posted by Alyssa on July 19, 2009 at 01:57 AM EDT #

read the book in 4 hours AHMAZING! i am soo sad about Isaac and Emily. Emily shoulda taken him back. Spoiler ALERT!!! i think Naomi mite b A or maybe Maya. bc of the picture of her and Ali. And watever happened to Aria's old bf (the teacher)??? isn't she ever gonna visit him in jail??? I think kate might of had herpes......wat else could it b????? i am still not understanding how they saw ian dead but yet hes iming them. is it rlly him??? and where is melissa in all the midst of this????

Posted by AK on July 19, 2009 at 04:51 AM EDT #

CHECK OUT MY SITE FOR PRETTY LITTLE LIAR DISCUSSIONS!!! WILL POST MORE!! GO TO MUNASOCCERLOVR.WEBS.COM!! CHECK IT OUT!

Posted by Muna on July 19, 2009 at 12:05 PM EDT #

Wow! Amazing! Was it just me, or did anyone else pick up on the fact that Jason was in love with Melissa? It would give Jason a double reason to hate Ian- stealing the one he loves and his sister. You'd be mad too, especially if you had mental problems. Maybe Ali's alive but then...who was the girl in the hole with Ali's ring?

Posted by Ali on July 19, 2009 at 12:51 PM EDT #

i think whoever A is has to be someone thats tied in with the whole alis murder thing it has to be someone who is involved and wud have a reason 4 tellin the grls to find out who killed ali because y wasnt A tauntin them as usual unless they had a motive 4 getting them to find out who killed ali i mean when a was mona she only started talkin bout alis murder so that she could blame spencer 4 it but other than that she never cared at all who killed ali so y does this new A care?

Posted by sabrina on July 19, 2009 at 01:38 PM EDT #

SPOILER ALERT: I am totally shocked, but yet again I'm just kind of weirded out, if you know what I mean. I had a feeling throughout the series that Wilden was in on something. And that makes sense to why Jason freaked out by the Radley invitation...considering he used to be a patient there. And I think when it was one of Aria's chapters, they say that DNA hasn't showed that the body found buried in the ground is definitelly Ali. I think Ian tried to protect her from Jason & Wilden, and they ran away somewhere else. And 'A' must be Jason or Wilden, because 'A' told them to go to the barn in the first place. And I was thinking that Wilden had a perverted crush on Ali (That's why he stalked her) and that he wanted to get Ian in trouble (because Ian and Ali were together & Wilden was jealous) As for Melissa, I guarentee you that she is either hiding away with Ian, or is part of the plot with Jason (Remember: Melissa had wrote in her notebook that she had made out with someone initialed JD 'Jason DiLaurentis'. And that he was mad whenever he saw Ian and Melissa together) So MAYBE Melissa and Jason were a secret couple, just like Ali and Ian were! I am still shell-shocked because Ali appeared, but then again I was expecting a twist to come up like that.

Posted by alexaandraax3 on July 19, 2009 at 03:36 PM EDT #

i think melissa is just rude i mean i understand y she would b mad at spencer but like she steals evrything from her and she gets watever she wants and her parents dont even pay attention to spencer but seriously i no spencer deserves alot of things that shes got but her parents dont hav to b i cant blieve ur my daughter u should just move out i never want to c u again i understand that but wat they dont get is that well saying u never want to c ur daughter again and saying that i hate u and all that crap they would probably lose her for like evr and the thing is that spencers parent dont care they dont care if everyone hates her they dont give a crap anymore its like she doesnt excist its so wrong!

Posted by bigreadhead101 on July 19, 2009 at 03:37 PM EDT #

OMG-JUST GOT A THOUGHT! (Spoiler Alert) Melissa obviously knew that Ian was going to IM Spencer (Thinking it was Melissa) But maybe Melissa WANTED to help Spencer, knowing that Ian would give her hints & tell her what she needed to know

Posted by alexaandraax3 on July 19, 2009 at 03:46 PM EDT #

omg!!!!!!!!! that ending was awesome! i think the next book is called heartless, and it is coming out on jan. 19th 2010! i cant wait that long!!! ahhhhhhh... anyway the ending to killer was so shocking! i just finished reading it and i couldnt put it down until i finished it! i cant believe ali is alive!!!! omg it rox!

Posted by maddy on July 19, 2009 at 03:48 PM EDT #

OOOH SNAPPPP SABRINA YOU ARE SOOO RITE MONA DIDNT GIVE A HOOT ABOUT WHO KILLD ALI! SHE JUST WANTED TO TORTURE THE GIRLS AND THE NEW A THATS LIKE ALL SHE CARES ABOUT IS WHO KILLED ALI, ALIS FAMILY & FRIENDS, AND PPL WHO ARE INVOLVED WITH THE MURDER!

Posted by LAN'EA on July 19, 2009 at 05:28 PM EDT #

The ending was insane!! I knew something was up with Wilden that he had to be hiding something, never would have guessed that he was hiding something that big. The suspense is killing me for the next book. Does anybody know when it is supposed to come out?

Posted by Andrea on July 20, 2009 at 12:32 AM EDT #

See alexaandraax3, that is what i was getting at!! (: Melissa knew that her msn would pop up if Spencer used her onld laptop! Meaning that Melissa would "make up" a fake msn from Ian so she could fake Spencer out! Ian has to be dead!...It said that the feed was coming from Rosewood..MEANING MELISSA!!! Also Andrea, HHEARTLESS COMES OUT NOVEMBER, 9th (: (: NOT JANUARY 19th

Posted by emm on July 20, 2009 at 10:26 AM EDT #

Alright so my theory is that Widen and Ali were "secret lovers" and yes whoever said that at the begining of Killer when the fight with Ali and Jason happened that Wilden wad there...I agree i think that since Hanna saw his car, he was there and maybe the fight was because Jason and Widen were friends?? Maybe, and Jason didn't want them to date and since Jason hated Ian she used Ian to tell Jason that it's either Ian or Widen...like and altimatum! This knew A does seem to be helping the girls try to figure out what was with Ali but Sara did say in the next book A is way more sinister so i'm looking forward to that (; NOVEMBER 9th!!!!!!!

Posted by Rachel G. on July 20, 2009 at 10:35 AM EDT #

Sorry i posted that twice!! Anyway also maybe A is Jenna, but she is Ali! and maybe she just pretended not to remember them because she was never supposed to be scene that way! maybe she had to meet someone "out of disguse" and the girls saw her and she had to cover up because she wasn't supposed to be seen that way! I dunno just an idea but in that picture, it shows Ali, Jenna and someone that looks like Naomi..Well i don't think it was Naomi, I think It was Ali, Jenna and Mona!!! But why???? I am not sure, and hopefully we will ind out in Heartless!!!! (: (: (: (: xxoo

Posted by Rachel G. on July 20, 2009 at 10:38 AM EDT #

SPOILER ALERT! Aaah! I knew it! This whole time I just felt that Ali was still alive. And I think that her parents know. And Jason knows too. And that is the REAL secret he is keeping from them. They could have easily used a body double. Or it could have been someone else. But who knows? Sometimes I'm wrong about these things.

Posted by Jamia on July 20, 2009 at 01:32 PM EDT #

i agree with Rachel G. on the wilden and ali lover theory cuz doesnt ali say that she likes a bad boy, which wilden totally was and ian was the good boy of rosewood. and plus sara is leading us to think that wilden started the fire and she did that in the 1st 4 books with A so he prob didnt do anything

Posted by LYSSA!!! on July 20, 2009 at 05:12 PM EDT #

just have a short theory building on what a lot of people have said: i'm pretty sure jason and wilden were only mad about the fact that ian dated both melissa and ali. because in the yearbook wilden says "I can't believe what that asshole did." meaning not only did ian steal melissa from jason but he's also screwing around with jason's sister. i honestly think thats it. i don't think that they had anything else against the guy and i'm pretty sure A is framing them. I also think there's something wrong with Ali, mentally. I used to believe she has a twin, but now that seems too obvious, and Sara doesn't make things that evident. Maybe she had an alternate personality, or simply bad memory, there are a lot of signs that point to it. Not too many people have said anything about a multiple personality disorder, but its definitely possible, with this book, actually anything is possible hahaha. Anyway i can't wait for heartless!!! Its sure to be amazinggg.

Posted by sarah on July 20, 2009 at 06:51 PM EDT #

ok, i've NEVER read these books so keep that in mind. my friends just told me about them so i thought i'd check it out. but from reading these comments and what my friends say, i think that the twin theory is possible (and things like that have actually happened b4 in real life) but i dont think that would be my first guess. another thing to consider when reading a book, the words can be interperated in several ways which gives the author somewhat of a back door. she can distract you by leading you to believe this one theory while actually created an entirely different scene. its kinda like subtext to all those actresses out there. everyone may believe that a is actually a 'bad guy' who is trying to ruin everyones lives but maybe they are just provoking the girls which enhances their senses. they look more carefully now and maybe a is just leading them into the resolution of the crime. theyre finding the 'murderer' and maybe even growing closer to each other. but who knows?

Posted by agirl on July 20, 2009 at 07:04 PM EDT #

no this A is "much more sinister" than mona sara shepard said so in her interview. i wish SOME1 could be nice for once though, these books are giving me bad vibes lol

Posted by CoachCutie <3 on July 20, 2009 at 08:15 PM EDT #

I can't believe this ending!!!!! When is the next one coming out???????

Posted by Crazzy on July 20, 2009 at 08:24 PM EDT #

I haven't read Killer yet but I'm going 2 buy it soon. Wilden's acting strange! I think he's A! Or maybe he killed Ian. Idk. I really want 2 read Killer!

Posted by Jenna on July 20, 2009 at 08:31 PM EDT #

SPOILER ALERT! Please read ! Theories: I have it ALL figured out! For Spencer's momma drama: The grandma that died was Spencers DADS mom (everyone knows that). I think that Spencer's mom cheated on Spencer's dad with Ali's dad. Spencer's mom got pregnant and had Spencer, which would explain the hostility because maybe Spencer's mom is angry at Spencer for selling out her affair, etc. Also explains why Ali and Spencer look so much alike and how Spencer's mom would always get angry when Spencer and Ali pretended to be sisters and stuff. And the affair could have been anywhere, because I know that Ali's family didn't know Spencers until like 3rd grade or something. It could have been a one night stand on a business trip or a sperm donor thing or whatever you want to think for that part. For Ali/Jason: I think that Ali had a twin that had some mental problems. Jason would visit her every Sunday at the mental hospital. That would explain why Jason got the phonecall "from his sister" during school during the flashback. I think that Ali wanted to maintain her "perfect life" and admitting that she had a mentally impaired twin would ruin everything for her, so she never visited. Then Jason would get mad because he was a good brother and felt like Ali shouldn't pretend that she didn't have a sister and should visit her, but Ali wanted nothing to do with her. So then that would explain the "sibling problems" that Jenna explained. Then the Radley place closed and they had to take Ali's twin out and bring her to the house. The murder night: They got in a fight at the barn, Ali went outside, Spencer went outside. They had a little argument, Spencer pushed Ali but then Spencer fell backwards, the sound of the crack was her own head on the rock. She was on the ground unconcious for awhile, this could be the time when Ian and Ali had their talk, then Spencer woke up again and looked across the lawn to see Jason and Ali's twin arguing over something. (this is where my theories get a little shaky, but everything up until here I am almost positive of). Okay so then I think that Jason pushed Ali's twin into the hole and she hit her head and died. Then I think Spencer went unconsious again while Wilden, Jason, and Ali filled the hole in a little bit to cover the body but not enough to make anyone go "hmm, the hole was empty when we went to bed last night and now its full". Then everyone ran into the woods. After the murder night: The next day Ali's parents wake up to find no Ali-twin in the house. Wilden, Jason, and Ali aren't about to confess so they send out a missing persons report, but they send it out looking like Ali is the one missing because no one knew about the twin. So they move away and Ali has to go into hiding. Jenna knows everyhing and has been Ali's true best friend the entire time. Present day: Ali had been living in the main part of her parents house, thats why Jason really didn't want Aria to go into the main house and was so angry when she might have. Ali and Jenna had been working as a team. Jenna had gotten her vision back the year the A notes started coming and Jenna and Ali worked as a team to be A. Jenna always wears her sunglasses because she doesn't want anyone to look into her eyes and see that they are perfectly clear and not blind. Ali tells Jenna everything she knows about all of them and they stalk the girls together. Mona could have been in on it and been one of the stalkers, which is why when she died the A notes kept coming. Thats how A could seem to be in more than one place at one time, because it was actually 3 people (before Mona died) and two people after Mona died. The blonde hair flashes are of Ali and Jenna (they both have blonde hair). Ali couldn't come out of hiding because everyone thinks she is dead and Jason and Wilden can't tell anyone anything because they would go to jail for murder or assisting murder or withholding information from the police. The thing the police are in on is the fact that Ali is really alive and that it was a twin in the hole that they dug up. Ian doesn't know that there is a twin so he thinks that he saw Jason kill Ali, and Wilden knows that Ian saw. Ian, dead?: Wilden and Jason know that Ian saw because Ian gave his statement to Wilden about Jason. Wilden beat up Ian and he thought he was dead. He left him in the forest and came out just in time for the girls to get the message from A to go in. They went in the forest and saw Ian's body, Hanna tripped and Ali stood over her, "Shh." Then the girls left and Ali and Jenna grabbed Ian and brought him to Jenna's and helped him get better. That's where he was when he said he was still in Rosewood. When the girls brought Wilden into the forest and Ian wasn't there, he got jumpy because Ian was SUPPOSED to be there, thats where he had left him. Then Wilden went looking around for him or for Jason in the forest. Jenna and Jason arguing: Jason went to Jenna's house and found Ian there, and they had a big argument because it was Jason and Wilden who had tried to kill Ian. But Jenna didn't want anyone else to die so she and Ali had saved him. Jason told Jenna that Ian had to go and Jenna had said No so Jason stormed out of the house. Then the Jenna and Ali had moved Ian to a safer place (to Mellissa's) and Mellissa needed to get out of there fast so she could keep Ian safe. The fire: Spencer, Emily, and Hanna are in the barn. Ali is in the forest, trapped, and Jenna is elsewhere (hiding? already dead? not enough information). Wilden decided that Ali knew too much and that she was going to turn him and Jason in. He also decided that the girls knew too much. So he started the barn and the forest on fire, making sure all the girls would burn to death. Ali had gotten a note that said she had to be there in the forest that night from Wilden. Ali didn't recognize them right away because she got bonked on the head from that log and so she is momentarilly delusional or she has lost some memory. So pretty much Wilden is going to try to kill them all (: If you feel like correcting something or sharing your theories with me, email me : rsmtvolleyball.babe@Yahoo.com

Posted by Nicolette <3 on July 20, 2009 at 10:16 PM EDT #

Okay theory number two ! :For Ali/Jason: I think that Ali had a twin that had some mental problems. Jason would visit her every Sunday at the mental hospital. That would explain why Jason got the phonecall "from his sister" during school during the flashback. I think that Ali wanted to maintain her "perfect life" and admitting that she had a mentally impaired twin would ruin everything for her, so she never visited. Then Jason would get mad because he was a good brother and felt like Ali shouldn't pretend that she didn't have a sister and should visit her, but Ali wanted nothing to do with her. So then that would explain the "sibling problems" that Jenna explained. Then the Radley place closed and they had to take Ali's twin out and bring her to the house.

Posted by Nicolette <3 on July 20, 2009 at 10:19 PM EDT #

(They aren't seperate theories, they all go together, they're just in parts because its all so long) Theory part 3:twin out and bring her to the house. The murder night: They got in a fight at the barn, Ali went outside, Spencer went outside. They had a little argument, Spencer pushed Ali but then Spencer fell backwards, the sound of the crack was her own head on the rock. She was on the ground unconcious for awhile, this could be the time when Ian and Ali had their talk, then Spencer woke up again and looked across the lawn to see Jason and Ali's twin arguing over something. (this is where my theories get a little shaky, but everything up until here I am almost positive of). Okay so then I think that Jason pushed Ali's twin into the hole and she hit her head and died. Then I think Spencer went unconsious again while Wilden, Jason, and Ali filled the hole in a little bit to cover the body but not enough to make anyone go "hmm, the hole was empty when we went to bed last night and now its full". Then everyone ran into the woods.

Posted by Nicolette <3 on July 20, 2009 at 10:20 PM EDT #

(My theory is actually one big one, broken into parts, NOT many differnet theories) Part three! :The murder night: They got in a fight at the barn, Ali went outside, Spencer went outside. They had a little argument, Spencer pushed Ali but then Spencer fell backwards, the sound of the crack was her own head on the rock. She was on the ground unconcious for awhile, this could be the time when Ian and Ali had their talk, then Spencer woke up again and looked across the lawn to see Jason and Ali's twin arguing over something.

Posted by Nicolette <3 on July 20, 2009 at 10:21 PM EDT #

Part four: The murder night continued:(this is where my theories get a little shaky, but everything up until here I am almost positive of). Okay so then I think that Jason pushed Ali's twin into the hole and she hit her head and died. Then I think Spencer went unconsious again while Wilden, Jason, and Ali filled the hole in a little bit to cover the body but not enough to make anyone go "hmm, the hole was empty when we went to bed last night and now its full". Then everyone ran into the woods. After the murder night: The next day Ali's parents wake up to find no Ali-twin in the house. Wilden, Jason, and Ali aren't about to confess so they send out a missing persons report, but they send it out looking like Ali is the one missing because no one knew about the twin. So they move away and Ali has to go into hiding. Jenna knows everyhing and has been Ali's true best friend the entire time.

Posted by Nicolette <3 on July 20, 2009 at 10:23 PM EDT #

Part five ! (wooh i told you this was long!): Present day: Ali had been living in the main part of her parents house, thats why Jason really didn't want Aria to go into the main house and was so angry when she might have. Ali and Jenna had been working as a team. Jenna had gotten her vision back the year the A notes started coming and Jenna and Ali worked as a team to be A. Jenna always wears her sunglasses because she doesn't want anyone to look into her eyes and see that they are perfectly clear and not blind. Ali tells Jenna everything she knows about all of them and they stalk the girls together. Mona could have been in on it and been one of the stalkers, which is why when she died the A notes kept coming. Thats how A could seem to be in more than one place at one time, because it was actually 3 people (before Mona died) and two people after Mona died.

Posted by Nicolette <3 on July 20, 2009 at 10:24 PM EDT #

Part six : present day continued:The blonde hair flashes are of Ali and Jenna (they both have blonde hair). Ali couldn't come out of hiding because everyone thinks she is dead and Jason and Wilden can't tell anyone anything because they would go to jail for murder or assisting murder or withholding information from the police. The thing the police are in on is the fact that Ali is really alive and that it was a twin in the hole that they dug up. Ian doesn't know that there is a twin so he thinks that he saw Jason kill Ali, and Wilden knows that Ian saw.

Posted by Nicolette <3 on July 20, 2009 at 10:25 PM EDT #

Part seven: Ian, dead?: Wilden and Jason know that Ian saw because Ian gave his statement to Wilden about Jason. Wilden beat up Ian and he thought he was dead. He left him in the forest and came out just in time for the girls to get the message from A to go in. They went in the forest and saw Ian's body, Hanna tripped and Ali stood over her, "Shh." Then the girls left and Ali and Jenna grabbed Ian and brought him to Jenna's and helped him get better. That's where he was when he said he was still in Rosewood. When the girls brought Wilden into the forest and Ian wasn't there, he got jumpy because Ian was SUPPOSED to be there, thats where he had left him. Then Wilden went looking around for him or for Jason in the forest.

Posted by Nicolette <3 on July 20, 2009 at 10:25 PM EDT #

Part eight! : Jenna and Jason arguing: Jason went to Jenna's house and found Ian there, and they had a big argument because it was Jason and Wilden who had tried to kill Ian. But Jenna didn't want anyone else to die so she and Ali had saved him. Jason told Jenna that Ian had to go and Jenna had said No so Jason stormed out of the house. Then the Jenna and Ali had moved Ian to a safer place (to Mellissa's) and Mellissa needed to get out of there fast so she could keep Ian safe. The fire: Spencer, Emily, and Hanna are in the barn. Ali is in the forest, trapped, and Jenna is elsewhere (hiding? already dead? not enough information). Wilden decided that Ali knew too much and that she was going to turn him and Jason in. He also decided that the girls knew too much. So he started the barn and the forest on fire, making sure all the girls would burn to death. Ali had gotten a note that said she had to be there in the forest that night from Wilden. Ali didn't recognize them right away because she got bonked on the head from that log and so she is momentarilly delusional or she has lost some memory. So pretty much Wilden is going to try to kill them all (:

Posted by Nicolette <3 on July 20, 2009 at 10:27 PM EDT #

Part eight ! :Jenna and Jason arguing: Jason went to Jenna's house and found Ian there, and they had a big argument because it was Jason and Wilden who had tried to kill Ian. But Jenna didn't want anyone else to die so she and Ali had saved him. Jason told Jenna that Ian had to go and Jenna had said No so Jason stormed out of the house. Then the Jenna and Ali had moved Ian to a safer place (to Mellissa's) and Mellissa needed to get out of there fast so she could keep Ian safe.

Posted by Nicolette <3 on July 20, 2009 at 10:28 PM EDT #

And last but not least, Part Nine : The fire: Spencer, Emily, and Hanna are in the barn. Ali is in the forest, trapped, and Jenna is elsewhere (hiding? already dead? not enough information). Wilden decided that Ali knew too much and that she was going to turn him and Jason in. He also decided that the girls knew too much. So he started the barn and the forest on fire, making sure all the girls would burn to death. Ali had gotten a note that said she had to be there in the forest that night from Wilden. Ali didn't recognize them right away because she got bonked on the head from that log and so she is momentarilly delusional or she has lost some memory. So pretty much Wilden is going to try to kill them all (:

Posted by Nicolette <3 on July 20, 2009 at 10:28 PM EDT #

nicolette- WOW all your theories make great sense. everything fits but one thing im not sure about is how you said jenna has blonde hair, she has dark hair. i really dont like to believe mona was working with jenna and ali, it just doesnt make sense. and how did the twin in the hole get ali's ring? she would have had to been dead before that. but i think alot of what you speculated is true

Posted by kel on July 20, 2009 at 11:44 PM EDT #

Hey, guys. I'm just going to throw out a quick theory. What if Olivia really is just scamming Spence? What if she isn't adopted? Perhaps, we need to look at other options. What if Spence's mom didn't NATURALLY give birth to her? As in, no drugs. It could be that, you know. Spinal tap. Or a c-section! I just thought I'd throw that out there! PLL <3 Btw, nic, amazing theories!

Posted by Av on July 21, 2009 at 01:28 AM EDT #

I MEANT 2009!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by LAN'EA on July 21, 2009 at 01:58 AM EDT #

NEW BOOK HEARTLESS COMING OUT NOVEMBER 9TH 2009!!!! NEW BOOK HEARTLESS COMING OUT NOVEMBER 9TH 2009!!!! NEW BOOK HEARTLESS COMING OUT NOVEMBER 9TH 2009!!!! NEW BOOK HEARTLESS COMING OUT NOVEMBER 9TH 2009!!!! NEW BOOK HEARTLESS COMING OUT NOVEMBER 9TH 2009!!!! NEW BOOK HEARTLESS COMING OUT NOVEMBER 9TH 2009!!!! NEW BOOK HEARTLESS COMING OUT NOVEMBER 9TH 2008!!!! NEW BOOK HEARTLESS COMING OUT NOVEMBER 9TH 2009!!!!

Posted by LAN'EA on July 21, 2009 at 02:01 AM EDT #

SARA SHEPARD SAID IT HERSELF ON TWITTER!!!!! SHE MADE AN ANNOUCEMENT TELLING ALL THE READERS WHEN THE NEXT PRETTY LITTLE LIARS BOOK #7 "HEARTLESS" CAME OUT!!! AND THATS THE DATE NOVEMBER 9TH 2009!

Posted by LAN'EA on July 21, 2009 at 02:03 AM EDT #

SARA SHEPARD SAID IT HERSELF ON TWITTER!!!!! SHE MADE AN ANNOUCEMENT TELLING ALL THE READERS WHEN THE NEXT PRETTY LITTLE LIARS BOOK #7 "HEARTLESS" CAME OUT!!! AND THATS THE DATE NOVEMBER 9TH 2009!

Posted by LAN'EA on July 21, 2009 at 02:04 AM EDT #

Okk well, i also think ali has a twin... it makes sense. the time her mom got mad and she had to change shirts? it was just her twin. and the day of them trying to steal the flag, it was really alis twin, because she said there was a felid hockey girl and a manga frog... not. there were only commets and a doodle of a well. + dude i always new that wilden had something todo with it. before mona i thought A was him... & i think that jason was in the ward... ali or her twin wasnt on the list, and jasons always kinda been weird/ had problems... so thats my theory. and nicoletteeee wowza girl you typed hella lot (: Im not too sure about ur theorys, but heey, who can be, anything in this book can happpen !

Posted by Tayleeer on July 21, 2009 at 10:43 AM EDT #

What do you guys think about Spensers "mom" and Morgan frick? A scheme from A ?

Posted by ElliBellizZzZ on July 21, 2009 at 12:26 PM EDT #

what if Ali has a twin, right? and then ALI killed her TWIN, could be sibling problems there, right? or if how jason didnt like how aria was in his house, what if Ali is still alive and she lives there, unlikely but still. and spencer is sooooo stupid. i knew they were a scam from the start...still could be her mom, but a con artist could have a daughter. i love emily and isaac!! he sounds so cute, but his mom! and since everyone loved ali, jason could've been jealous. and jason is definately bipolar.

Posted by julie on July 21, 2009 at 01:55 PM EDT #

ahah, julie. i agree they are. and d0000d, i know ! his mom was so horrible. and how he said that other girls said the same thing !? and what was up with maya, she was so sinister at the Radley. but at the same time she still acted attracted to Emily !~!

Posted by oli babehh ! on July 21, 2009 at 02:31 PM EDT #

omg i have the book but its taking me soooooooooooooooooo long read it i cant focus cuz i keep jumpin 2 the stick

Posted by lauren on July 21, 2009 at 05:07 PM EDT #

omg hey guys, i think that ali never had a twin, i know its crazy but my theory is that wen ali and jason were together in the woods that night that "supposedly" ali died jason took her somewhere to be safe. He mite have known darren wilden was up to something. jason couldve been protecting ali this whole time! and jason and darren were friends rite? so he couldve known all along and went with darrens plan along, but wasnt really? he juhs said he was so that he could find out things so he could protect ali, and since they were both gone that night darren hada chance to do something to her! but jason said he would, i know thi sounds crazy but its a possibility that could happen. so think it thru comment about my theory! thans guys(:

Posted by sofia(my theory) on July 21, 2009 at 07:09 PM EDT #

uhh, i just keep thinking that jenna is not blind ! i mean really, throughout the books it just seems, idk. i think it's a fake, i'm not for sure. & how ali came back in the 6th book, wow. i was not expecting that at all. & i think wilden is a freak, and so is jason. & kate is just... odd. and so is xavier.

Posted by luna on July 21, 2009 at 08:40 PM EDT #

ok; i havent read killer or the spoiler alerts; bt heres what i think. ali has always been alive, cause remember emily said at ali's funeral, she remembered seeing those same blue eyes she's only seen once? and now ali is blackmailing them. & theres something weird about jason, because why was he running through the woods when he gave aria the flag? i wish all of them remembered what happened that summer!

Posted by laurenn. on July 21, 2009 at 09:43 PM EDT #

IN COMPLETE SHOCK!!!!!! HERE IS MY THEORY::: i think ali is alive. i think that she was just taken somewhere by jason to for her safety from wilden, who secretly had a crush on her and was stalking her. When aria and jason where at the bar, he told her he was in love with someone and i think it was melissa. but i also think melissa had something to do with her murder/disappearence. I think Melissa and jason secretlly liked each other but i am also thinking that ali and jason had some kind of secret relationship. they both got jealous of the bfs/gfs so they ran away together! lastly, i think that it wasnt ali it was some other girl who was found dead and since wilden is a cop and can change dna or whatever. he probablly just made it look like it was ali! not really shuree thoughh. very excited for the next one hoping it comes out soon!!! love this series ready for more drama! :) p.s. maybe ali was staying at the parents home. could be why jason was wierd about her being in the main house and his room.

Posted by bri on July 21, 2009 at 09:49 PM EDT #

i think that ali was never murdered! i think she was taken away by jason for protection against wilden who has some kind of crush on her. i think she was in the family's house all along. they didnt want any news reporters around the house and jason got all freaked when aria was in the house. so maybe she was there all along.

Posted by bri on July 21, 2009 at 09:58 PM EDT #

next.... i think the body that was found in the hole was a sister of ali's or a twin or something odd like that. i thnk that if she did have a twin then she could have been secluded out of everything and no one knew about her for there own good. i think that wilden was in love with ali and was secretly stalking her. and when they found that body in the hole if it wasnt a sister he made it look like ali using some kind of switched dna. since he has the power to do that.

Posted by bri on July 21, 2009 at 10:02 PM EDT #

and lastly.. i think that jason and ali had some secret weird love relationship going on. or jason was sexually abusing ali like jenna was being abused by toby. and when ali told jenna they created this secret bond or they ended up being best friends. JENNA IS NOT BLIND... I HAVE A FEELING SHE WAS NEVER BLIND. and she is the GOOD A!!! if this girl they think is ali turns out to be her then everything that we have read in the past years would be a lie. but im pretty excited to finally find out the truth!!! cant wait for the next book. looking forward to see whats going on with the drama in the series :)

Posted by bri on July 21, 2009 at 10:09 PM EDT #

ohhhh myy goddd.. i just realizeddd!!! what kind of dog does jenna have.. just if someonee rememberrss.. telll me please!! i think i mightt knoww whats going on. cause if jenna has a rottweiler then we know who a is!!! just tell mee! :)

Posted by bri on July 21, 2009 at 10:24 PM EDT #

SPOILER ALERT!!!!: OMG!!!! i am freaking out!!! is ali really alive???? haha i think i might need 2 check into a mental hospital like jason waiting 4 book 7 2 come out!!!! i am going crazy tring to figure out who is dead then because there was a body in the hole!!! And i was like screaming OMG when they saw ali in the end!!!! i'm like " WHAT???? HOW IS SHE ALIVE SHE CAN'T BE ALIVE!!" my parent gave me a really weird look as if to say "what the heck are you screaming about??"haha well see you later! Mwah! -J

Posted by Jenna (NO JK) on July 22, 2009 at 12:40 AM EDT #

haha jenna (not me) has a golden retreiver. Wait now i'm confused...... i think it was either that or a lab. Mwah! -J

Posted by Jenna (NO JK) on July 22, 2009 at 12:41 AM EDT #

WOW! i just finished Killer and its crazy!!!! ***SPOILER ALERT!!!***** I kinda figured Alli was alive because the DNA tests didn't say it was her body in the hole, but i thought Alli was A too?? I dont think Jenna is A cuz shes blind and hellooo blind people cant really text. unless she made someone do it for her....? Anyways I kinda suspected Wilden but i had no clue about Jason! I would h8 to be Aria knowing that she might have dated a psycho path but i definitely think Melissa had something to do with it! And i wanna know whats on the Time Capsule flag??? Lol Hannas dreams about Alli talking to her are insane lol maybe shes psychic?? or maybe Alli stalks hanna and talks to her in her sleep.... FREAKY!!!I cannot WAIT till the next book theres so many unanswered questions!!! JANUARY CAN'T COME SOON ENOUGH!! =D lol

Posted by Alex on July 22, 2009 at 07:57 AM EDT #

Oh yeah and i think Alli might rele have a twin but Alli or Alli's twin was DEFINITELY stalking the girls cause they wer always seeing "shocks of blond hair" and "a hooded figure" and if Alli lived in the woods she probably just had one outfit which was a hood. and Alli's cool and all but if i saw her looking at me thru my window or at the Train Station like Aria did, i would be REALLY freaked out lol. HEY why isnt ther a "Psst we have a secret" thing at the end saying when the next book is coming out??? does that mean there is no 7th book?? NOOO !!!

Posted by Alex on July 22, 2009 at 08:05 AM EDT #

Alright so everyone...THE 7th BOOK HEARTLESS, IS COMING OUT NOVEMBER 9th 2009!!!!!!!! Thanks to LYSSA!!! for agreeing with me about Ali and Widen being secret lovers...and yes Ali did like the "bad boy" (: and Nicolette <3 enough comments for ya lolol there is A LOT!!! haha and yah Jenna has brown hair making her either Ali, who died her hair brown to cover up her identity. So ya Ian is dead! that is my theory and Melissa prob killed him and is now pretending to be him! Anyway as for Ali...? i don't no if she really is alive anymore cause there is still two more books and for the girls to discover her this early, is kinda weird! Widen is odd but not murder odd, just "knows a secret" odd. And Jason is a freak, but again, not a murder freak!!! Xoxo

Posted by Rachel G. on July 22, 2009 at 10:23 AM EDT #

omg i finished the book a few weeks ago, and it is so scandalous! spoiler alert: i don't think ali is really dead, cause they never checked if the skeleton was really her.

Posted by jasmine on July 22, 2009 at 01:50 PM EDT #

No way are Jason and Wilden guilty it's too obvious and there are two books left so it would be hard to finish the books if they know who the killers are. I think Naomi has something to do with it because she was in the picture with Ali and Jenna that A sent Emily and she used to be friends with Ali so when Ali left her and Riley to be friends with the others maybe she got mad about that or something else Aly might have done when they were still friends. Plus she was friends with Mona so....

Posted by Leslie on July 22, 2009 at 06:32 PM EDT #

ok so i think that Ali is definitely alive!!! The body in the hole could have been Ali's twin sister's body--she probably had the same ring as Ali cuz they were twins and twins have the same stuff usuallyy...!! Ali is in hiding in her family's house in Yarmouth--that's why Jason was so freaked out and worried about Aria going in there!!! Ali was probably in there somewhere!!! I think that Ali herself had mental problems and maybe she was a schizophrenic with another personality--that's why she would like space out at times!!! I agree with nicolette <3 about spencer's mom having an affair with ali's dad and getting pregnant with spencer!! That makes sense cuz A-Ali and Spencer look alike with the same blonde hair and blue eyes. (They could be sisters) B-Nana, who was Spencer's DAD'S mother, only gave money to her NATURAL-BORN grandchildren, meaning Spencer was not her real granddaughter--she was conceived with a different father (Ali's father) That's why Spencer's mom is so hostile towards her--she believes Spencer ruined her life by being born. Spencer is not adopted, she just has a different father than Melissa does, meaning Melissa and Spencer are only half-sisters, and Ali and Jason, and possibly Ali's twin, are Spencer's half-siblings also!!!!!

Posted by Emily <33 on July 23, 2009 at 11:43 AM EDT #

ok so i think that Ali is definitely alive!!! The body in the hole could have been Ali's twin sister's body--she probably had the same ring as Ali cuz they were twins and twins have the same stuff usuallyy...!! Ali is in hiding in her family's house in Yarmouth--that's why Jason was so freaked out and worried about Aria going in there!!! Ali was probably in there somewhere!!! I think that Ali herself had mental problems and maybe she was a schizophrenic with another personality--that's why she would like space out at times!!!

Posted by Emily <33 on July 23, 2009 at 11:45 AM EDT #

I also think that Spencer's mom was having an affair with Ali's dad and accidentally got pregnant with Spencer!! That makes sense cuz A-Ali and Spencer look alike with the same blonde hair and blue eyes. (They could be sisters) B-Nana, who was Spencer's DAD'S mother, only gave money to her NATURAL-BORN grandchildren, meaning Spencer was not her real granddaughter--she was conceived with a different father (Ali's father) That's why Spencer's mom is so hostile towards her--she believes Spencer ruined her life by being born. Spencer is not adopted, she just has a different father than Melissa does, meaning Melissa and Spencer are only half-sisters, and Ali and Jason, and possibly Ali's twin, are Spencer's half-siblings also!!!!!

Posted by Emily <33 on July 23, 2009 at 11:51 AM EDT #

i think dat ali staged her death and da copz was in on it...... cuz ian said da cops was ignoring something but he neva said wat........ i dont thank dat wilden and jason dit it cuz its 2 more books left and it would be hard to rite da otha 2 if dey dit do it........... i dont know dis serise is so crazzy !!!!!! i cant imagine bein des gurls !!!!!!!!!!!!! oh and i thank dat xaier or wateva is so stupid !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and i thankn dat ian a lie !!!!!!

Posted by Sh3 s0o FiiNe... <3 on July 23, 2009 at 11:58 AM EDT #

let me no wat ya'll thank bout muh thoerys ! KiiSES ! -Jasmin<3 AKA Da baddes in MiiAMii !

Posted by She s0o FiiNe... <3 on July 23, 2009 at 12:02 PM EDT #

Emily <33, Your theory can't be right, because Ali's family didn't move to Rosewood until Ali was in 3rd grade... I think that there similarities have something VERYYY important to do with the book though... I think that when she says natural that her Mom got a C-section or something... I dunno honestly. +++ Jenna is not blind, no way. Also... What does the patern on the flag have to do with anything ? that day Ali said she drew a manga frog and a feild hockey girl... but it was actually a doodle of a well and commets and shooting starsss. maybe that was Alis twin that said that ? i dont know.

Posted by Hannnnnnnnnnnah. on July 23, 2009 at 12:09 PM EDT #

Ali could be Spencer's half-sister for another reason too!!! Spencer blocked the night Ali disappeared from her mind for a long time, and also blocked out the time that Spencer's mom got mugged in the street with her and Melissa. Ali would space out and act weirdly at times, so maybe Ali did the same thing!!!! Maybe it's in the family, cuz Jason was obviously mentally unstable also!!!! Jason is probably protecting Ali and hiding her in their new house, and Wilden might be helping him and making sure that no one exposes the secret of Ali being alive, and the body in the hole someone else's with close DNA to her. (Ali's twin) As for Ian, i think that he was threatened and beaten up by Wilden in the woods, and Wilden left him for dead, which is what they saw when A told them to look in the woods. However, Ian was able to crawl away to safety, possibly to Melissa, who is also very suspicious to me.... I think the new A is Jenna, who is working with Ali cuz they were secretly always best friends. AND I DO NOT THINK JENNA IS BLIND!!! Or it could be Maya, who is angry at Emily for dumping her and dating boys. She was friends with Mona, who was the previous A--Mona spit out banana gum when she fell off Floating Man Quarry, which only Maya had from San Francisco. Spencer also saw flashes of blonde hair in Ali's old window and Maya's new window, which was probably Mona spying on the girls. She could have given Maya Ali's old diary that she had, asking her to be the new A if she couldn't.

Posted by Emily <33 on July 23, 2009 at 12:11 PM EDT #

OMG NO YOU GUYS... I THINK ALI WAS SKITZOPHRENIC ! BECAUSE SHE DIDNT REALIZE HER USED TO BE BEST FRIENDS AT THAT END... AND THE SHE GOT WHAT WAS ON HER OWN TIME CAPSULE FLAG WRONG... I THINK IT EXPLAINS ALOT... YOU GUYSS ? PLEASEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE LET ME KNOW WHAT YOU THINK ABOUT THIS THEORYY ! I WOULD LOVE YOU FOREVER (:

Posted by Tayllllllllllllller. on July 23, 2009 at 12:12 PM EDT #

As for Ian, i think that he was threatened and beaten up by Wilden in the woods, and Wilden left him for dead, which is what they saw when A told them to look in the woods. However, Ian was able to crawl away to safety, possibly to Melissa, who is also very suspicious to me.... I think the new A is Jenna, who is working with Ali cuz they were secretly always best friends. AND I DO NOT THINK JENNA IS BLIND!!! Or it could be Maya, who is angry at Emily for dumping her and dating boys. She was friends with Mona, who was the previous A--Mona spit out banana gum when she fell off Floating Man Quarry, which only Maya had from San Francisco. Spencer also saw flashes of blonde hair in Ali's old window and Maya's new window, which was probably Mona spying on the girls. She could have given Maya Ali's old diary that she had, asking her to be the new A if she couldn't.

Posted by Emily <33 on July 23, 2009 at 12:14 PM EDT #

Ohhhh yeahh Hannnnnnnah you're right but idk i think somehow Ali and Spencer are related =//// Any ideas how?? Maybe Ali's family moved away after Spencer's mom got pregnant and came back years laterr??? Ya never knoww in Rosewood!!!!

Posted by Emily <33 on July 23, 2009 at 12:20 PM EDT #

Yeaaah, possibly ! but idk... maybe they met some weird way + moved away before she was born, it could be possibleee. and i totally agree on you with the skitzophrenia, cause it adds up. i thought about that and i saw you said it in a previous post and was like OMGG YEAH ! SOMEONE AGREES ! (:

Posted by Hannnnnnnnnnnah on July 23, 2009 at 12:33 PM EDT #

Lmaooo i know!!!! =)) I seriously think that Melissa is guilty in some wayy...she acts like she knows something big all the time but never says it! For a while i thought SHE killed Ali, until the end of killer when we realize Ali is still alive. Like in unbelievable when her and Spencer are in the hot tub in Jersey and she says she knew Ali and Ian were together and says to Spencer "who said i haven't already done something to her?" Hello killer!!! and she was sizing up the hole in Ali's yard, as if she was preparing to throw someone in there!! Melissa knows somethinggggg !!!!!!

Posted by Emily <33 on July 23, 2009 at 12:38 PM EDT #

Ahahahah dude seriously. she always acted like she hated ali ause she sas reallyyyy intimidating to everyone. and i think it makes sense cause shes portrayed as a goody two shoes but in reality has alllllloot going on under the surface... and what do you thinks he was looking for when she was in the woods digging mini holes? do you think it was even her ?

Posted by Hannnnnnnnnnnah on July 23, 2009 at 12:41 PM EDT #

Bri, she has a retreiver.

Posted by you <3youhateme. on July 23, 2009 at 12:43 PM EDT #

I think that Melissa was looking for Ian's class ring that Aria found when she was cutting through the woods to get to Spencer's barn...he lost it when he was in the woods playing dead. Or maybe she was looking for something else, something no one would even suspect that only her, Ian, Wilden, and Jason know about. They were all in the same yeaar! Or maybee it was Ali searching for something in the woods behind her old house and Spencer's!! What could she be searching for??

Posted by Emily <33 on July 23, 2009 at 12:50 PM EDT #

emily <33-- wow i think that makes sense about spence ali and jason having some kind of mental problems like blocking things out, which also can show they're related. and remember ali's mom recognized spencer in the beginning of killer. and its kinda weird that they lived next door to eachother... that seems suspicious maybe they moved there so alis parents could keep an eye on spencer or something. who knows. and i also thought that melissa was involved in killing ali especially after she said "it takes a unique person to kill" or something like that.

Posted by jess on July 23, 2009 at 02:04 PM EDT #

Ok I LOVED the book!!! From book 1 I was positive that Ali was alive! I think that the figure in the woods in the 5th book who pushed Hanna down was Ali, and that Emily really did see Ali in the car after the trial. I think Ali’s parents are just hiding Ali and pretending that she died to keep her safe from people who want to hurt her. Maybe Wilden and Jason??? And the time capsule flag- maybe Jason drew the weird drawing on it. Maybe Ali really did draw a frog, but Jason tampered with the flag piece before he gave it to Aria? I have NO idea about the body in the hole though- what the heck- something is not adding up!!! As for Spencer, I do think she is related to her dad because she has the Hasting nose, and she looks similar to Melissa but I don’t think she’s related to her mom. AND I’ve noticed that her dad is always a little nicer to Spencer than her mom is. Her mom is probably just bitter towards Spencer because she is the result of Mr. Hasting’s affair

Posted by tara on July 23, 2009 at 04:09 PM EDT #

sorry the rest didnt fit! I think that Olivia might be Spencer’s real mom, but is leaving Spencer’s dad out of the story. The whole bank account thing really threw me off though. Maybe it wasn’t a scam but just New A trying to freak Spencer out. And Melissa, I don’t think she knows anything more than Ian told her. I don’t think she’s done anything horrible or even that mean. I just think she and Spencer don’t get along. What I think is Ian is living with Melissa in her town house to hide from Jason and Wilden. As for Kate I don’t think that she is entirely evil, just a little bit bitchy. I do think she kinda wants to be Hanna’s friend. Naomi and Riley are a little suspicious because they were Ali’s friends before, but I think they are really ok. I have my suspicions about Maya-I NEVER liked her! I don’t think she’s good!

Posted by tara on July 23, 2009 at 04:11 PM EDT #

and still more!!! And Jenna, I have had my doubts that she really is blind, sometimes it just seems a little sketchy that she cant see. Maybe she wears the Gucci glasses to cover up her eyes because she doesn’t want people to know her eyes are ok. I have NO idea who New A really is, but I wouldn’t bee surprised if it was Jenna. Jenna always seems to be right there when there is something weird happening…

Posted by tara on July 23, 2009 at 04:12 PM EDT #

AHHHH!!!! Whens the next book coming out?!?!?! Killer was an awesome book. The end was insane. The books before said for sure she was dead. I mean they found her body in the hole with her ring on her finger. Did they do a DNA test in one of the books? It seems like they did. But if Ali really is alive I bet it was all set up and she has gotten brainwashed by someone because at the end it said she looked at them like she didn't know who they were maybe she doesnt remember anyone in Rosswood. AHHH please tell us about the next book. I can't wait to read it. I think these books would make the best movies too. =]

Posted by Emily on July 23, 2009 at 04:12 PM EDT #

Spoiler Alert!how could Ali be alive?Maybe Wilden had the DNA results and lied to Ali's parents?Well since Ali is